L

Lord Shamash (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 10 November 2026

Debate

Courts and Tribunals Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I declare an interest as a founding partner of Edwards Duthie Shamash. We are principally a legal aid firm with a substantial commercial aspect. I have been in the legal aid business for a very long time: more decades than I care to remember. The problem we have now is that we are operating under a graduated-fee system and a fixed-fee system. Under a fixed-fee system, you can find yourself doing an awful lot more work, and you are stuck. Just before this debate started, I spoke to one of the partners, who said that you can get down, sometimes, as low as £10 an hour. The average rate, and the fixed rate, is about £60 an hour in the magistrates’ court. It is a bit higher in the Crown Court. It was mentioned that, being a lawyer, you sometimes make advocate because you want a bit more money. In this case, I would certainly welcome this amendment. One of the other points that has been touched on is recruitment. Recruitment of young lawyers to do crime is incredibly difficult. I speak from personal experience. I hope it does not reflect on my firm, but we have had adverts out for a very long time for young criminal lawyers. You are competing with the salaries that you can earn in the City: over £100,000 for a newly qualified lawyer. We cannot even begin to think about paying that sort of rate. It is very difficult, because somebody who comes to do this work has to be politically, with a small ‘p’, very committed to the work they are doing. It is extremely difficult to find the right sort of person to do that. Not least of which, these days, most students who have gone through the education process have ended up with enormous debts. Many noble Lords will be aware of this, having grandchildren or whoever who are at university ending up with considerable debts to be paid at the end of their training. So this is incredibly serious. The noble and learned Lord, Lord Thomas, asked: what are we doing with this? We are going to find ourselves very short of young criminal lawyers. We can see that ourselves. What is going to happen then? Coming back to the debate we had earlier about the number of people waiting to come to trial in a magistrates’ court, sometimes, even at the current time, the wait is two years. In the Crown Court, we have cases that are waiting to be heard in three years’ time. It is complete madness. What is going to happen? I am genuinely very concerned at the situation that we are now confronted with.

More from Lord Shamash (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.