Contribution
My Lords, I must add to the noble Baroness’s very interesting speech that Tony Blair, the last Prime Minister actively to be involved in the appointment of Church of England bishops, had a Roman Catholic adviser on faith, Francis Campbell, who later became the first Roman Catholic to be our representative at the Vatican.
The Bill reflects how far Britain has come from its historical anti-Catholic foundations. We still celebrate the Glorious Revolution of 1689 and its Bill of Rights, although we have forgotten the latter’s strongly anti-Catholic language, which states that
“it hath beene found by Experience that it is inconsistent with the Safety and Welfaire of this Protestant Kingdome to be governed by a Popish Prince or by any King or Queene marrying a Papist”.
We have also forgotten that Bonfire Night is an anti-Catholic festival.
As a Liberal, I rejoice that this country has in my lifetime become so much more tolerant of different approaches to faith or lack of faith. When I was a chorister at Westminster Abbey, we were all aware of political appointments within the Church of England, not only of bishops: one of our canons, it was whispered, had been appointed, controversially, by Ramsay MacDonald; and then of course there was the “Red Dean” of Canterbury.
I absorbed an instinctive suspicion of Roman Catholics from the children’s books I read; in particular, those of Charles Kingsley, an Anglican priest as well as a professor of history at Cambridge. The first Catholics I met, however, were the choristers of Westminster Cathedral when we played them at cricket.
In the past half-century, we have made great strides towards understanding and tolerance, not only among the different Christian denominations but towards other faiths. In 1953, the Cardinal Archbishop of Westminster preferred to watch the Coronation procession from a gallery outside Westminster Abbey, rather than directly witnessing this heretical ceremony. Fifty years later, his successor read the first lesson at a service commemorating the Coronation, with representatives of Britain’s other faiths sitting in the transept in front of him. Not long thereafter, the Pope himself visited the abbey, and one of those who welcomed him was the abbey’s first female canon.
Therefore, this short Bill marks another small step towards a more open and mutually tolerant national society. Our Prime Ministers are drawn from diverse backgrounds. The relationship between the Church of England and the state is a dynamic one, which changes as our society evolves.
My party has long been in favour of disestablishment and carried that through in Wales and Ireland. I remain an antidisestablishmentarian because, like the noble Baroness, Lady Bottomley, I see this as a national Church, involved in local communities and playing the role of a national Church in the most inclusive way that it can. It represents our Christian heritage and the values that that has embedded in our democratic life.
The relationship between politics, religion and identity is contested and complicated. As the noble Baroness, Lady Bottomley, said, Margaret Thatcher was shocked, as Prime Minister, that the Archbishop of Canterbury included a prayer for the Argentinian dead in the thanksgiving service after the Falklands War, and she later intervened to block bishops who might be as forgiving as him.
Danny Kruger, in the Commons debate on this Bill, condemned our current bishops as “left wing”, while Sir Edward Leigh accused them of spouting “woke rubbish”, but it is the responsibility of faith leaders to remind us of the values that underpin society, even when the message is uncomfortable. I first learned about political values, I think, from listening to sermons in Westminster Abbey on the social message of the Christian gospel. The current Pope, like his predecessor, reminds his flock and the political leaders whom he meets that the poor and the marginal deserve help and respect. I am sorry that some consider such a message left wing or woke.
We have not entirely lost the prejudices against outsiders and heretics that marked previous generations. Elements of antisemitism still drift around the edges of our society. Prejudices against Muslims have replaced prejudices against Catholics and Jews, and there are some politicians who are twisting the Christian faith to promote nationalist and racialist division in Britain, the United States and elsewhere. Happily, our Church of England is a broad church and works hard to be inclusive. I have sat next to the president of the Bradford Council for Mosques in Bradford Cathedral and I have listened to the choir of the Belsize Square Synagogue in Westminster Abbey at a service in which the noble Baroness, Lady Neuberger, gave the sermon.
Mutual tolerance and interfaith dialogue play an important part in holding our diverse national community together. This Bill takes us a step further in that direction by removing now archaic discrimination against Jewish and Catholic Prime Ministers. It leaves us with a set of arrangements for Church and state that are a bit eccentric and still rely on conventions and understandings to work successfully, but that is how our unwritten constitution is supposed to work.