L

Lord Marks of Henley-on-Thames (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 10 November 2026

Debate

Courts and Tribunals Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I have Amendment 33 in this final group of the day. This amendment would remove the power of the Secretary of State to amend the Sentencing Code as proposed in Clause 5(1) of the Bill to substitute periods of 6, 12, 18 or 24 months as the general limit for magistrates’ court sentences for “either way” offences, currently with 12-month limits. Amendment 35, from the noble Baroness, Lady Jones of Moulsecoomb, and the clause stand part notice from the noble and learned Lord, Lord Keen, the noble Lord, Lord Wolfson, and the noble Baroness, Lady Jones, would have the same effect. There are two broad headings for our objections to this proposal. The first is that it would hand to the Government another unacceptable Henry VIII power, giving the Secretary of State the power dramatically to increase by secondary legislation the sentencing powers of the magistrates’ courts. The use of Henry VIII powers for such a purpose is particularly egregious, because sentence lengths are concerned with the liberty of the subject and so are pre-eminently matters of policy for Parliament and not matters of implementation by Ministers. The Delegated Powers Committee expressed itself trenchantly on this issue, as it did on the issue in group 7, saying: “‘Henry VIII powers are controversial, and for good reason. Every such power, and its scope, must always be fully justified’ … we consider that the Government has failed to justify the … power in clause 5(1) and we recommend that it is removed from the Bill”. The Government seek to support the new power by reference to an alleged requirement that “adjustments to magistrates’ sentencing limits can be made swiftly where operational pressures or changes in case volumes necessitate a rebalancing of work between the magistrates’ courts and the Crown Court”. The Government referred then to responding “flexibly to fluctuations in demand, ensuring that cases are allocated to the appropriate court without the delay that would result from requiring amendment via primary legislation”. I have no wish to be flippant because this is a serious issue, but that attempt by the Government at a justification sounds more appropriate to a supermarket chain resolving its grocery distribution issues than to the impartial administration of justice where sentence lengths for individual offenders are at stake. The nature of the Government’s attempted justification of these changes demonstrates just how important it is that Parliament should retain control of these significant policy questions and that they should not be subordinated to ephemeral, practical, operational difficulties. The extent of government overreach on this issue is accentuated by the Bill providing for the negative resolution procedure only. At least Amendment 34 from the noble Baroness, Lady Goudie, would right that obvious wrong. The second area of objection to the proposal to enable sentences to be increased by Ministers by regulations is both principled and practical. The combined effect of the proposals in this Bill would be to draw criminal cases into the magistrates’ court and away from the Crown Court. That would have the effect, as we have discussed, of depriving many defendants of a right to a jury trial. Indeed, that is the Government’s stated aim, expressed as directed towards reducing the appalling Crown Court backlog. However, as I said earlier today and as has been said by others, the evidence that this would actually be achieved is thin. The backlogs in the Crown Court are stabilising as measures have been introduced to address them. As I said at Second Reading, although we can argue about the exact figures, the Criminal Bar Association’s figures show that, over the first six months of this year, the Crown Court backlog rose by less than 0.5%. In the magistrates’ court, on the other hand, the backlog in June, excluding single justice procedure cases, was up 16% in a year to about 169,000. We have heard a great deal today about the magistrates’ courts being as clogged up as they are and the difficulties that this Bill could present, because those figures are before any of the proposals in this Bill have taken effect.

More from Lord Marks of Henley-on-Thames (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.