Contribution
My Lords, I apologise for missing the first 90 seconds of the Minister’s speech, which was the time it took me to sprint from my room to the committee corridor. I am grateful to the Minister for her lengthy explanation— it has enabled me to get my breath back. As she explained, these instruments follow from the Tobacco and Vapes Act, which is an Act I supported as a long-standing member of the APPG on Smoking and Health, and which actually carried forward a policy started by the previous Conservative Government. As the Minister has said, the first SI is relatively simple. It ensures that tobacco products, which cannot be displayed in shops, are not shown to anyone who is not old enough to be sold them—that is, anyone born after 1 January 2007.
The Government recently closed a consultation on extending point of sale restrictions to nicotine products. This is actually overdue. The display of addictive vapes in plain view of children has helped to increase youth usage, and it has undermined their essential role as a primary smoking cessation aid. I was interested to see the coverage in the BMJ regarding large amounts of industry lobbying around the consultation. Of course, this is nothing new, as those of us who have worked on this issue for a long time know. This was then followed by another story about how AI bots flooded the initial consultation on the then Tobacco and Vapes Bill in 2023. Of the 118,756 responses received, 90,835—that is, 76%— were submitted by bots. The DHSC said the submissions were
“often duplicated many times and sent at high frequency from a small number of IP addresses”.
This bombardment appears to be the first documented instance of large-scale automated interference in a formal public health policy consultation. We know that the tobacco industry will often work with or through other organisations, third parties or proxies to fight regulation. For example, the C-Talk website is dedicated to independent retailers, convenience stores and high street businesses. Campaign materials on this site, relevant to the consultation exercise, appear to have been written by somebody who completed an internship at British American Tobacco. Paul Cheema, the co-founder of the site, has recently received awards and prizes sponsored by Imperial Tobacco and has also appeared in an advertisement for another tobacco company, JTI. That is a concerning relationship.
Consultations are not referendums; they are there to gather evidence, information and views. But where responses come from does matter. When it comes to tobacco, responses should be driven by public health, not commercial interests, in order to drive decision-making to protect our population from the harms done by these lethal products.
The second instrument outlines what defence is accepted for retailers when it comes to verifying age, making it clear that either physical or digital ID must be checked. While the mention of digital ID may set alarm bells ringing for some, given previous plans to mandate digital ID for workers in the UK, I actually think this is fair, ensuring that this is an option for consumers and mirrors what has already been introduced for alcohol. It makes sense that we make the identification process as seamless as possible.
These regulations are about ensuring we are ready ahead of 1 January. There will be many more to come, and we have recently seen many announcements relating to vape shops from other government departments, such as the need for planning and the removal of business rate relief. It is important that we do not encourage the sort of shops and behaviours that we are seeking to resolve, so I welcome those initiatives.
Finally, the Minister will recall the pressure, as the Bill went through, for a road map showing how smoking rates will be reduced, having some milestones and ensuring that vaping policy is a broader part of a tobacco control plan. The Government resisted this, but I would be keen to hear when the Minister winds up what type of evidence is being gathered to judge the success of the Act, alongside other government policies on tobacco and vaping.