Esther McVey

Nothing highlights the fiscal failure of this Government more starkly than the plight of Poundland. The chain’s 600 stores and 12,000 workers sit on the verge of collapse, not because customers have walked away—they have not; sales grew by 6.7% in September—but because of the Government’s unaffordable tax rises, which make it impossible to run a business that works on slim profit margins. Those that work on slim profit margins keep prices down for customers. How ironic it is that a Government who preach about helping the least well-off and helping with the cost of living are forcing those firms out of business. Business owners in my constituency are mystified by the damage that the Government have inflicted on businesses up and down the country. What I am asked by them most often is, “Do this Government not understand the harm that they are doing, or is it that they just do not care?” They have concluded that it is both. The Chief Secretary to the Treasury, the right hon. Member for Wycombe (Emma Reynolds), made sure of that when she said that employers were not working people—which, by the way, was a kick in the teeth for every employer in the country who is often at work before everyone else, and leaves work after everyone else. When the former Chancellor, the right hon. Member for Leeds West and Pudsey (Rachel Reeves), announced that she would raise business and employer-related taxes by over £50 billion by the end of the decade, she wanted money for Labour’s pet projects—benefits and net zero—and she did not care that they squeezed the life out of businesses. Labour did not care where that money came from. I asked the right hon. Lady on several occasions whether she expected the number of jobs to go up or down when she taxed them. She did not say. She did not know. She was shocked. Labour does not seem to understand that you cannot tax your way to growth and you cannot spend your way out of debt. The consequences have been job losses and, combined with day one workers’ rights, fewer opportunities. The tax rate policy hit on family businesses was hard as well.