L

Lord Patel of Bradford (Non-Afl)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 11 November 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I support the aims of all three amendments in this group. At Second Reading I raised the stark health inequalities facing people living in our coastal communities, and I thank the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, and the noble Baroness, Lady Tyler, for introducing my amendments while I was not here. I particularly thank the Minister for agreeing to meet us to discuss coastal and rural health inequalities. For clarity, when I am talking about coastal communities, I normally think of small towns of 10,000, 20,000 or 50,000 people. Collectively, we are talking about 10.4 million people, which is nearly a fifth of the population. I declare my interest as chair of the Coastal Navigators Network, a community interest company originally founded by NHS England. It brings together more than 20 coastal towns and locations to put into practice the recommendations of Sir Chris Whitty’s 2021 report, Health in Coastal Communities. Several of those areas are working to improve oral health and access to NHS dentistry through prevention, local workforce training, and community-based services. Their experience can help us understand where people are struggling to get care, and what needs to change locally. Sir Chris Whitty’s latest report, Health in Rural Areas and Small Towns, was published just last week. It highlights a national framework for improving oral health in rural and coastal areas. This has been developed by the office of the Chief Dental Officer, working together with the Coastal Navigators Network. The work is led by Jason Wong, the Chief Dental Officer for England, and his team. Our contribution has been to bring practical experience and case studies from our coastal communities. I was going to give two examples, but I will only give one, because one was about Lowestoft, which the noble Baroness, Lady Coffey, has already mentioned. The other example is Dorset, where the report says that only 35% of adults currently access NHS dental care, and no practices are accepting new adult NHS patients. In response, Health Sciences University, based in Bournemouth, and NHS Dorset are developing a proposed oral health institute, bringing together care, prevention and local workforce training. It is intended to support more than 30,000 clinical patient contacts a year. That is an amazing, potentially promising, answer, but they need the premises and facilities to deliver the care, and train the workforce. The latest business case still shows a funding gap of around £10.25 million, mostly in capital funding. Without that capital investment, there is a real risk that this work will be delayed, or that the institute will not go ahead at all. The Dorset example shows why identifying unmet need must lead to practical action. Commissioning more NHS dental care will take us only so far if the facilities to provide it are not there. We need capital investment alongside commissioning, so communities can develop services and train the people who will deliver them. The geographical problem is substantial, and perhaps the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, will talk about this. A study published in the British Dental Journal in August estimated that around 2.3 million people in England live in neighbourhoods with a centre that is more than 5 kilometres from the nearest NHS dental practice. But distance is only part of the problem. Is the practice accepting NHS patients, and can someone without a car get there? For coastal communities, transport difficulties, travel costs and a shortage of NHS appointments can put all the care out of reach. That is why I welcome Amendment 213, tabled by the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, and the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, with its emphasis on unmet need, workforce distribution and geographical inequalities. National and ICB averages must not hide communities where access is particularly poor. I also welcome the focus of Amendment 216 on practical action, including emergency access, contract reform and workforce planning. There is, however, an important question about how we identify a dental desert. Amendment 216 counts practices: excellent. The British Dental Journal measures distances from one place, a home, to a dental practice. Both are useful, but we also need to know whether those practices have any NHS appointments available, and whether people can reach them. I would welcome the Minister’s response on a couple of practical points. Will the Minister ensure that reporting shows whether people in coastal communities can actually get NHS dental appointments, and include the barriers caused by workforce shortages and difficulties with travel? Where that reporting identifies unmet need and dental deserts, how will the Government ensure that commissioning and investment follow? Will that include capital funding, where the premises and facilities are simply not there, when they are needed to provide care that is missing? Without that commitment to act, we risk describing the problem again and again, without helping people get the care that they need. More widely, will the Government use the national framework developed by the Chief Dental Officer’s team to help other rural and coastal communities facing similar problems? Finally, I would appreciate it if the Minister could ask officials to work with the Dorset partners to explore how the proposed oral health institute can move forward so we do not lose such an invaluable option.

More from Lord Patel of Bradford (Non-Afl)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.