B

Baroness Hayman (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 11 November 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I am grateful for the support for my Amendment 52 from the noble Baronesses, Lady Sheehan and Lady Ritchie of Downpatrick, and the noble Lord, Lord Crisp. I shall listen with interest to the debate on, and particularly the Minister’s response to, Amendment 248, tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Boycott, which is a very practical way forward. I did not take part in Second Reading on the Bill. Actually, I had a self-denying ordinance. I decided, having had my first involvement with the NHS in 1980, having seen so many reorganisations and, I am afraid, having become a little jaundiced about the effectiveness of those reorganisations in transforming patient care rather than changing administrative structures, that I would not say anything. My mother always said that if you cannot say something nice, do not say anything at all. However, here I am, and I am here because of the recent history of legislation on the NHS, in particular, the NHS Health and Care Act 2022. I was involved in the debate on issues relating to climate in that Bill. After cross-party pressure on the issue, the Conservative Government of the time tabled amendments which became part of the Act, and which are mirrored in Amendment 52 in my name today. They were described thus by the then Minister, the noble Baroness, Lady Penn: “They place a duty on NHS trusts, foundation trusts, ICBs and NHS England to have regard to the Government’s key ambitions on climate change and the natural environment in everything they do. This could mean preparing thousands of NHS buildings to adapt to climate impacts, protecting and enhancing biodiversity across 25 million square metres of trust estate, or decarbonising the millions of kilowatts of energy used by trusts every year”.—[Official Report, 1/3/22; col. 729.] That, of course, saves money for the trusts involved. The amendments were warmly welcomed by the then Opposition, with the noble Baroness, Lady Wheeler, saying: “I thank the Minister and welcome these government amendments in response to the key concerns raised in Committee about the crucial importance of including the NHS’s duties on climate change and working towards net-zero emissions in the Bill”.—[Official Report, 1/3/22; col. 733.] My amendments, which mirror those amendments, are trying to maintain the status quo. They are essentially Conservative in the sense that it was a Conservative Government who introduced them. Therefore, I ask the Minister to help me understand why, when NHS England’s functions transfer to the Secretary of State along with responsibilities to consider the impacts of climate change on our health services and public health and the significant role the NHS has to play in helping the UK to meet its national climate and environmental targets and to provide leadership—we saw that at COP 28 in Glasgow, with other countries’ health services actually responding—the Bill before us omits the NHSE’s statutory duty to publish guidance on what it regards as the best way for ICBs and the organisation itself to meet those duties and how it is fulfilling them, along with an established framework for reporting details of progress on reducing emissions in its annual report and accounts. There is no in-kind replacement for these requirements on the Health Secretary, meaning that without legislative change and amendments of this sort, there will be no obligation on DHSC to continue driving progress, specifically on the health service’s carbon emissions reduction work. Ministers may say that they will have powers to issue fresh guidance if they choose to, but whether it is issued and how robust its contents are will be contingent on the priorities of the Government of the day, and we have an example before us of how those can change. That outcome does not bring the same level of certainty or direction that the NHS needs to maintain regular accountability and long-term national momentum towards its targets. I hope that the Government will not try to argue that, because the Climate Change Act 2008 applies to all government departments, this amendment is unnecessary. It is clear that the powers that were put in the 2022 Act are much more specific to the NHS and the health system and essentially provide accountability and transparency. The NHS itself says that the duties supported the health service’s own ambition to become the world’s first health system to embed net zero in legislation. The 2022 Act requires commissioners and providers of NHS services specifically to address the UK net-zero emissions target and environmental targets and to adapt to any current or predicted impacts of climate change identified within the Climate Change Act 2008. We saw quite a few of those this summer and quite a few of the effects on the health service. The Bill before us does not require the Health Secretary, when making decisions about the NHS, to consider how the organisation is contributing to carbon targets, to regularly report on its performance or to prepare it for the climate risks it faces. That is what we risk losing if we do not amend the Bill. I know the Government are trying to clear provisions and responsibilities out of the way and do not want to put extra bureaucratic requirements on the NHS, but my amendment recognises this. Because it is already in the 2022 Act, it does not widen the requirements in any way. It is simply trying to restore the status of the existing duties. The need to co-ordinate and steer responses to climate change and nature loss at the national level ought not to be treated as unnecessary paperwork. These duties have been quietly working as intended in the face of rising climate challenges. NHSE appears to have been getting on with them and setting emissions reductions targets that now have a statutory basis. It reports that direct emissions were reduced by 14% in the years 2020-25 and that the NHS is on track to meet its 2032 and 2040 goals. Within the last four years, the evidence points to climate change increasingly becoming a major challenge for health and health services. The Parliamentarians’ Guide to Health and Climate Change, developed by Peers for the Planet—in which I declare a past interest—and the Wellcome Trust is insightful reading and shows why climate change is already a UK public health issue. A number of organisations, such as the Wellcome Trust and the UK Health Alliance on Climate Change, have expressed concerns that failing to replace these obligations once NHSE functions are transferred to the Secretary of State will mean that there is no obligation for Ministers to report annually on progress towards NHS net-zero commitments, to publish sustainability guidance or to account to Parliament for this work. This will leave future transparency and oversight reliant to an unacceptably large degree on ministerial discretion, and it will undermine co-ordination of national objectives. I hope the Minister will be able to tell us how, if these duties for the DHSC are not replaced, we can ensure that our national health services have appropriate regard to the challenges of climate change. I beg to move.

More from Baroness Hayman (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.