B

Baroness Kidron (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 11 November 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I will speak to Amendments 53, 171 and 289 in the name of my noble friend Lord Tarassenko, and Amendment 160 in the name of the noble Lord, Lord Clement-Jones, all of which I added my name to. I have my own amendment on NHS data as a sovereign data asset in a later group, which is remarkably poor organising on my part, but it does give the Minister two shots at saying we are right. The primary difference between the amendments in this group and those in the later group is that these amendments focus largely on the use of NHS data by companies contracted and procured to provide services to the NHS, rather than primarily on how the benefits from technology trained on NHS data are retained in the UK. However, both sets of amendments cover the key elements and, whichever approach is finally taken, determining who has access to UK health data, and on what terms, is an extremely urgent issue. During debates on the Data (Use and Access) Bill last year, I tabled an amendment on sovereign data assets, of which the NHS’s data was a key example but not the only one. At the heart of that debate, which I urge officials to look at, was a warning that has become only more urgent. The speed at which the Government are giving access to our data is swifter than the plans they have to protect its financial or societal value. We are nearly two years on and there is still no published strategy or government policy to maintain British control over valuable data assets. We do not have a clear plan for how our data or the systems that host it will be resilient to foreign interference. We do not have a clear strategy for building technological capability within the NHS for its data or ensuring that all the healthcare and economic value that comes from our data will indeed come back to the UK as a benefit. Amendment 53 offers a road map for the conditions for access to NHS contracts, with a focus on control of data, building sovereign capability for data handling and reducing the dependencies and risks from foreign firms. This is not government data; it is data held in trust for the British public and they are being poorly served. Amendment 160 looks at how contracts are awarded and ownership of the architecture that supplies services to the NHS. It singles out the way in which free or low-cost services are used to gain access, create dependency and result in vendor lock-in, which a number of noble Lords have already described well. Amendments 171 and 289 would require the Secretary of State to publish a digital sovereignty strategy for the NHS, including control of systems that host data, control over the data itself, avoiding vendor lock-in and capitalising on our data to build technological capability and commercial value. It is an exhaustive checklist, but it mirrors those issues I laid in the Data (Use and Access) Bill and the Cyber Security and Resilience Bill, and in the debate on digital sovereignty in July. It also aligns with multiple recommendations by committees of both Houses, including—I will try to say this very quickly—the Commons Science, Innovation and Technology Committee’s report, Rewiring the State; the Commons BIST Committee’s report, Investing in the UK Economy, the Joint Committee on the National Security Strategy’s report on undersea cables; and the Lords Science and Technology Committee’s inquiry into financing and scaling UK science and technology. The Lords committee also has an open inquiry on innovation in the NHS and personalised medicine. How many times do we have to make the same recommendation? This is a flashing warning light.

More from Baroness Kidron (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.