L

Lord Kamall (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 11 November 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My understanding is that it is in this group, but maybe other noble Lords can confirm. There is a slight disagreement between my noble friend’s and my understanding of that. I repeat that important point made by the noble Lord, Lord Tarassenko: the cheapest initial purchase is not necessarily best in the long term. There is also a legitimate question about whether procurement requirements have become unnecessarily complicated, which the noble Lord, Lord Austin of Dudley, calls for in his amendment, around clarity and consistency about the objectives against which procurement decisions are assessed. I turn to the wider concerns raised in this group about patient data, digital sovereignty and the security of NHS information systems. Patients need to have confidence that their data is secure and their privacy is respected. I quite often like to quote my favourite philosopher, Jimi Hendrix. I have cited this more than once. He talked about building castles made of sand that fall into the sea eventually. What we do not want is the single patient record or the federated data platform to be that castle made of sand that falls into the sea eventually because there is no confidence from patients and they want to opt out of the system. We have tabled our own amendments on the single patient record that speak directly to some of these concerns. I will return to those points when we reach that group. The crux of the matter is Palantir, what people really think about Palantir and whether it should be here. When I was the relevant Minister, I was told quite clearly by my officials that Palantir had by far the best solution to deliver the federated data platform. We should acknowledge the contribution it has made in increasing discharges, reducing discharge times, identifying and contacting patients who need to come back, making sure cancellations are reduced, and all those sorts of metrics that we want to see.

More from Lord Kamall (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.