Contribution
My Lords, I declare my interest as set out in the register of interests, in particular as chairman of Canaccord Asset Management. I congratulate our four new noble colleagues on their maiden speeches.
I will devote my remarks to a single measure in this Budget: founders’ relief, as mentioned by the noble Lord, Lord Leigh of Hurley, which is a new incentive for entrepreneurs. I also endorse the remarks made by the noble Lord, Lord Elliott of Mickle Fell, earlier in this debate.
As has been mentioned in many speeches today, the UK needs more investment. My central point is that this must start with the people who actually create businesses. The incentives that we offer founders are not just a technical footnote to this Budget; they will affect the level of future growth and are indicative of the willingness of this Government to create real incentives for entrepreneurs.
Many years ago, I left a secure, well-paid job to build a business. The prospect of a 10% tax rate at that time, if I succeeded, was an important part of that decision, and I benefited from it when I sold, so I have some experience of the decision that this relief is meant to influence. That is why I say, respectfully but with some conviction, that this measure is unlikely to deliver the purpose set out in the Budget and is a missed opportunity. Think of a software engineer at a large technology company or a marketing director at a food company—well paid and secure, but with a great business idea. What would persuade them to give that up, put their savings at risk and start something of their own? Above all, it would be a reward if it succeeded and confidence that the reward would be there. That is the test for founders’ relief.
As mentioned by the noble Lord, Lord Londesborough, the conditions to qualify are very onerous and complicated—actually too complicated for a short speech. The headlines are that a business must reach £10 million of turnover, have 15 full-time staff, and then clear a series of demanding growth tests and R&D spend requirements. HMRC can then claw back the relief years later if it disputes that R&D spend.
As a consequence of these conditions, the number of companies expected to qualify is, of course, minuscule. HMRC’s own impact note expects 600 founders across 400 businesses to qualify. Set that against the more than 300,000 new businesses created in this country every year and founders’ relief will benefit roughly one in 800 businesses. If we look at the larger investables from smaller companies in venture capital trusts, their trade body has determined that, out of 1,100 companies, only 16 would qualify. No one resigns from a good job on the strength of tests they cannot predict and a reward that may be taken back.
The Government will say that this relief is about scaling up, not starting up, but every scale-up begins as a start-up, and an incentive that founders cannot rely on will encourage neither. Let us look at how this is being financed. The Government are balancing their books by halving the lifetime limit on business asset disposal relief. By HMRC’s own estimate, 13,000 business owners will pay more tax as a result. The £1 billion raised through this will go to around 600 individual founders who may benefit from founders’ relief, so 95% of affected entrepreneurs will be worse off after this Budget.
This Government have all but abolished tax relief for start-ups. When they came to office, the potential tax saved was £100,000. It is now £30,000 and presumably heading to zero. They also reduced the tax relief on venture capital trusts from 30% to 20% in last year’s Budget. I am really not sure what message they are sending to entrepreneurs. The Red Book rather grandly calls this relief world beating, but one has only to look at the US—the world’s most successful entrepreneurial economy by far—to see a far superior scheme. Founders pay no tax at all on up to $15 million of gains, and the key test is met when the shares are issued, not years later. There is no turnover test, no headcount test and no clawback. The founder knows from the start where he stands. That is an incentive for an engineer to leave his company, as it was for me to leave mine. I ask the Minister to consider whether the Government should offer a simpler, more certain relief with far fewer restrictions to businesses started from today, on the same principle as the US model.