Contribution
My Lords, I thank the Minister for his patience in listening to this debate, and for his optimism in his opening remarks. I declare my interest as director of South Molton Street Capital.
Let us close the debate by going back to what was said at the Budget, in the light of the excellent speech made by my noble friend Lady Neville-Rolfe on the importance of growth and getting on top of the cost to the public sector, and the comments made by my noble friend Lady Moyo on getting on top of welfare spending. My noble friend Lord Balfe also spoke extremely well on that. The Minister was part of the preparation of this Budget; he appeared in it, photographed wearing a summer suit—a little distinct from the rest of the team but showing the independence of thinking that we admire in this House.
I know that the Minister also heard the Budget speech in person, because we sat together in the Gallery of the House of Commons. He heard the Chancellor say, in rather plain English, that the bill for welfare would be coming down. Very soon afterwards, perhaps worried about the problems Governments have between the saying and the doing, the Government clarified that, in this case, the cost of welfare would not be coming down. That was the position for a little while, but the very next day in the House of Commons, the Financial Secretary to the Treasury said again that the cost of welfare would be coming down with this Government. Can the Minister clarify, in his own words, how he understands the position? It is a very core position of this Budget. Where do we stand? How should we understand these statements, which are in Hansard and in the Budget?
On taxation, my noble friend Lady Neville-Rolfe reminds us that the Budget expects tax to GDP to reach 38.6%, which is an astonishingly high level, well past the level where we would expect the public sector to crowd out the private sector. But before we get to this level of taxation, tax to GDP today stands at 37%. It is extremely high but, amazingly, it is much lower than the Government were hoping for. Only two years ago, the Chancellor was hoping that we would already be at 38% tax to GDP, two years on from her first Budget. Remember, her first Budget was followed by a second Budget that had a whole bunch more tax rises in it, but we are more than 1% adrift. We are not even expected to reach 38% tax to GDP next year.
This shortfall may not sound very substantial overall, but this cost falls very heavily on millions of families in the country. Can the Minister help us understand why a shortfall is arising here? What is it about government policy and our economy that means the economy’s tax yield appears to be slowing down? The gap is very wide—much wider than the famous fiscal headroom that we talk about. Can the Minister clarify what his understanding is and whether we can take taxes much higher?
Another way of looking at the Budget—going back to the comments about complexity made by my noble friends Lord Leigh of Hurley and Lord Mackinlay of Richborough, is that it is a rather melancholy expression that we have reached a tax ceiling. At this point, the Treasury and the Government are putting in dozens of the kinds of small changes that are an absolute menace to taxpayers trying to do the right thing but a joy to tax accountants, such as my noble friend Lord Mackinlay, who likes this kind of thing.
These dozens of small changes often do not have a whole lot of benefit for the beneficiaries and often come at a great deal of cost to other people. My noble friend Lord Massey described very well the problem that has arisen in the idea that we transfer the changes in business asset disposal relief—which, as the Treasury seems to concede, would affect more than 10,000 people—to the benefit of only 600 entrepreneurs. We might think about those 600, which has always been a good number in English history, as being the 600 government entrepreneurs doing their duty for England. We hope and pray they do well for us, because a lot is riding on those hopes.
I turn to debt. As the Minister and I and many others in the Chamber heard, the Chancellor said in the Budget that he did not believe that it was appropriate that the cost of welfare would fall on taxpayers for many years to come. But the Government are adding around £300 billion to our national debt during the period of this Government, so they are, as a practical matter, adding a whole lot of debt. This matters a lot, because we are walking along a fiscal cliff edge around the public finances. The debt we add is all financed over 5%. The Debt Management Office is being very skilled: it is bringing in much more short-term debt to avoid some of the peaks in rates that have been happening and we have been exposed to. Nevertheless, all that is being financed over 5%. As the stock of debt comes up to refinancing, all that is being refinanced over 5%. These numbers are becoming very high. As we have heard from many noble Lords, the cost of interest is now weighing on the public finances.
I ask the Minister to comment directly on his observations about the cost of debt on the public finances. Can he also comment on the ongoing cost of issuing inflation-linked debt? We have done that routinely in recent years, at great expense to the public finances. For context, last month the Government issued £19 billion of debt, some of which was linked to inflation, and the Government will go back to issuing inflation-linked debt before the end of the year. It is a bet that the Government keep making against investors, and investors take the view that the country is very likely to experience inflation, as, indeed, we are.
In concluding, it is unavoidable that this was the third tax-and-spend Budget of this Government. It was more modest than the previous two, but nevertheless it is directionally the same. As my noble friend Lord Bridges said, it is not just that taxes and spend are going up; rates, inflation and debt are going up. These financial metrics may sound abstract, but they all fall on millions of families across the country who experience the economic consequences. I point out that the Government, in presenting this Budget, are trying to speak rather quietly, but they do not have a good plan to turn the situation around. They have not presented us with a plan—certainly not in the Budget, but we will hear from the Minister on that shortly. Meanwhile, families, as we have heard, are likely to experience declining disposable income, with social consequences that could be quite serious, as my noble friend Lord Patten pointed out. We have not had that for many years and we are about to experience it in our country.
In closing, I urge the Government to listen to some of the comments made by noble Peers in this very interesting debate, and to their experiences. I thank those noble Lords for speaking. I say a particular welcome to the noble Baronesses, Lady Kitching, Lady Aglionby and Lady Ussher, and the noble Lord, Lord Neri. I also remember Lord Skidelsky, who always loved to refer to Keynes. Therefore, we might give the prize for the first mention of Keynes today—there were five mentions—which goes to the noble Baroness, Lady Ussher. With that, I close for the Opposition and look forward to the words of the Minister.