Rebecca Paul

Rebecca Paul

Conservative — Reigate

Speaking in the House of Commons on 16 November 2026

Debate

Visitor Levy (England) Bill

Contribution

I will make a little progress, otherwise I will be here all night. Obviously, on my birthday, I would love to be here all night, but I am sure that everyone will want me to sit down at some point. Scotland is providing us with a cautionary tale. Why on earth is Labour so determined to repeat its mistakes? The wider economic evidence that we have is also deeply concerning. Research conducted by Oxford Economics modelled the potential consequences of a 5% visitor levy across England. It estimated that by 2030, such a levy could result in £1.8 billion less tourism spending, a £2.2 billion reduction in GDP, and almost 33,000 fewer jobs than would otherwise be supported. The levy is also expected to wipe out nearly £700 million of existing tax revenues as a result of reduced activity. Of particular interest is separate research commissioned by Haven, examining the potential impact of a visitor levy in East Lothian, a Scottish coastal area that is heavily dependent on domestic tourism. This assessment, by Lichfields, estimates that a 5% levy—6% when VAT is included—could result in about 32,000 fewer visitors every year, £19 million less visitor spending, and 190 fewer direct tourism jobs. All this involves a significant cost to the public purse: VAT on the lost visitor spend, income tax and national insurance on the lost jobs, and the cost of welfare for those who are now out of work—this adds up to millions of pounds lost. And how much do the Government expect the levy to raise every year if they go ahead? Just £1.2 million. All that effort and cost for so little, and there will likely be similar stories in many parts of England if the Bill is passed. Let me ask the Government this: what is the total cost of this levy to the Treasury when we take into account lost tax revenue, lost jobs, closed businesses and other impacts? I urge the Government to do their sums on this one before proceeding further, so that they can reassure the House about the expected net benefit or, more likely, cost, at both a regional and a national level.

More from Rebecca Paul

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.

For Rebecca Paul's full parliamentary record including voting history, expenses and all other contributions, see the Rebecca Paul report card.