Dame Caroline Dinenage

Dame Caroline Dinenage

Conservative — Gosport

Speaking in the House of Commons on 16 November 2026

Debate

Visitor Levy (England) Bill

Contribution

It is a great pleasure to follow the hon. Member for Crawley (Peter Lamb), although I find myself in the unfortunate position of not being able to agree with a single word he has just said. I am also very puzzled about this Bill and why the Government have decided to bring it forward now. It is generally accepted that Governments do not get people to do more of something by taxing it. Taxation is usually quite a persuasive way of trying to get people to do less of something, so my starting point is that I am deeply suspicious of an overnight visitor levy because it will have the unwelcome consequence of encouraging fewer overnight stays. However, on the basis that the Digital, Culture, Media and Sport Committee, which I chair, has only in the last couple of months kicked off an inquiry into the UK’s competitiveness as a global visitor destination, and what might attract people or put them off, I decided that I would approach this topic with an open mind. We have received more than 110 written submissions, we have so far held two oral evidence sessions, and we have visited Blackpool and Morecambe. It is safe to say that one issue has been raised consistently throughout all of that: the overnight visitor levy. As a Committee, our focus has been on whether the levy will make our town, cities, coast and countryside more attractive to visitors. Tourism is worth £147 billion to the UK economy—it is about 5% of our GDP—so boosting the number of inbound tourists is vital if we are serious about economic growth. Inbound tourism stimulates investment in new infrastructure, increases business competition, creates jobs and opportunity and is self-perpetuating, in that growth stimulates growth. The Government have set a sensible ambition for overseas visitor numbers to rise from 42.5 million in 2024 to 50 million by 2030, but there are major challenges in the way of that ambition. The UK is the second highest-taxed accommodation market in Europe and ranks 113th out of 119 countries for price competitiveness. That is why the Government should be worried. Domestic overnight tourism fell by 5% in 2025. That is why the Government should be worried. Most English regions outside London have not yet returned to 2019 visit volumes by inbound tourists. That is why the Government should be worried. By 2030, inbound visits to the UK are forecast to be 23% up on 2019, but that is compared with 34% in western Europe overall. The UK is losing out. That is why the Government should be worried. They must not simply add to the pressures on an already struggling hospitality sector with a visitor levy. They must not further weaken the UK’s global competitiveness in this valuable industry. I want to set out a few of the key concerns that the Select Committee has heard so far. First, there is the question of cross-Government co-ordination. A key theme of our inquiry has been that tourism is often overlooked in Whitehall. I have already explained to the House how important it is to our economy. The Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport may be responsible for tourism within Government, and it may do its best to champion the industry, but its efforts can be undermined by decisions taken in other parts of Government. The visitor levy is primarily a devolution measure led by the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government, so Ministers have to ensure that the needs of the tourism industry do not get lost in a policy designed primarily to boost mayoral powers, and that it does not become a means of propping up the coffers of cash-strapped local authorities. Secondly, there is the question of how the proceeds are used. Our evidence has stressed that any revenue raised by the levy must be genuinely and visibly additional. If we are asking tourists to cough up, they must be able to see the benefit. Their money must be used to support the visitor economy, even if that is in a wider sense, so I encourage the Minister to consider what safeguards might be needed to prevent levy proceeds simply replacing existing tourism and cultural expenditure. We have also heard that the tourism industry wants an ongoing role in how levy receipts are used. We have heard from other speakers today that that is how it is done in places such as Greater Manchester, where a number of people think it is a success, but the Government would need to strengthen the Bill to give accommodation providers and attractions a role in setting priorities, monitoring expenditure and reviewing the operation of levy schemes. Thirdly, we need to consider how the proceeds would be distributed within each area. Visitor economies do not fit neatly within strategic authority boundaries. A metro area might contain a major city alongside a rural, coastal or smaller destination, each with very different needs and very different visitor profiles. In London there is a particular question about the relationship between the Greater London Authority and individual boroughs, particularly those on the outskirts. What will prevent the proceeds from being concentrated in the metropolitan area, with no great benefit seen by those out towards the edges? Finally, there is the practical issue about camping, which we have already heard about, and in particular how the levy will impact on the festival sector. The Bill provides that where a single ticket covers accommodation and other services, the accommodation element must be calculated on a just and reasonable basis. We heard from the Secretary of State earlier that the levy will apply to camping, but the sector needs to know how a festival operator would find a way to apportion the ticket price between camping and the wider festival experience. It is unlikely to be straightforward. How should an operator value a pitch that is sold only as part of a festival ticket? At the moment it looks as if they will have to put the percentage uplift on the whole ticket, and that will be a really miserable experience for the smaller festivals that take place right across the summer in many of our constituencies. The Government need to provide clear guidance about how the accommodation element of a ticket could be calculated. Individual operators should not be left to devise their own potentially competing interpretations. As the Bill proceeds, the Select Committee will be keeping a close watch to ensure that its measures add to, and do not burden, one of this country’s most important industries. The feedback on our visit to Blackpool and Morecambe was exactly the same as what I have heard from my own constituency in places such as Gosport, Lee-on-Solent, Stubbington and Hill Head: this is a sector that is already on its knees due to the impact of rising employment and labour costs, business rates and energy and finance costs. It cannot take another blow. It is already the highest-taxed sector, and the Government need to proceed with caution.

More from Dame Caroline Dinenage

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.

For Dame Caroline Dinenage's full parliamentary record including voting history, expenses and all other contributions, see the Dame Caroline Dinenage report card.