Contribution
I am being heckled about Bettys. It would of course be remiss of me not to mention Bettys. We have one of the world’s largest crime writing festivals, and it is clear to see why so many people want to come to Harrogate. Next door in Knaresborough, we have the world famous Knaresborough bed race and FEVA—the festival of visual arts and entertainment. The local area is quite often called the jewel in the crown of North Yorkshire, and understanding what makes it so special is key.
I have engaged extensively with local business on this matter. For two years in a row, I have run a post-Budget business breakfast with the hospitality sector, and over the summer I held a hospitality roundtable. Those involved say that they agree with the principle of a visitor levy, but they struggle with the idea that a far-off, distant mayor from York and North Yorkshire will get his hands on their money. As we have heard from so many Members, we need that money to be ringfenced for local priorities. The idea that Harrogate would once again be used as a cash cow to pump money and investment into other areas and for the pet projects of a mayor—he was only elected, on a turnout of under 30%, with 35% of the vote—is jarring for a lot of people.
This really matters because that same mayor has said in the local press today that he is not content with the potential of a tourism tax, which he has said he wants to levy, and is now talking about a transport levy. It would be yet another tax on working people and anyone who comes to Harrogate and Knaresborough, or to North Yorkshire more broadly.
That brings me to the Secretary of State’s point about how the visitor levy could be used to invest in transport. If we will already be getting that money through a transport levy, that prompts the question: where will it really go? It feels to me as though this is just another way for the Labour Government to tax people yet again, and that simply will not do.
For me, when we talk about what investment we need to facilitate, embolden and empower Harrogate’s tourism offer, we need the dualling of the line between Knaresborough and York, and investment in our pothole-riddled roads, particularly at a time when the Mayor of York and North Yorkshire has cut North Yorkshire’s funding and allocation for road repairs for potholes. That really prompts the question of whether we are going to end up worse off if this levy comes in. I know that local authority leaders can object and recommend, but the final say remains with the mayor alone. That is not devolution; it is a bit of a con, quite frankly.
We have not seen any impact assessments or justice impact assessments. Time and again, we hear Ministers and others who support the Bill compare it to similar schemes in France, Italy, Spain and across the world. In France, a hotel that accidentally or deliberately evades the tourist tax gets a fine. In Spain, people only get a jail sentence if it is over €120,000. In Italy, where they used to lock people up for dodging the tourist tax, it has been changed to just a fine.
I strongly suggest to the Minister that if the Government seriously want to start giving out maximum sentences of 14 years for the evasion of this tax, they should publish the justice impact test to say what the consequences will be for the justice system, the court system and prison places. That is the bare minimum we should expect if this is a serious and credible punitive measure that they wish to hand out to those who evade the levy. That is not to say that people should be allowed to get off scot-free—absolutely not—but it is about proportionality. Anyone who is watching this debate or reading it will think that locking up Mrs McGinn who runs a B&B in Scarborough might be a little bit much.
The other issue that has been mentioned time and again throughout the debate is that any authority would have to bring forward those same impact assessments—something the Government themselves have not done. It slaps of arrogance and ignorance, frankly, that they do not want to do the sums. They probably know that they do not add up and that the levy does not support bringing tourists to an area. We have heard time and again that the hospitality sector across the board needs a VAT cut, not a new tax. This tax would be levied before VAT, compounding the payment that would be due.
It is really frustrating that something the local business community in Harrogate actually wants on their terms will end up being something that will happen to them, rather than with them. That is why, having weighted it all up, I think that the Bill as it stands is simply not up to scratch.