Helen Whately

Helen Whately

Conservative — Faversham and Mid Kent

Speaking in the House of Commons on 17 November 2026

Debate

Milburn Review: Final Report

Contribution

I thank the Secretary of State for advance sight of his statement. I am pleased to say that, as I read Alan Milburn’s report, I found plenty that I could wholeheartedly agree with. Indeed, much of it was strangely familiar, because it makes the same arguments that we Conservatives have been making for months. The review sets out how the Government have treated employers as if they were the problem: hiking the jobs tax, piling red tape on businesses and destroying opportunities for young people, because companies simply cannot afford to take them on. The review implores the Government “not to increase the costs on employers of hiring young people still further.” Why does today’s statement so conspicuously ignore this message from the Government’s own adviser? Will the Secretary of State finally concede that his Government’s policies have been killing jobs for the same young people they say they want to help? It was refreshing to see Alan Milburn, as a former Labour Health Secretary, call for substantial reforms to sickness benefits, an end to the fit-notes farce and a shift from cash to support for people with mild mental health conditions. [Interruption.] Labour Members do not want to hear it, but I am so glad that our policy announcements have helped Alan Milburn so much with his report. It must be painful for the Government to see their own landmark review trash their economic policies and then recommend our plan to reform disability benefits. Does the Welfare Secretary still think these are “crude cuts”, or has he now seen the light? How will he square these proposals with the Timms review, due out next week? I hear that it will recommend precisely the opposite. Mr Milburn is a savvy politician. He knows that his most important audience are the Labour Back Benchers opposite me, who want to raise taxes to pay more in benefits. It is no wonder that the lion’s share of what this review recommends is a massive spending plan and a massive expansion of the role of Government. It recommends spending almost £6 billion of taxpayers’ money on thousands of Government-subsidised work placements to compensate for the real jobs that Labour policies have destroyed—not less Government, but more. The Government will keep on raking in their jobs tax from businesses with one hand, and give back some of that tax in subsidies for made-up jobs with the other. Does the Secretary of State see the absurdity of that? Over the past few weeks, the country has been forced to watch this Government’s farcical pantomime—“Will they? Won’t they?”—on welfare savings. This report, to its credit, finds savings of £3.6 billion, albeit in 10 years’ time, but the Secretary of State’s statement made no mention of savings—not a peep. Why not? Is he too worried that he will suffer the same fate as the last Welfare Secretary, who tried to make savings only to lose her job? All we heard in his statement was more spending, and no wonder the Government waited until the Budget was out of the way. For a year we have been told that we must wait for this review, and now the Secretary of State has questions to answer. He has praised Alan Milburn for his hard work, and Milburn has been clear that he wants to implement his review. Will he be given the job? Will the Government learn the lessons of their own review, and get off the necks of businesses so that they can afford to give young people real jobs again? Although the Secretary of State made no mention of savings, will he be taking forward the cuts to sickness benefits proposed by Alan Milburn, or will he and the Prime Minister turn tail at the first sign of trouble? This statement seems true to form: cherry-picking the big spending ideas that they like and quietly ignoring the savings their welfare-loving Back Benchers cannot stomach, or sticking their fingers in their ears and deciding the solution is more Government, more taxes and more welfare, leaving their lost generation to pay the price.

More from Helen Whately

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.

For Helen Whately's full parliamentary record including voting history, expenses and all other contributions, see the Helen Whately report card.