Max Wilkinson

Max Wilkinson

Liberal Democrat — Cheltenham

Speaking in the House of Commons on 17 November 2026

Debate

Immigration and Asylum Bill

Contribution

I thank the hon. Member for his intervention. I wonder whether he is implying that the Reform party might be going soft on immigration, crime and law and order at the same time? Who knows? It is a good point, well made. I too was surprised to see that among the new clauses. The Conservative party and Reform told us that Brexit would let the UK take back control of borders, but the reality is that being outside the EU is a huge factor driving this crisis. According to research by the Oxford Migration Observatory, asylum seekers themselves tell interviewers that they are heading to the UK because we no longer have agreements with the EU. Those whose claims have failed in EU countries know that the UK offers a second bite at the cherry. We have become the de facto court of final appeal for every asylum seeker whose claim has failed in the European Union. Without access to the EU’s Eurodac database, we have no idea who they are or whether they have already been refused asylum by our neighbours and on what grounds. Without a watertight EU-wide agreement, we cannot hope to reassert control. The shadow Home Secretary knows this better than anyone, because a leaked audio recording has him admitting that, just before the end of the transition period in December 2020, the then Government realised that Brexit meant losing the Dublin agreement and that they could no longer, in his words, “rely on sending people back to the place where they first claimed asylum”. That is why the Liberal Democrats are calling for Members to back new clause 18, which would see the UK join the EU’s new migration and asylum pact. I have a sneaking suspicion that Labour MPs know this makes sense and, based on his comments, so does the Prime Minister. It is just a shame that the Home Secretary is lagging behind. Joining the pact would remove the incentive to come here. Indeed, under the rules of the pact, asylum seekers are obliged to seek help in the first country they arrive in and are safely processed onward. The Government are reportedly already negotiating access to the biometric database as part of the UK-EU reset. Why not just cut out the middleman and join the pact instead? It would be cheaper than the series of deals the Government are negotiating, and it would likely reduce the number of asylum seekers arriving. This is the only reasonable proposal for tackling small boat crossings. If Ministers will not countenance joining the pact, they should surely at least be able to support new clause 20, which simply asks for an assessment of Brexit’s impacts on migration—something that the Prime Minister has already started his big discussion about. On the topic of monitoring, why can Ministers not support an independent assessment of the economic impact of changes to earned settlement, as recommended in our new clause 21? On the point about impacts, may I briefly speak to the new clause tabled in the name of my hon. Friend the Member for Harrogate and Knaresborough (Tom Gordon)? When the Prime Minister arrived in Downing Street, he pledged to end homelessness. That is a laudable aim that everyone in this House would agree with, but sadly it is obvious that the measures in this Bill risk increasing the number of homeless people on our streets. New clause 6 seeks to unpick this problem. Other new clauses before us today arrive from the Conservative party and include even more extreme limits on grants of ILR than those put forward by the Home Secretary. Following on from the intervention by my hon. Friend the Member for Sutton and Cheam (Luke Taylor), Hongkongers in this country will wonder whether the Conservative party has decided they are no longer welcome here, because that is what the Tory amendments today suggest. If their intention is not to tell British national overseas visa holders that they are unwelcome, why not name them in the amendments specifically? What is required is a fair system that aligns grants of ILR for refugees broadly with the time periods set in the rest of the immigration system. A period of 20 or even 30 years with reviews every two and a half years is clearly going to harm efforts to integrate, and applying this retrospectively is clearly unfair and un-British. On a related note, it is now long forgotten, but the Leader of the Opposition once said that she did not believe in the retrospective application of the rules as a point of principle. We are left today to wonder whatever happened to the Conservative party’s principles. The Government’s proposals move the goalposts and the Conservative amendments are fundamentally unfair. Blanket retroactive changes violate fundamental British values and risk damaging our economy and social fabric.

More from Max Wilkinson

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.

For Max Wilkinson's full parliamentary record including voting history, expenses and all other contributions, see the Max Wilkinson report card.