Contribution
I draw hon. Members’ attention to my entry in the Register of Members’ Financial Interests, which includes the support provided to my office by the RAMP—Refugee, Asylum and Migration Policy—Project. I thank the Minister and her colleagues for their engagement with me on part 1, which is where I focus my remarks, particularly in relation to amendments 55 to 59 and 66, tabled by my right hon. Friend the Member for Hayes and Harlington (John McDonnell).
In Bill Committee, the Minister stated that the Government’s intention is to deliver a swift and fair decision-making body. I completely agree with that. Long, drawn-out appeals serve no one, and nor does poor-quality initial decision making. Many of us made that point on Second Reading. With nearly 40% of asylum appeals granted in the first quarter of this year and many more withdrawn, there is still some way to go, and it is the initial decision-making quality that most directly affects the appeals backlog. The appeals backlog is, of course, unenviable, but it is not clear that it is a permanent crisis. The Government have been successful in boosting judicial capacity in the first-tier tribunal, and the most recent tribunal statistics show receipts down and disposals up 30% on the same period last year. That should be celebrated. Before we go down the IIAA route, will the Minister produce an updated impact assessment that confirms whether the new appeals body will do a better job than the existing system, properly resourced, in clearing the backlog?
If the proposed new appeal body is established, ensuring its independence, competence and fairness is paramount. Several amendments have been tabled in this vein. I welcome the introduction of an access to legal representation provision in clause 12. That is an area that the Justice Committee has recently investigated. Amendments 56 to 58, which I support, would strengthen that clause. The objective must be that everybody served with an appealable decision gets legal advice and representation, so will the Minister guarantee that that will be secured? That would be quicker in the long run. In her statement in November, I think the Home Secretary accepted that early legal advice was key to enabling all claims to be advanced in one go, which saves time in the long run.
Let me dwell a bit longer on competence, which is addressed in amendments 55, 59 and 66. We are talking about individuals who are affected by often traumatising situations: people fleeing conflict and persecution, and people who may have been trafficked and be at risk of modern slavery. Appeal decisions are not only highly consequential, but hugely complex, requiring an in-depth understanding of the law and how it is applied. This extract from Lord Justice Underhill, in a case called Khan from the Court of Appeal in 2017, helps us to understand the complexity of the law that we are dealing with:
“I have great sympathy for applicants trying to find their way through the maze of immigration and asylum procedure (quite apart from the shameful complexities of the substantive law)”.
That makes good this truth: even a simple factual case will involve the application of complex law. That is why rigorous training will be required, and why minimum knowledge standards should be stated in the Bill. It makes no sense that, to represent an asylum seeker at appeal, someone must have passed a rigorous knowledge assessment, as they have to do under the Immigration and Asylum Act 1999, while there is no minimum requirement for the person deciding the case to have any immigration knowledge at all.
It seems that supervision by legally qualified senior adjudicators of executive adjudicators will be a key feature of the system, but the senior adjudicators, who do have to be legally qualified, will, on the current wording, have far less experience than anyone working in a supervisory capacity elsewhere in the legal profession. For example, the Bar Standards Board normally requires a qualified person guiding a junior barrister to have practised for at least six of the preceding eight years. I would welcome clarification from the Minister as to how it is proposed that the senior and executive adjudicators will work together. For example, will the guidance given by the senior to the executive be disclosed to the parties? How will the parties know that the executive has gone off and sought advice? Why does the Home Office feel that two adjudicators working together will be a quicker and cheaper way of deciding appeals than a single, legally qualified adjudicator doing it themselves?
The key thing to avoid is pushing the backlog from the current appeals body into the upper tribunal, which is a real risk if we do not get this right. In its observations, the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees has highlighted that Australia, which moved to a lay adjudication model, has now reverted back to a body that places renewed emphasis on legal qualifications and expertise, so I stress the importance of ensuring that we have a minimum knowledge standard in the Bill.