Contribution
I wish to speak in favour of new clauses 1 and 2, which stand in my name. Both concern basic Government accountability—demonstrating that any proposed large asylum accommodation site is suitable, and explaining what the site will cost the taxpayer. Ministers justify moving to large sites on the grounds that they will reduce both the cost of hotels and the pressures their use creates in communities. The Government must demonstrate that their chosen approach will address those problems, because decisions taken in Whitehall have lasting consequences for the communities that are expected to accommodate these sites, and those communities deserve to see the evidence behind those decisions.
The experience of my constituents in Bicester and its surrounding villages is that the Government have not provided this information for their proposed asylum centre at MOD Bicester. They have delayed publication, chosen an urgent planning route that reduces scrutiny, and cited vague security and commercial concerns as grounds not to publish key information or to redact it. New clause 1 would require a published suitability assessment before a site accommodates 300 or more people, including consultation with the relevant local authorities—something that did not happen in my constituency’s case. That assessment would cover accessibility, public services, infrastructure, environmental constraints and the impact on the surrounding community.
MOD Bicester demonstrates why that is necessary, because even after a planning application, fundamental questions remain about transport, utilities, local services and the practical implications of developing the site. Cherwell district council’s objection to the planning proposal identified insufficient information across those areas. There is no supply of electricity, water, or sewage removal to a site that has never had accommodation before; there is, however, a Ministry of Defence training site still used as part of the £100 million bomb disposal training facility at MOD Bicester.
As a result of the Government’s not providing that information, an incredible army of local volunteers has devoted hours to examining the application, working through redacted documents and identifying gaps. Those volunteers have brought information to light that was not previously public, showing that Ministers have not fully considered the implications of this proposal. New clause 1 would require Ministers to explain publicly why they consider a site suitable—if the evidence supports their decision, they should be willing to publish it.
New clause 2 would require publication of the expected acquisition, construction, annual running and total costs before a site opens, alongside comparisons with alternatives and the assumptions behind the figures. Material changes before opening would require an updated assessment. The Government’s estimates of nightly costs are very inaccurate. Yesterday, in response to an urgent question I posed, the Minister claimed that large-scale asylum centres would be cheaper than hotels. However, due to the huge set-up costs associated with MOD Bicester, the Wrong Plan Wrong Site group estimates that the cost per bed per night will be nearly £235, fully £100 more than the cost at some other sites and over 60% higher than occupying similar hotel beds.
It is especially important to see the Government’s statement of total expenditure, because the Home Office has a frankly terrible record of managing the cost of large asylum sites. It wasted £60 million on the Scampton site before abandoning it in 2024. Back in 2005, it wasted £28 million at the site at MOD Bicester, before rightly abandoning those plans. In March 2024, the National Audit Office reported that four large sites were forecast to cost £46 million more than hotels and fully £140 million more than the original estimate.
The hon. Member for Stoke-on-Trent Central (Gareth Snell), along with other Members, rightly criticised the Government for not informing his local authority before the opening of asylum accommodation, so I regret very much that Ministers and Labour MPs have so far refused to support my two amendments. New clauses 1 and 2 would establish straightforward requirements: to publish the suitability assessment, to publish the full expected costs and to explain the assumptions. My constituents and those in other constituencies where large-scale asylum sites are proposed deserve answers about the consequences for their communities, and taxpayers deserve evidence that their money will be spent wisely. If Ministers are confident in these proposals, they should support the scrutiny needed to demonstrate that that confidence is justified.