Contribution
I voted against this Bill on Second Reading, and everything that has happened since has strengthened my opposition, both to what is in it and to the ill-advised speed at which it has been pushed through. I welcomed the Home Secretary’s decision to keep the five-year route to settlement for care workers, who came here in good faith on a promise, but if it is wrong to change the rules halfway through for care workers, why is it right to do so for everyone else who came here on the same understanding?
For almost everyone earning under £50,000, the wait for indefinite leave to remain will double from five years to 10, but someone earning over £125,000 will wait only three years. Settlement is not being earned; it is being bought and flogged to the highest bidder. I am old enough to remember the global pandemic, when low-paid workers were essential. Refugees will now wait 20 years, or thirty if they arrived by small boat. That punishes people for how they were forced to flee, which is exactly what the refugee convention was designed to stop. These changes will hit people who are already here and who are part of our communities, and we will not even have a full impact assessment until after the policy has been implemented, when it will be too late to stop it. That is why I am pleased to support new clause 62, in the name of my hon. Friend the Member for Poole (Neil Duncan-Jordan).
Nowhere is the injustice of wealth deciding someone’s status clearer than in the case of the children I discuss in my new clause 56. It would make sure that children pay only what it actually costs the Home Office to process their applications, not the inflated fee charged now, and it would make registration free for children born here. Their parents are living here legally, and these children are not migrants but are being treated as if they were. The law recognises that, and many of them have British birth certificates. This country is the only home they have ever known. They already have the legal right to be British, and we are simply charging them £1,000 for a right that the law says they already have. Neither these children nor their parents are what anyone in this House would call “illegal migrants”, and Members of different parties agree on that. Even the last Conservative Government agreed. They implemented a fee waiver and an end to the charge for looked-after children.
Just a few years ago, wards of the state were being charged full price to register as British citizens, as my hon. Friend the Member for Reading West and Mid Berkshire (Olivia Bailey) mentioned. The fee waiver that was put in place is not working, as at one point more than half the people applying for it were being rejected. The Supreme Court has said that the level of the fee is a matter for Parliament. We are Parliament, and that decision is ours. The Conservatives accepted that these children are not migrants and should not be held back. The Liberal Democrats, the Greens, Your Party, Plaid Cymru, the SDLP and the SNP have gone further, and in the nearly seven years in which I have been arguing for the provisions in new clause 56, they have lent their signatures to the idea that the fee should be scrapped or cut to cost. Labour backed this in opposition and assured me that it would be resolved in government, so why am I still saying the same thing nearly seven years later?
I withdrew the last amendment I tabled, because the Government assured me that they would fix this issue. Well, fool me once, because nothing has changed. I am back again, and I will keep coming back until someone with the power to change something actually does so. Are we so obsessed with proving how tough we are on migrants that we are willing to put at risk the safety and future of children who we all agree are not migrants? Did we learn anything from the Windrush scandal? Are we not ashamed? I am ashamed of us.
With so much in this Bill to object to, I had hoped that we could at least get one thing done on which we generally agree. I say again that these children are not migrants; they are British. The law says so, and we across this House say so. I have one question for the Minister when she responds: when will this Government keep their word, and fix it so that we are not pricing children out of their citizenship rights?