Siân Berry

Siân Berry

Green Party — Brighton Pavilion

Speaking in the House of Commons on 17 November 2026

Debate

Immigration and Asylum Bill

Contribution

The Bill will do so much harm to people who have faced torture or political oppression, who feared for their lives in war and who need their human right to leave their country and be given asylum to be fully respected. It will do harm to children and families, whose family life human rights will be eroded, and to victims and survivors of abuse, violence and exploitation. Justice will be curtailed under the Bill, processes will be made more discriminatory and unfair, and the tax on successful refugees will push people who are trying to build a new life into desperate poverty. It will not bring communities together, but will further divide them. The shadow Minister was right to note that Green Members oppose the Bill, and we will continue to do so. The amendments that I will talk about relate to the refugee tax—the payment proposals in part 4 of the Bill. Amendment 1 to clause 28 changes the words “without becoming destitute” in the requirements for regulations to prevent harm being done by demanding payments from refugees who have needed support while claiming asylum, instead ensuring that we prevent them or their households from becoming impoverished. Without that amendment, the Bill will push into ongoing poverty people who have successfully claimed asylum and are just trying to rebuild their shattered lives. Amendment 2 to the same clause would extend exemptions from the refugee tax to victims of modern slavery, survivors of sexual or gender-based violence or domestic abuse, as well as survivors of torture. Support organisations point out that the Government’s violence against women and girls strategy says of survivors: “financial insecurity should never force them back to an abusive partner.” Yet, without the amendment, the Bill risks doing exactly that. Why not give people the right to work to support themselves while they are waiting for Government decisions, which are taking too long and are wrong in far too many cases? I have tabled several other amendments and, as I argued in Committee, I want all of part 1, which creates the appeals authority and reduces access to justice, removed and clause 41 struck out completely, because it cruelly seeks to doubt the testimony of survivors of modern slavery who already face so many barriers to speaking up. I have also tabled new clauses 16 and 17 to remove the current uses of artificial intelligence from Home Office systems for summarising asylum information and to prevent its use in any part of decision making in future. I do not need lots of time, because I spent hours in Committee arguing against the cruelty, discrimination and neglect of our international duties in the Bill, which the Government have continued to ignore. The new Prime Minister has pressed on with the Bill, proposed under the previous Administration, which plays into the hands of the far right’s narratives, instead of doing what is right, standing up for the right to asylum and making sure our processes are without errors, fair, efficient and just. A hostile environment, a tax on rights and the enforced disbelief of people’s experiences will not stop the boats, but will create more harm and more opportunities for criminals. I hope we can amend some humanity back into the Bill and if not, we should vote it down.

More from Siân Berry

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.

For Siân Berry's full parliamentary record including voting history, expenses and all other contributions, see the Siân Berry report card.