Chris Murray

Chris Murray

Labour — Edinburgh East and Musselburgh

Speaking in the House of Commons on 17 November 2026

Debate

Immigration and Asylum Bill

Contribution

I draw hon. Members’ attention to my entry of the Register of Members’ Financial Interests, as I am a board member of the Human Trafficking Foundation. I am pleased to see some strong and robust measures in the Bill, which, after 15 years working on immigration policy, I think will make a tangible difference. First, I strongly welcome the creation of safe routes. We are not living in the world of 70 years ago. With mass international travel, successive global conflicts and migration pressures, a combination of safe routes and core protection is a good balance if we want to preserve and reform a refugee system so that it survives. I completely condemn the comments of the hon. Member for Runcorn and Helsby (Sarah Pochin) in her vile characterisation of the immigration system, but I also strongly believe that we cannot say that any reform of immigration is somehow a drift to the far right. We must keep reforming the system so that it is manageable in the future. I am pleased that some of the concerns I set out on Second Reading are addressed in the clauses on the reform of the appeals process, particularly measures on prioritising public interest cases and expanding or contracting the system dynamically. That will make the system effective while addressing the concerns of the public, whose trust has been eroded by the legacy system. As always with immigration policy, the issue is not just the principles, but state capacity—that is, can the Home Office adequately grip the system? That brings me to the issue of asylum costs. I agree that refugees should contribute if they are able to pay, but the structural and systemic flaw in the costs of asylum lies in the asylum accommodation contracts. The Prime Minister has spoken passionately and powerfully about the impact of decades of centralisation and privatisation, the outsourcing state and HMO Britain. I absolutely agree, and nowhere is that more pertinent than the asylum accommodation system. I have been sounding the alarm on this for two years and have been approached by multiple people speaking privately about egregious failures—allegations of data manipulated to mislead the Government, failure of the Government to conduct basic audits, glaring flaws in supply chain oversight and an extraordinarily opaque network of interconnected companies and directorships allowing individuals based in tax havens to extract substantial sums of public money while our poorest communities bear the consequences. On top of that, there are safeguarding failures. It is a scam and it is wrong. I want to be clear that I welcome the Government’s progress and many of the Bill’s measures, alongside a reduction in small boat crossings and hotel use, faster decisions, increasing returns and upstream work with our international partners. These are practical, substantial measures in contrast with the gimmicks and, frankly, ridiculous moves of the last Government. But I say to Ministers that we will not radically restore public confidence unless we grip these contracts at the heart of the system. I hope the Minister can reassure the House that the pilots proposed last year are continuing and that they do not require primary legislation to have an impact on the system. While I wait for that, and I assure the Minister that I will keep asking, I strongly welcome the measures in the Bill.

More from Chris Murray

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.

For Chris Murray's full parliamentary record including voting history, expenses and all other contributions, see the Chris Murray report card.