Contribution
My Lords, we support both these SIs. Permitting the broadcasting of court proceedings has always been a Liberal Democrat policy, since well before any such broadcasting was the policy of the Government or even the Official Opposition. We have also been active in pursuing the provision of free court transcripts to members of the public who need them, and we have had considerable success in securing amendments to a number of Bills to that effect, notably to the Sentencing Act passed this year.
The basis of the justification for court broadcasting is, of course, open justice and transparency, as the Minister has mentioned. Justice done in the open, in public, is likely to be better justice, less likely to be abused by the state and more powerful than justice behind closed doors. That is why our courts have always permitted the public to enter courtrooms unless there is good reason to exclude them on justified privacy or security grounds. Once we allow the public to enter courtrooms physically, what justification is there for excluding broadcasters which will broadcast their proceedings to the public at large?
We have proceeded slowly and cautiously. The noble Lord has given some of the history: pilots at the Court of Appeal in 2004; then the Supreme Court, in a remarkable break with tradition, allowed general broadcasting from its inception in 2009. The Court of Appeal followed with further broadcasting in 2013. Crown Court sentencing remarks could first be legally broadcast in 2020 and, in 2022, the first remarks were actually broadcast; those were the sentencing remarks of Judge Sarah Munro from the Old Bailey in July of that year.
The magistrates’ court order made under the Crime and Courts Act 2013 is to be made at a time when it appears likely that magistrates will be hearing more, and possibly more serious, cases if the Government succeed in passing the more controversial provisions of the Courts and Tribunals Bill currently in Committee in this House. However, this order is very narrow in scope, and we would prefer it to be far broader. It covers, as the Minister has said, only the sentencing remarks of the Chief Magistrate, who is the senior district judge, designated by the King under Section 23(a) of the Courts Act, who is, of course, paid, rather than a lay magistrate. Only then is recording of his or her sentencing remarks allowed on such terms as the Chief Magistrate might direct on a case-by-case basis.
Can the Minister explain why only the Chief Magistrate, a single representative of the professional magistracy, almost invariably sitting in London, although he is entitled to sit elsewhere, will be open to broadcasting in this way, subject to such restrictions as he may impose, rather than allowing a more general broadcasting of the magistrates’ courts, not necessarily only by professional magistrates but by lay magistrates as well, subject to conditions that they might wish to impose or have imposed? For instance, they must be willing to be broadcast before that happens.
The second order, made under the Crime and Courts Act 2013, enables the broadcasting of submissions, exchanges with the judge and judgment given in open court before a High Court judge or a Court of Appeal judge sitting in the Administrative Court, which is part of the King’s Bench Division, with the permission of that court and on such conditions as the court might impose on the broadcast. Live witness evidence is excluded for the protection of witnesses. That is not a severe restriction, because oral evidence is rare in the Administrative Court, which is primarily concerned with considering and determining the legality of decisions of public and official bodies, and almost all the evidence is on paper. This is the widest of the improvements that we will secure by these orders. It is important, because the decisions of the Administrative Court are important, and public understanding often is also important, so it is particularly welcome.
The second order also extends permitted broadcasting of Court of Appeal proceedings, permitting submissions and argument as well as the giving of judgment. Significantly, as the noble Lord has mentioned, there is no exclusion for the submissions of unrepresented parties, nor is there in the provisions relating to the Administrative Court. Litigants in person will have the right to be broadcast in those two courts on the same terms as represented litigants. An unintended consequence of that may be that the public will see in action in these circumstances how being unrepresented affects cases. That may turn out to be beneficial in the long term, particularly when there is much public concern about the increase in the numbers of unrepresented defendants and increasing consciousness of the disadvantages to which they are placed.
These orders are welcome but they are, frankly, timid. A lot will depend in their effect on the conditions imposed by the courts on the broadcasting that they permit. The magistrates’ courts order is far too restricted in being limited to the Chief Magistrate, who generally sits in Westminster Magistrates’ Court in Marylebone. I am not sure how often he strays elsewhere, but it is not very often. Therefore, geographically, which is important, and in the range of cases covered, members of the public will not have the chance to witness justice being done in their name, particularly in the magistrates’ courts. We hope therefore that these minor steps, for minor they are, will be followed by further and, I hope, rather faster enlargement of the range of broadcasting proceedings. Our aim must always be to make open and transparent justice more of a reality.