Contribution
My right hon. Friend is spot on. Let me say to the House gently that none of this is a walk in the park. It is complicated. When I was in government I had a different portfolio, but I know about trade and have seen what has happened to my local farmers. Wicks Manor produces great pork products that it sends not just to EU countries but across the world, as far away as the United Arab Emirates and Indo-Pacific countries. It will be asking what this agreement means for those relationships. I want to press the Minister on that.
Will the Minister, in her closing remarks, commit herself to providing the full funding model and the assumptions of the costs and benefits that underpin the figure the Government have given, namely an economic uplift of 0.4% of GDP over the long term, including the definition of “the long term”? Will she say what primary and secondary legislation the Government will be introducing as part of their renegotiation and this deal?
As for the economic factors, inflation has been a fundamental challenge for this country in recent years. That is obviously due to the Ukraine conflict, energy prices and life post-covid, but we should also reflect that it has been exactly the same for the rest of Europe. Our levels of inflation are not higher than those in the rest of Europe. Claims that rejoining the EU or giving more powers to Brussels would lead to lower prices are therefore not accurate, which is why the modelling is fundamental. I appreciate that the Minister is from the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office, but in this context we need to see the dynamic modelling from the Treasury, because the claims are not backed up by facts.
The economic analyses, predictions and models that are often quoted are subject to huge variability, big caveats and questionable assumptions. For example, the 4% figure from the Office for Budget Responsibility, which is often quoted, is not an OBR forecast; it is an OBR prediction that results from looking at other studies. I think that the Government should examine these details and consider the economic implications and consequences before trying to make assumptions on behalf of British businesses.
The Minister for Intergovernmental Relations and European Relations is not in the Chamber now, so I call on the Minister who will sum up the debate to tell us how many of the goods to which her colleague has referred—including the basket of goods that he was holding up on social media—would have their prices changed by the deal that he will be signing this week, and to also tell us whether there will be a risk of higher prices as a result of increased EU red tape.
Let me also caution the Government about using the Cabinet Office to promote pro-EU views. Having been in the last Parliament—we have seen how divisive these campaigns can be—I know that that is deeply unhelpful. Ten years ago, just before the referendum, the Cabinet Office produced a booklet that was sent to every household explaining what it felt was the case for remaining in the EU. It suggested, among many other things, that 3 million jobs would be at risk, that a trade deal with the EU could not be delivered, and that our services sector, which is the best in the world, would struggle. It made so many vacuous and false promises and claims that did not materialise, and it actually did a lot to undermine trust in democracy and politics.
We do have a free trade deal with the EU, and we have not seen a huge reduction in the number of jobs. The current problems in our employment market have been well debated in the House this week and in previous weeks, including the week following the Budget, but we have to look at the Employment Rights Act 2025 and the costs imposed on businesses through higher taxes and national insurance contribution increases. We have to carry out a sobering check on all this. We should also bear in mind that the value of goods exports to the EU is up by 30%, from £146 billion to nearly £191 billion.
There are some very important economic facts that we need to discuss. We should recognise that the UK and other major economies all face significant structural changes and challenges caused by a range of factors, including demand on public services, high levels of taxation and the impact, as has been noted, of global factors. Taking Britain closer to the EU will not address some of these challenges. It is not a silver bullet. There is no single solution, which is why I think it is wrong to go backwards in debates such as this.
I should like to mention one other aspect—