Contribution
My Lords, with the leave of your Lordships’ House I will also speak to Amendments 2 to 60. I am delighted to be opening the debate on the Sporting Events Bill. I am particularly pleased because when the Bill was last before us, a week before the reshuffle, noble Lords—not looking at any noble Lord in particular—raised concerns that I may not still be a DCMS Minister by the time the Bill headed to the Commons.
Earlier this year, as the Bill passed through your Lordships’ House, a strong and thoughtful case was made that a small number of our world-class recurrent events could in future face the same delivery, commercial protection and hosting challenges as itinerant events. I am hugely grateful to noble Lords and our outstanding recurrent events sector in the UK for the constructive engagement we have had on this issue. I particularly thank the noble Baroness, Lady Evans of Bowes Park, and the noble Lords, Lord Markham and Lord Addington, for their continued engagement on this point, as well as many other noble Lords. Our recurrent sporting events make an important contribution to the sporting life of this country and bring significant economic and social value to the United Kingdom. Having carefully considered this matter over the summer, as I committed to doing, this Government ultimately agreed with the principal points of consensus reached between noble Lords, albeit with a small number of important and proportionate amendments.
The Bill as amended by your Lordships’ House risked being overly broad in scope. That is why Amendment 8 requires events to have “international”, as opposed to just “national”, interest. In our view, without safeguards to ensure the framework is applied in a proportionate way, we risk an extremely large pool of events being unintentionally eligible for protections, therefore having a disproportionately wide effect on local businesses and communities. We believe that the outlined approach is the most appropriate and right one.
Amendments 3, 5 and 10 introduce a third condition that must be met in the case of recurrent events. Under this third condition, the organiser of a recurrent sporting event must apply to the Secretary of State, or the devolved Government, requesting and setting out evidence as to why it is appropriate to apply one or more parts of the framework to the event. The Secretary of State, or devolved Government, may then consider such events on a case-by-case basis, notably considering such matters as the prominence of the event within its field of sport and the frequency of such events. This is a right and proportionate approach for a cohort of events which are numerous, well established and not routinely dependent on government operational support. It builds on the concept of application introduced in your Lordships’ House.
Government Amendment 11 introduces a sunset provision so that a recurrent event would need to reapply after a maximum of five years to keep the protections applied to it. Events would then be expected to apply again, setting out why it remained appropriate for one or more parts of the framework to be applied to it. That is an important safeguard. It ensures that provisions and their wider impact do not continue indefinitely by default, while providing the chance for events that continue to meet the framework conditions to receive proper scrutiny and continue to benefit from them.
Amendment 21 introduces a mechanism for cost recovery in relation to the advertising and trading provisions where those provisions are applied to a domestic sporting event. Where additional burdens arise from the delivery of events run wholly independently of government, it is right in our view that these costs should not fall on the taxpayer. That is why this amendment enables local authorities to recover additional costs incurred when implementing the advertising and street trading provisions, but no more than that. That is, in the Government’s view, a fair and proportionate approach.
This Government are committed to ensuring that the Bill provides appropriate protections for major sporting events to take place, but at the same time are committed to ensuring businesses are supported. For recurrent events, Amendment 46 now provides a blanket exception to the trading offence for traders in a restricted zone who already hold a licence granted by the local authority. This means that, for example, a long-standing independent food seller will be able to continue to trade as usual. We have also made further amendments to the advertising and unauthorised association provisions to strengthen safeguards for small and microbusinesses through Amendments 18 and 43. Amendment 12 will also mean that traders licensed by local authorities, who are prevented from trading, can now expect reasonable steps to be taken to mitigate that. This includes having alternative trading locations identified.