B

Baroness Harding of Winscombe (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 18 November 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I will speak to the amendments in my name but first, I thank the Minister and his officials for their extremely constructive engagement between Committee and Report. This is an important group, because all the amendments —the Government’s, mine and those tabled by the noble Lord, Lord Dixon—are trying to do the same thing, which is to make sure that we have an economically fair, transparent and non-discriminatory market for online ticket retailers, enabling them to compete on a level playing field with Great British Railways. This matters because we currently have a functioning, competitive online retail market. There is a real risk that, in creating GBR, we send the wrong signals—“We don’t have the right safeguards in place”—and therefore investors will not invest, competition will gradually disappear, and with it innovation. With that, we will see ticket sales decline, which none of us wants. I think we are all united in trying to achieve the same thing with this amendment. I tabled Amendment 10, which I thank the noble Lord, Lord Hampton, for adding his name to, to ensure that GBR will compete in the online retail services market on fair economic terms, no more favourable than those on which the independent online ticket retailers do. I very much thank the Minister for tabling his Amendments 9 and 12, which broadly replace mine, and I will not press this amendment at the end of the debate. I also really appreciate what he has just said from the Dispatch Box, making it clear that “non-discriminatory terms” means non-discriminatory between the online retailers and GBR, not among the online retailers. He has also been clear at the Dispatch Box that GBR will be under an obligation to provide products, systems, data and services that are not just needed but, in effect, the products, systems, data and services that GBR itself uses, and that there will be no difference in availability and timing. I very much appreciate that. That takes me swiftly to my Amendments 16, 18 and 21, which aim to ensure that there is transparency on GBR’s online retail costs and revenues, and that any cross-subsidy of its online retail activities is visible to the ORR, the Secretary of State and taxpayers. This is important because it is not enough just to have a commitment to a fair and transparent market; we have to see the data to be certain that it is happening. Amendment 16 would require the online costs and revenues to be set out in GBR’s business plan. Amendment 18 would require the ORR to advise the Secretary of State whether there is “any cross-subsidy of Great British Railways’ online … retailing activities” from other parts of its operations, and Amendment 21 would require that advice to be published, provided that publishing does not “seriously and prejudicially affect anyone’s commercial interests”. I appreciate the discussions that I have had with the Minister and his team, and I recognise his personal commitment to creating a level playing field, but without clarity on the financial performance of GBR’s online retailing, his assurance is simply a hope that economic theory and business practice suggest is unfounded. I know that GBR intends to run its online retailing operation combined with its physical retailing. Personally, I wish that it would separate them, but the Minister has been clear that that decision is not up for debate. However, any good multichannel retailer allocates costs across its different sales channels to understand the profitability of each of those channels. Regardless of how it is operated, I would expect GBR management to know the costs and revenues of its online retailing operation versus its physical retailing operation. By the way, I would also expect the Treasury to want to know whether there is a subsidy in either of those pieces. That is really all that my amendments would do. I know that officials have been concerned about confidentiality, but we are not asking for deep, granular detail or the disclosure of commercial contracts. We are simply asking to be really clear, publicly, whether there is a subsidy between the physical retailing operations and the online ones, which is why, should we get to that stage, I expect to divide the House on this issue.

More from Baroness Harding of Winscombe (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.