Contribution
My Lords, it is me again. I shall speak to Amendments 24 and 82 in my name—I know that Amendment 82 is of interest to the noble Lord, Lord Berkeley. Before I do so, I wish heartily to associate myself with the amendments in this group in the name of my noble friend Lord Harper; I shall not be speaking about them, but I am happy to lend my support to him in what I believe he is about to say.
Amendment 24 would require the long-term rail strategy to include a policy linking pay increases for GBR employees to measurable improvements in productivity or operational efficiency. We have seen, not solely under this Government but very much so under this Government, a succession of pay rises without corresponding commitments to productivity improvements. We all think back with embarrassment to the pay concessions made by the former Secretary of State, Louise Haigh—who I see has resurfaced in government. She had not been in office for five minutes before dishing out everything the unions wanted in exchange for no productivity improvements whatever—one of the first actions of the failed and discredited Starmer Government.
In Committee, the Minister argued that making pay increases conditional on productivity improvements through primary legislation would be restrictive. That is the whole point: this is taxpayers’ money and it should be restricted and controlled. There should be limits on how it is dished out, and one of them is that the taxpayer should get something back for the money they are paying out by way of improvements in efficiency. We are an economy that needs to improve labour efficiency—everyone agrees on that. “The need to improve productivity” is another way of putting it, but it is exactly the same thing, and we wish to see that in the railway sector and in the Bill.
Amendment 82 also relates to industrial relations. We have a beautiful new east-west railway that goes to Milton Keynes, Winslow and places like that, and the trains occasionally even run—but they have no passengers, because there has been no agreement with the unions about the operation of the trains. Fingers of blame can be pointed: “Oh, it’s the fault of Chiltern Railways”—now part of the Department for Transport’s operator—“or the fault of the last Government for not thinking about it far enough”. However, the fundamental problem is that the unions, particularly the RMT, I believe, do not want to agree to driver-only operation, and they have held up the operation of the railway for just that reason.
Driver-only operation should be required on all services—although this amendment, as I recall, would simply require it on all new services—and it should not be held hostage by the unions. Passengers living in the Winslow area, and I am afraid I hear a lot from them, are fuming that they are not getting the service they are promised. They are also fuming that the first passenger use of the railway, although I may or may not get the details of this right, is going to be for diverting services. Fundamentally, because there are going to be closures on the main line into Paddington, trains from Swindon—which I think is the Secretary of State’s constituency—are going to be diverted to Paddington around that line, so there will for a period be many passengers on the line, but the trains will not be stopping at Winslow or places like that and giving local people, who have thirsted for this railway for a long time, the chance to get on it. All that is because it is being held up by the RMT.
It is a disgrace. The Minister can say that it is someone else’s disgrace or someone else’s fault, but it falls to him to sort it out, and it falls to us in this Bill to ensure that there are measures in it to ensure that this sort of thing will not happen again, and that we get a modern and efficient railway running with modern standards that serves the people. I beg to move.