Lord Thomas of Cwmgiedd (CB)

I am grateful to all noble Lords who have spoken in this debate, in which the views, save that of the Minister, have been unanimous across the House. The unanimous view is that something needs to be done in the interests of justice. It is justice that lies at the heart of this debate. One of the cardinal principles of justice is treating everyone equally before the law. If you stole a mobile phone from someone in 2005 or 2014, you ought to be treated in exactly the same way if you committed that offence during the period of this misconceived sentence. Failing to do that is to condemn people to injustice and to perpetuate it. It is no excuse to say, “Well, they were under a sentence passed by the courts”, when everyone has agreed that that sentence was wholly misconceived; nor is it an excuse to say there is a risk that they are more dangerous, because the psychiatric evidence is unanimous in the view that the form of sentence has made that danger greater. On the amendment and what it tries to deal with, I am very sorry that those who provided the briefing to the Minister did not understand the change that had been made to the proposals I and the noble and learned Lord, Lord Garnier, put forward, because neither required a two-year release. There was a safeguard put in. What we proposed would have protected the public to the extent that they are and must be protected. I would hope that we could give people hope. I do not believe, from what I have seen—as the noble Baroness, Lady Chakrabarti, said and the noble and learned Lord, Lord Garnier, has said, from the files he reviewed—that this can be solved administratively; it needs legislation. I, therefore, with deep regret, feel it necessary to test the opinion of the House. In doing so, it is important to bear in mind what Lord Lloyd of Berwick reminded the House of in 2014: Winston Churchill said many years earlier that “one infallible test of any civilised country is the way it treats its prisoners”.—[Official Report, 20/10/14; col. 456.] I hope we will not fail that test. We need to do justice to those in prison. I therefore would like to seek the opinion of the House on Amendment 76.