Age of Consent
Wednesday, 18 November 2026
Contributions
Question
Asked by
Baroness Hazarika
To ask His Majesty’s Government what consideration they have given to staggering the age of consent.
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Ministry of Justice (Lord Lemos) (Lab)
My Lords, a range of offences already exist to protect children, and it is for the police and prosecutors to determine whether a crime has occurred. We will always look at what more can be done to protect young people from abuse and exploitation, and we are focused on tackling exploitation and supporting young people to understand healthy relationships and consent.
Baroness Hazarika (Lab)
My Lords, I think we will all have been sickened by the behaviour of Russell Brand and allegations involving other people. Some of the victims are calling for legislation, with the idea of staggered consent, but we should have a much wider conversation about consent. Can my noble friend the Minister say whether we should have a broader conversation about culture? It is not okay for predominantly, although not always, older men to prey on younger people—lots of women, lots of men and sometimes teenagers—for sex. It is not okay if you are a musician or an actor, and it is not okay if you are an ordinary person—we have just been discussing the grooming gangs, and that was a feature of that kind of abuse. Can my noble friend say that we need to have a bigger conversation about this? Can we all agree that the shame and the stigma should be not on the younger person, who is often coerced into sex, but on the creepy older man?
Lord Lemos (Lab)
My Lords, I agree with my noble friend Lady Hazarika that we need to have a wider conversation. The question of the staggered age of consent has come to the forefront of public discourse. It is a complicated question, but we can certainly look at it—it has far-reaching consequences. However, as she indicates, there are plenty of things that we could take action on now. The issue at stake is the sexual exploitation and coercion of vulnerable young people by powerful and manipulative older people. There is much that can be done by broadcasters, by online companies and in education.
Lord Marks of Henley-on-Thames (LD)
My Lords, I agree with what the Minister just said about the topical interest, but this Topical Question raises very difficult issues on which there are widely divergent views and evidence. The Law Commission has an upcoming project on consent in criminal law, on which it has not yet embarked. Have the Government considered whether they might ask the Law Commission to broaden the ambit of that project to include considering the age of consent?
Lord Lemos (Lab)
I can confirm that the Law Commission is, as part of its 14th programme of work, reviewing the concept of consent in the criminal law, including in sexual offences, so it will look at the issue that the noble Lord raised. It has confirmed that the review will include a wide range of issues and will provide greater predictability to modernise particularly the criminal law in England and Wales. Of course, the Government will consider its findings carefully.
Lord Keen of Elie (Con)
My Lords, the author Graham Greene described fame as a “powerful aphrodisiac”. As recent events have illustrated, it can also be a catalyst for vile exploitation. What steps will the Government take to address such conduct, widely regarded as morally repugnant, and render it liable to the criminal law?
Lord Lemos (Lab)
Sorry, I missed the very first sentence—could the noble and learned Lord just repeat it?
Lord Keen of Elie (Con)
The first sentence was a reference to the author Graham Greene, whom the noble Lord may have heard of. He described fame as a “powerful aphrodisiac”. As I pointed out, it can also be a catalyst for vile exploitation. What steps will the Government take to address such conduct and render it liable to the criminal law?
Lord Lemos (Lab)
I have read a bit of Graham Greene; I am happy to confirm that. I did English literature at university—I dare say that the noble and learned Lord did law. Indeed, if he did, I would say that the law curriculum should be updated to include a little bit more Graham Greene. On the serious point that the noble and learned Lord makes, of course the Government will look at ways in which we can address the criminal behaviours here. We have done things in the online safety space; we have created new offences there. However, I think it is fair to say that no one feels that we are in a comfortable place, and the Brand case illustrates some aspects of sexual exploitation and abuse that we need to think about more carefully—and we will. If necessary, we will legislate. It is an appalling case, as my right honourable friend the Prime Minister said, and we will do all that we can.
Baroness Harman (Lab)
My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Hazarika, for the Question and agree with everything she said in asking it. I thank the Minister for his Answer, which I found very encouraging. I agree that the Law Commission can play a big role in this. I feel confident that we can have a genuinely cross-party discussion in this House, especially with the expertise that we have, with many noble Baronesses on both sides of the House having fought for protecting women against male sexual violence and many on both sides of the House who have experience in the judicial and legal system. Fundamentally, do we think that it is okay for a 60 year-old man to be having sex with a 16 year-old woman? We do not—we recognise that there is a great power imbalance by virtue of age. Do we think that the criminal law could step in and provide some protection against this imbalance founded in age? I hope that we can. I agree that there should be a staggered age of consent, and I think that we should discuss it. Does the Minister agree that that is an important discussion to be had?
Lord Lemos (Lab)
Yes, I agree with my noble and learned friend that it is an important discussion for us to have. I think the scenario that she describes is deeply troubling to all of us, and we should absolutely discuss it—and if necessary, we will legislate. She referenced the Law Commission’s work. We have accepted all the recommendations of the noble Baroness, Lady Casey, and we have legislated in the Crime and Policing Act to create new offences covering rape and other penetrative sexual activity with a child under 16 by an adult. I agree with my noble and learned friend that there is no doubt more that we can do, and we must come back and look at that. What she describes should concern us all.
Lord Young of Acton (Con)
The Minister has just confirmed that the Government are taking seriously suggestions of staggering the age of consent. Can he confirm that the Government are reconsidering lowering the voting age to 16?
Lord Lemos (Lab)
I sort of expected that question—I did not quite know who from, but I guess I might have guessed. But no, we will not reconsider voting at the age of 16. It was a manifesto commitment, we are legislating on it, and we hope that it will be law very soon.
Baroness Uddin (Non-Afl)
My Lords, I declare my interest as a former safeguarding and child protection officer. I thank my noble friend Lady Hazarika and my noble and learned friend Lady Harman for suggesting that we need collective action to address these massive issues. My noble friend talked about wider society and the difficulties of consent, but what procedures and support are in place for vulnerable young people who come into this House for volunteering or work placement regarding whistleblowing? What processes do we have in place to ensure that their safeguarding is as paramount for us here in this House as it is outside?
Lord Lemos (Lab)
I agree with the noble Baroness that we in this House must have the highest standards. That is really a question for the House authorities. I think it is true to say that we have all done training and been introduced to the code on this—I certainly have, and it was excellent—but I am sure the House authorities will write to the noble Baroness and set out our approach.
Lord Pannick (CB)
My Lords, none of us supports sexual exploitation, but is it really for the criminal law to tell 16 year-old men and women who they can have sex with?
Lord Lemos (Lab)
The noble Lord is right. One issue that we are concerned with, and which the noble Baroness, Lady Casey, was concerned we should be clear about, is that we should not inadvertently criminalise consensual relationships between young people—I am not quite sure if that is exactly what the noble Lord had in mind. As I have said, we will look again at the wider question of consent of 16 year-olds for sexual relations with older people. If there is a need to do something, we will, but the age of consent has been set at 16 for a very long time—although only much more recently for young gay men—and it would be a big and far-reaching change. Still, we will do what we can on sexual exploitation.
Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5440387.