Cyber Security: PHP Vulnerability
Thursday, 22 October 2026
Contributions
Private Notice Question
Asked by
Lord Dixon of Jericho
To ask His Majesty’s Government what assessment they have made of the impact on government websites and digital services of the PHP vulnerability set out in the alert issued by the National Cyber Security Centre on 21 October 2026.
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade and Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport (Baroness Lloyd of Effra) (Lab)
My Lords, the Government have made a detailed assessment of the impact of the PHP vulnerability on government websites and digital services, and have been working closely with the National Cyber Security Centre and departments across government in response. Prior to public disclosure, departments were alerted to the vulnerability and advised to identify potential affected systems, assess their exposure and prepare to implement mitigations and security updates as they became available. PHP is one of the world’s most widely used web technologies and is deployed extensively across both public and private sectors globally. The vulnerability is therefore not unique to government systems and has affected organisations worldwide. The Government Cyber Coordination Centre and the NCSC continue to coordinate the cross-government response, monitoring potential impacts, sharing technical guidance and supporting departments in implementing mitigations and remediation activity. Our current assessment is that the principal impact on government digital services has arisen from precautionary measures taken to protect systems while security updates are applied. The Government continue to monitor the situation closely and work with departments to maintain the security, resilience and availability of public services.
Lord Dixon of Jericho (LD)
My Lords, it is good to hear from the Minister what advance notice we had, and that we were able to work in advance. When both the “Traitors” website and the Office for Budget Responsibility website go down, we can see how widespread an issue this is. It is crucial that we keep improving how we respond and react to this. The House will be very aware that we will not get everything right. Can the Minister give us her sense of what went smoothly over the last 24 hours, and what was frankly a bit more difficult in terms of the processes the Government ran?
Baroness Lloyd of Effra (Lab)
The Government stood up, and there was a cross-government incident response structure, as you would expect. The Government acted proactively ahead of public disclosure. As is often best practice, the NCSC was able to co-ordinate with vendors ahead of disclosure to ensure that, when disclosure was made, they were prepared with the patches and other mitigations to support their customers just after the disclosure was made. That is an example of using the identification of vulnerabilities and acting effectively with vendors and with the industry. I would encourage industry and others to sign up to the NCSC’s early warning scheme. The NCSC was able to make 50,000 proactive notifications to the wider economy to advise business and other organisations on what actions they should take, so I encourage all organisations to sign up to the NCSC early warning system.
Baroness Harding of Winscombe (Con)
My Lords, if the Cyber Security and Resilience (Network and Information Systems) Bill, which is currently going through this House, had been on the statute book and been live, can the Minister tell us what additional powers or actions the Government could have taken, and does she think that is sufficient?
Baroness Lloyd of Effra (Lab)
The incident regarding PHP identified vulnerabilities ahead of potential exploitation. That is one of the potential benefits we can see of frontier AI, although of course we understand that frontier AI, and AI in general, can also increase and augment potential threats. In respect of the Bill, MSPs will be brought into it. As SMEs rely on the sort of underlying systems and websites that may be supported by PHP, the fact that MSPs will be brought into the Bill will mean that more of the economy will be covered: in particular, companies that do not manage their services directly. In addition, under the security and resilience requirements, there will be further requirements on patching, and requirements for critical patching within defined timelines. In those ways, the Bill will support what we are seeing in terms of new threats and the identification of vulnerabilities.
Baroness Ludford (LD)
One problem with the Bill is that it leaves central government and local authorities outside its statutory duties, relying instead on non-statutory guidance. But the public sector has been particularly hard hit by this incident, with several councils taken offline: Edinburgh, Oxford, Bristol, Lambeth and Barnet, and probably others. With Report on Monday, will the Government commit to tabling amendments to put the public sector under the enforceable incident reporting and resilience obligations in the Bill?
Baroness Lloyd of Effra (Lab)
As I mentioned, the Government have acted proactively, ahead of public disclosure, to work with departments, to assess the potential exposure and to prepare mitigations. The focus has been on protecting public services, supporting rapid remediation and ensuring a co-ordinated response across government. This is a global security issue that has affected one of the world’s most widely used web technologies, so it requires remediation across the public sector and across the private sector, across the globe. In respect of the Government’s Cyber Security and Resilience (Network and Information Systems) Bill—indeed, we have Report on Monday—as I mentioned in Committee, the Government are looking at future sectors that may be brought within it. That piece of work already ongoing.
Lord Bellingham (Con)
My Lords, the outage at numerous government departments will obviously lead to a delay in the provision of key services. We have already heard about the DVLA, numerous government departments, and perhaps police departments and so on. What assessment has the Minister made of the actual impact of these delays? Can she tell us something about the remedies that would be available to members of the public who suffer as a consequence, maybe financially?
Baroness Lloyd of Effra (Lab)
Currently, the information I have is that 32 government services are unavailable and four are partially unavailable. That is the latest cross-government reporting. That has resulted largely from precautionary measures taken to protect systems while security updates and mitigations are applied. We are working very carefully with departments to restore the services safely and securely following that remediation activity. The advice of the NCSC is to mitigate and then restore the services. We are working to restore the services safely and as quickly as possible.
Baroness Northover (LD)
My Lords, experts warn that it is not a matter of if an organisation is going to be attacked, but when it will be attacked, and that is what we are seeing here. For small businesses, as I think the Minister knows, a cyber incident can be existential. Some 60% of SMEs that fall victim to a cyber attack go out of business within six months. Does the Minister think that the Government are being sufficiently proactive in what she has outlined in terms of protecting the whole of our economy? Given that frontier AI can now find such flaws at such speed, will she be giving the AI Security Institute statutory powers of inspection and mitigation?
Baroness Lloyd of Effra (Lab)
The noble Baroness raised a series of very important points. In respect of this vulnerability, while we have seen exploitation activity in scanning being reported internationally, we are not currently aware of any confirmed compromise of central government systems resulting from these vulnerabilities. As we have previously noted, frontier AI allows for the identification of vulnerabilities. As the head of the NCSC and others have alerted industry and, indeed, government, this means we need to be more vigilant and quicker in readying ourselves to apply patches and other mitigations. That is something that we all need to prepare for, including SMEs. In this example, most probably SMEs will be relying on their managed service providers. I recommend that they talk to their managed service provider to assure themselves that the services that they rely on have been updated, as advised by the NCSC.
The Earl of Kinnoull (CB)
My Lords, a newspaper article in the Times today suggested that this problem first surfaced on Tuesday and that anyway a patch had been planned to be available on Thursday. How long have the Government known about this situation—just indicatively, so we understand how much work has been going on behind the scenes, and for how long, on what is obviously a very serious international problem?
Baroness Lloyd of Effra (Lab)
The NCSC was briefed by OpenAI last week on this potential specific vulnerability and has been working to ensure that disclosure happened in a co-ordinated way with vendors, so there was sufficient preparation to protect customers. It is regarded as best practice to be able to mitigate the impact to prepare and disclose in a co-ordinated way.
Viscount Camrose (Con)
My Lords, the responsibility for cyber security has now been split between three government departments. We are still waiting for the national cyber action plan, and much of our economic activity, as we have heard from a number of noble Lords, remains out of scope of the Cyber Security and Resilience (Network and Information Systems) Bill. Can the Minister tell the House who is ultimately accountable for our national cyber resilience and when we will see a coherent plan to deliver that?
Baroness Lloyd of Effra (Lab)
DCMS, via the Government Cyber Unit and the Government Cyber Coordination Centre, is responsible for co-ordinating the cross-government response to cyber incidents affecting government departments and the wider public sector. That is documented in the G overnment Cyber Action Plan . As the noble Lord notes, the Government intend to publish a national cyber action plan that will set out the whole-of-government approach to tackling cyber security and resilience.
Baroness Berger (Lab)
My Lords, can my noble friend the Minister say what assessment the Government have made of the potential for cyber attacks as a result of the disclosure of the PHP programming vulnerabilities, specifically on our educational infrastructure, including UCAS, university systems and awarding bodies, and the risks to intellectual property and research data held by universities? Do the Government believe that current protections adequately reflect the importance of education to both our national security and economic resilience?
Baroness Lloyd of Effra (Lab)
In terms of the assessment that my noble friend mentioned, we are monitoring the situation closely alongside NCSC. While we have heard reports of exploitation activity in scanning internationally, we are not aware of any compromises in the UK public sector, or in the UK as such. In respect of cyber resilience more generally across the public and private sectors, our message is that with the increased threats that we are seeing from the augmentation of AI, we recommend that the public sector, including education, and the private sector, all of industry, increase their cyber resilience by taking the measures we have suggested, including board leadership, signing up to early warning systems, understanding fully their supply chains and ensuring that they all meet the requisite standards of cyber resilience.
Lord Grade of Yarmouth (Con)
My Lords, does the Minister agree that there are lessons here from the online safety legislation? The effects of regulation, legislation, action plans and so on are no substitute for the tech companies themselves taking full responsibility, and being made to do so, for the harm and dangers they can cause. What steps do the Government think they can take to move us along the path to get the tech companies to take full responsibility for the risks they create?
Baroness Lloyd of Effra (Lab)
The noble Lord asks about the responsibilities of tech companies but also the impact of technological developments on cyber security. In this incident, the effect has been to be able to identify vulnerabilities which can then be mitigated and patched. In respect of the cyber security Bill that is coming forward, it will include sectors such as data centres and managed service providers within the regulatory ambit. The Government continue to believe that regulating AI at the point of use is the right approach. The Minister for AI set out last week the many further efforts that we are taking to harden our defences and address both the opportunities and threats that AI presents.
← Previous
Hormone Replacement Therapy: Product Shortage
Next →
Church Appointments (Repeal of Discriminatory Provision) Bill
Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5423189.