Hansard·Grand Committee·Vol. 861

North Atlantic Salmon Conservation Organization (Immunities and Privileges) Order

Tuesday, 17 November 2026

15 contributions3 members

Contributions

  1. Considered in Grand Committee

    View contribution permalink →

  2. Moved by

    View contribution permalink →

  3. Lord Wood of Anfield

    That the Grand Committee do consider the North Atlantic Salmon Conservation Organization (Immunities and Privileges) Order 2026.

    View contribution permalink →

  4. The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office (Lord Wood of Anfield) (Lab)

    My Lords, I will also speak to the North-East Atlantic Fisheries Commission (Immunities and Privileges) Order. NASCO and NEAFC are both important international organisations through which the UK works with other countries to conserve and sustainably manage fish stocks in the North Atlantic. Fish stocks, of course, do not respect national boundaries, making international co-operation essential to their effective management. Through these organisations, countries work together to agree conservation and management measures, informed by the best available scientific advice, which supports sustainable fisheries and the marine environment. Their work is important to the UK’s fishing industry, our coastal communities and environmental non-governmental organisations, as well as to the health of the wider marine environment. By providing established forums for international co-operation, NASCO and NEAFC enable the UK to work with other parties to address shared challenges and support the long-term conservation and sustainable use of important North Atlantic fish stocks. These organisations have been headquartered in the UK since 1983 and 1999, respectively. These orders are a technical legislative exercise that was necessitated due to the sunset of the powers in the Retained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Act 2023. These orders do not alter the UK’s obligations to NASCO or NEAFC. Instead, they update the domestic legal basis on which those obligations are implemented and ensure the continuity of existing arrangements. It is standard practice for most international organisations with headquarters in the UK to have their privileges and immunities conferred under the International Organisations Act 1968. To date, the privileges and immunities in the headquarters agreements for NASCO and NEAFC were implemented under the European Communities Act 1972, which of course was repealed as a result of the European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Act 2020. Accordingly, the previous orders became secondary assimilated law within the meaning of Section 12(2) of the retained EU law—or REUL—Act. The relevant powers to amend or revoke secondary assimilated law under the REUL Act sunsetted on 23 June 2026. Consequently, the European Communities (Immunities and Privileges of the North Atlantic Salmon Conservation Organization and North-East Atlantic Fisheries Commission) (Revocation) Regulations 2026—that is quite a mouthful—were made on 14 May 2026. These two orders therefore replace the NASCO and NEAFC orders made under the European Communities Act 1972 and will come into force on 31 March 2027 to ensure continuity in the privileges and immunities that NASCO and NEAFC receive. These orders are required so that the necessary privileges and immunities that both NASCO and NEAFC operate under continue after the end of March 2027. Complementary provisions are also required in Scotland, where the Scottish Government intend to lay an order in due course. These orders grant NASCO and NEAFC the privileges and immunities they functionally require so that they may operate effectively. Doing so is a prerequisite so that the UK can continue to implement the provisions of their headquarters agreements. The privileges and immunities within these orders do not fundamentally change from what has been repealed. They are limited to what both organisations, and the persons connected with these organisations, functionally require to perform their roles independently and effectively. Both NASCO and NEAFC will continue to have legal capacity and their archives remain inviolable. Both organisations will retain the tax exemptions and reliefs necessary to enable them to function independently. The orders also confer special privileges and immunities on the representatives of member states to NASCO and NEAFC, and the staff at both organisations. This includes immunity in respect of official words and acts. No individuals will receive so-called personal or diplomatic immunities. The privileges and immunities in these orders are granted to ensure the independent and effective functioning of both NASCO and NEAFC. They are not for personal benefit. Their headquarters agreements and these orders contain a clear waiver so that a privilege or immunity may waived by the appropriate authority. For example, the head of either NASCO or NEAFC can waive the immunities of their staff if requested. Both orders expressly remove immunity in relation to road traffic offences and civil claims arising from motor vehicle accidents. The Government consider these privileges and immunities necessary and appropriate. They deliver on the UK’s interests, and the commitments they have made towards the organisations are in line with UK precedents. To conclude, this is the best approach to retain the ability to amend or evoke the privileges and immunities for both organisations beyond the sunset of the REUL Act powers on 23 June 2026. The work of NASCO and NEAFC is essential to the conservation and sustainable management of fish stocks across the North Atlantic, proving a forum for the UK to work with international partners to manage shared fisheries and protect and restore key species based on the best available scientific advice. I commend the order to the Committee.

    View contribution permalink →

  5. Lord Grantchester (Lab)

    My Lords, I thank the Minister for his explanation of the two orders before the Committee. Paragraph 6.2 very adequately outlines that the two orders continue previous orders beyond the sunset arrangements of the 2023 retained EU law Act. I realise they are very technical in nature, and I may stray from the brief of the subject before the Committee, but I am anxious about how the organisation interacts with the preservation and conservation of wild salmon in Scotland. Can the Minister outline the operational area and powers of NASCO and NEAFC, and how they relate to the inland shore areas and the conservation of migratory wild salmon, along with their international aspects? Are they able to monitor and enforce regulations on the considerable number of fish farms around the west of Scotland that, with the escapees and disease burdens arising from these farms, so endanger the migratory life of wild salmon in the rivers and streams of western Scotland? I declare my interest as a co-owner of a holiday home with fishing rights in Dumfries and Galloway, although I do not participate in the sport of fishing.

    View contribution permalink →

  6. Lord Roborough (Con)

    My Lords, before I begin, I declare my interests as the owner of fishing rights on rivers in Devon and Sutherland, and as president of the South West Rivers Association. In that role, I have had some dealings with NASCO, and the quality of its research is second to none. It has very able staff. I thank the Minister for bringing forward these two orders. In regard to technicalities of the orders, they will come into force in March 2027, providing continuity in the privileges and immunities that the retained EU law Act previously provided. We in the Official Opposition completely support this. Some of the articles in these orders will not apply in Scotland, but we understand that the devolved Government will implement complementary provisions. Can the Minister confirm that the implementation will mirror the same timeline? On the issue of salmon conservation, and without wishing to repeat the comments of the noble Lord, Lord Grantchester, noble Lords across the House have demonstrated considerable concern about the plight of the Atlantic salmon. In Scottish rivers, there has been a 70% decline in the population, and 90% of English principal salmon rivers have been officially designated as at risk or potentially at risk. Intensive salmon farming practices are among the causes of concern, such as failures to tackle sea lice, as well as genetic contamination when salmon escape.

    View contribution permalink →

  7. The Atlantic salmon is now an IUCN red list species in the UK as a result of these issues, as well as climate change, impact on spawning grounds, and availability of feed for the smolts when they first go to sea. Recently, the Soil Association has withdrawn its accreditation for UK-farmed salmon due to concerns over environmental and welfare outcomes. Meanwhile, other countries, such as Norway, are developing innovative methods to tackle this. Can the Minister provide an update on how the department is examining this issue and what outcomes it is working towards? NASCO itself has a budget of only £735,000 for the current year, funded mainly by national contributions, including our own. Have the Government considered allocating more funding to NASCO—for example, from the £24 million that is raised annually through rod licensing?

    View contribution permalink →

  8. Is there an opportunity for the Centre for Environment, Fisheries and Aquaculture Science to do more in support of NASCO research and the adoption of NASCO recommendations? Will the Minister consider working more closely with the Norwegian Government and NASCO in funding greater research into the incidence of salmon by-catch in the pelagic fishery? The last studies were completed over 23 years ago and showed a meaningful by-catch of as many as 1 million post-smolt salmonids per annum. Since then, the evidence is that the pelagic fishery has moved north and is now co-located with our migratory salmon. The risk is that there is much greater by-catch now than there was then, and it is urgent that this research is brought up to date.

    View contribution permalink →

  9. We on these Benches recognise wholeheartedly that our fishing sector is crucial to many areas, and we do not want to see this industry lost; hence the need to work collaboratively towards improved practices. More broadly, under the previous Government, we began the work of replacing the EU common fisheries policy with a new framework, consulting on six fisheries management plans. In 2021, £100 million was allocated to support the sector’s future. In 2024, we negotiated quotas of 750,000 tonnes of fish, an 80,000-tonne increase compared with 2023.

    View contribution permalink →

  10. However, this Labour Government signed away 12 years of access for EU vessels to UK waters. Agreeing not to increase the UK share of fish from UK waters over the next 12 years is costing our fishing industry in excess of £500 million per annum, in impoverished coastal communities where that money means a great deal. There has been a 15% decrease in the number of full-time jobs that the sector provides since 2024. How will the Government seek to prevent a further decrease in the number of these jobs?

    View contribution permalink →

  11. We support these SIs but I look forward to hearing the Minister’s response to some of the points I have put to him.

    View contribution permalink →

  12. Lord Wood of Anfield (Lab)

    I thank noble Lords for their contributions. As I outlined, fish stocks do not respect national boundaries, so ensuring that NASCO and NEAFC can continue to operate effectively is vital for ensuring that these stocks are well maintained and can last. I am grateful for the comments from the noble Lord, Lord Roborough, about the quality of the NASCO teams that he has had contact with, in his capacity as a man of the industry, and for his support for the general privileges and immunities transfer that this represents. On his question about the implementation timeline in Scotland, yes, I believe it is a commitment to do the same parallel timelines here. On the noble Lord’s question on sustainable management, which is obviously a hugely important question, NASCO combines international regulation with scrutiny of parties’ performance in its North-East Atlantic Commission and West Greenland Commission. It agrees regulatory measures for the important mixed-stock salmon fisheries at the Faroe Islands—where I will be going next week, interestingly—and west Greenland, informed by scientific advice from ICES. For example, it has agreed that no quota will be set for the Faroese fishery for 2026-27 to 2028-29, unless a review of the scientific advice warrants reconsideration. More broadly, as I am sure the noble Lord knows, parties and jurisdictions are expected to demonstrate how they are implementing NASCO’s resolutions, agreements and guidelines through implementation plans and associated performance indicators. The noble Lord also asked whether the Government should work more with NASCO on research and improvement techniques and sustainability. I am sure that that is absolutely true and there is much more to do. I will definitely pass on the imperative of doing so to colleagues who have far more expertise than I have. The noble Lord, Lord Grantchester, asked about issues to do with non-deep-sea salmon. Of course, NASCO recognises that the pressures on wild Atlantic salmon extend beyond fisheries in the Atlantic, including interactions with aquaculture. It has adopted international resolutions, agreements and guidelines addressing aquaculture introductions and transfers, and parties are required to set out through their implementation plans how they will implement these commitments. Progress is then assessed through NASCO’s reporting framework, providing transparency and enabling parties to be held to account for action to minimise impacts on wild salmon. The noble Lord and I may disagree about some of the actions taken in the past with regard to the fishing industry and Brexit, and associated acts by Governments of different political colours, but I totally agree about the need to support the fishing industry in a difficult time and going forward. I hope that that will remain a firm commitment of this Government and future Governments. I thank noble Lords for their keen interest in ensuring that both the North Atlantic Salmon Conservation Organization and the North-East Atlantic Fisheries Commission can continue to operate effectively in the UK. Approval of these draft orders will ensure that, and I therefore trust that the Committee will support them.

    View contribution permalink →

  13. Lord Roborough (Con)

    I have some detailed questions about the possibility of additional funding for NASCO and the funding of by-catch research in pelagic fisheries. I understand that that is probably way outside the brief that the Minister has today, but if it is possible to write, I would be grateful.

    View contribution permalink →

  14. Lord Wood of Anfield (Lab)

    I would be very happy to write.

    View contribution permalink →

  15. Motion agreed.

    View contribution permalink →

Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5439337.