Ofgem: Market Stabilisation Charge
Wednesday, 21 October 2026
Contributions
Question
Asked by
Lord Sikka
To ask His Majesty’s Government what assessment they have made of Ofgem’s proposal to reintroduce the Market Stabilisation Charge.
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department for Energy Security and Net Zero (Baroness Curran) (Lab)
My Lords, the market stabilisation charge is a matter for Ofgem as the independent regulator. The Government recognise that a stable and resilient energy market is in the interests of consumers. Ofgem is consulting on whether to activate the market stabilisation charge, and we will continue to monitor developments.
Lord Sikka (Lab)
My Lords, this charge would force energy companies to compensate consumers’ old suppliers for lost profits when people switch away. It would increase energy bills and millions would be forced to choose between eating and heating. This form of price fixing guarantees profits for inefficient suppliers, while people are forced to pick up the tab. Ofgem cannot do anything without government approval, so will the Minister rule out the charge? If not, what additional help will be given to households and industry?
Baroness Curran (Lab)
It is important that we understand the role of Ofgem. Ofgem is a regulator; it takes decisions independently of government and is directly accountable to Parliament, and indeed has been questioned by parliamentary committees. There is a lot in what the noble Lord has asked me, and I admire his tenacity and his role in this House in pursuing Ministers in Questions. Any intervention in the retail market would be designed as a temporary backstop, to manage risks of market disruption and to protect customers —which is the central responsibility of Ofgem—and, as he says, would avoid wider costs associated with supplier failure. I emphasise that this is out for consultation —Ofgem is consulting with suppliers, consumers and key stakeholders. Of course, it is about a balance. This was introduced in 2022 because of the impact that it had on ordinary customers, as has been recognised by parliamentary committees.
Lord Whitehead (Lab)
My Lords, does my noble friend the Minister agree that the best assessment we can make of the present situation is just to look at the price of wholesale gas at the moment, which is above 200p a therm, up 150% since before the events in the Middle East earlier this year? Does she agree that we must ensure that responsible energy companies that have properly hedged their arrangements should not be disadvantaged during a period of volatility by fly-by-night companies which might go bust as a result of the volatility in the markets in the future?
Baroness Curran (Lab)
I am sure that my noble friend, with his track record, is well aware of the circumstances in 2022 and why this measure was introduced temporarily. In fact, around 30 suppliers went bust, and the Public Accounts Committee found that, if the market stabilisation mechanism had not been introduced, it could well have pushed £2.7 billion in costs on to ordinary customer. It was, and was seen to be, a useful mechanism at that time. We now have only five suppliers, so the market is different from those circumstances, and I think Ofgem, in the consultation, will take that into account, because we need to keep the protection of customers at the centre of what we are doing. I recognise, of course, that this is a balanced argument. There are significant people who argue against this and there are significant people who argue for it. Supplier failure, whether we like it or not, will impact on ordinary customers, but of course we want to make sure that customers get the best deal and can still choose tariffs.
Baroness Sheehan (LD)
My Lords, will the Government publish the modelling behind Ofgem’s £0.5 billion loss estimate and expected consumer impact?
Baroness Curran (Lab)
I recognise the noble Baroness’s role in this House as chair of the committee. If I may be permitted to say, I will take some advice on that; I am not quite sure what our rules are as government on publishing Ofgem modelling. As a matter of principle, I believe profoundly in transparency and the accountability of public bodies. Maybe Ofgem will go directly to Parliament with that. If not, I will certainly do what I can to address the issue that the noble Baroness raises.
Lord Moynihan (Con)
My Lords, I declare my interests as chair of Amey, Acteon and Buckthorn. Does the Minister agree that if we on this side of the House are in complete agreement with the noble Lord, Lord Sikka, the Government have got to be in trouble, not least on this celebratory day of Jackdaw? To provide a parallel example we all understand, if Waitrose buys a cargo of bananas but the customers decide to switch to M&S, by the same Ofgem logic then M&S should compensate Waitrose. How does the Minister defend what Martin Lewis calls the “switching penalty”, which would add yet more costs to the households of this country, where electricity prices are already higher than in any EU country?
Baroness Curran (Lab)
I thank the noble Lord for this question. In my time in the House of Lords, and in politics, it is quite an experience to see the noble Lord, Lord Moynihan, agreeing with the noble Lord, Lord Sikka. Is not politics an interesting journey? This is a serious point, and one that I have given some consideration to in the time I have been looking at this. I have no interest in bailing out suppliers and companies that do not work, but, ultimately, we must protect consumers. It is about that balanced argument, and it will be interesting to see what Ofgem comes forward with. I point the noble Lord to former days, when he perhaps agreed less with the noble Lord, Lord Sikka, when his Government introduced this mechanism and it was regarded as being effective because of the risk to suppliers—and look what happened.
Lord Redwood (Con)
What other action will the government regulator take to get down the sky-high electricity prices, which are still going up despite a temporary cut in VAT?
Baroness Curran (Lab)
I have answered questions in this House a number of times in my new role, and every single time I have had a question from the noble Lord, Lord Redwood. If I had not had one now, I would have been quite disappointed, I must say. In all those questions, we have talked about the volatility of prices. He knows my argument on this, which is a key argument this Government are putting forward, particularly on this, the day of the Jackdaw announcement. We need to tackle the volatility of the gas market. We are incredibly exposed to that, and it has a knock-on effect for British energy consumers and energy bill payers. The way to do that is through energy security, and building and protecting homegrown energy and increasing electrification is the way to energy security.
Lord Foulkes of Cumnock (Lab Co-op)
My Lords, I warmly welcome the decision on the Jackdaw gas field. Will the Minister confirm that this will give a great boost to the Scottish economy, particularly in the north-east, around Aberdeen?
Baroness Curran (Lab)
This is my first experience at the Dispatch Box of being asked such a positive question and being able to give such a positive answer. As has been made clear today, the common-sense choice is for gas to be homegrown rather than imported, if that is at all possible. It is a great boost for the Scottish economy and for the UK economy, of which we are a very proud part. It brings jobs and security. Because of the nature of the court decision, work can get under way and we can bring back those jobs and start getting investment under way. I am very pleased to have had this positive experience.
Baroness McIntosh of Pickering (Con)
My Lords, do the Government not also have a role to play, because, on consumer choice, we are so often encouraged to switch supplier? We cannot just leave it to an arm’s-length body such as Ofgem. It is a residual government responsibility as well.
Baroness Curran (Lab)
In principle yes. In the balanced argument that I was addressing, it is vital that we make sure people have information about switching and get the tariffs that work best for them. Encouraging consumers to do that is part of our responsibility. We all know that we have a huge problem with energy prices. Affordability is at the centre of what this Government want to do, and the Prime Minister emphasised that emphatically today. We know that we have more to do, but, in the meantime, that choice is one mechanism consumers can use to help with affordability.
Lord Watts (Lab)
My Lords, is it not the case that successive Governments have given more and more power to regulators and, in most cases, those regulators have not protected consumers? There is a real issue around whether Parliament needs to get more control over regulators and make them accountable to the public.
Baroness Curran (Lab)
Yes, indeed, and that is an ongoing discussion about governance, and one that we must and should continue to have. Ofgem is directly accountable to Parliament; it lays its annual report every year in Parliament and is in front of Select Committees regularly, but I take the general point. In government—I am sure this feeling would be shared across the House—you get frustrated because you cannot solve some of the problems you are questioned and challenged on. I would be hungry for powers that can solve problems. If I thought there was an opportunity to do that, I would take it, but sometimes it is right that it is a regulator. Sometimes—I am sure that the noble Lord agrees with me, unless he has completely changed—there are times when Governments should not intervene in certain mechanisms.
Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5421861.