Prisons: Foreign National Offenders
Thursday, 15 October 2026
Contributions
Question
Asked by
Baroness Monckton of Dallington Forest
To ask His Majesty’s Government what steps they are taking to reduce the number of foreign national offenders held in prisons in England and Wales.
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Ministry of Justice (Lord Lemos) (Lab)
My Lords, within our first two years this Government increased returns of foreign national offenders by 41% compared to the last two years of the previous Government. Between 1 August 2025 and 31 July 2026, more than 3,000 foreign offenders were removed directly from prison under the early removal scheme. Next year, new powers will enable some determinate-sentence foreign national offenders to be deported immediately after sentencing, and we have established a cross-government taskforce to maximise removals.
Baroness Monckton of Dallington Forest (Con)
I thank the noble Lord for his response. However, at a time of chronic prison overcrowding, over 12% of our prison population are foreign national offenders. How many of this cohort who are liable to deportation remain in the United Kingdom due to Article 8 claims and human rights claims? Where this number is not available, why does the Home Office not have this data?
Lord Lemos (Lab)
My Lords, the information that the noble Baroness refers to is held by the Home Office but is not in a reportable format for data extraction purposes. The UK is committed to its human rights obligations at home and abroad, including the European Convention on Human Rights. However, that commitment does not mean complacency. The Chiinău declaration, adopted in May, recognises that the ECHR must not unnecessarily constrain the ability of sovereign states to expel serious criminals, and the Government are also legislating in the Immigration and Asylum Bill currently before the other place.
Baroness Brinton (LD)
My Lords, the Ministry of Justice’s new policy and guidance on foreign nationals in prison, implemented six months ago, is helpfully detailed about what needs to be done to speed up removals. The “Outcomes” section specifically says that there should be: “Increased uptake of voluntary returns … Faster immigration process times … A higher percentage of foreign national prisoners removed under the Early Removal Scheme … Fewer failed removals”, all of which is laudable. However, has the Prison Service been given specific extra resources to achieve those outcomes?
Lord Lemos (Lab)
I thank the noble Baroness for that question. It is an excellent summary of the approach we are taking. HMPPS has a very substantial budget, and we have been working on advancing the deportation of foreign national offenders for many years. The fact is that it has not come down as a proportion. That is why the noble Baroness is right that we need to speed the process up, and that is why we are legislating. We shall of course seek to find the resources to do that.
Lord Garnier (Con)
My Lords, most foreign national prisoners seem to come from Albania, Ireland, Poland, Romania, India and Jamaica. These are all countries with which we have friendly bilateral relations. When did the Minister, or any of his colleagues in his department or in the Home Office or in the Foreign Office, last have a direct conversation with the Governments of those countries better to empty our prisons of overstaying foreign national prisoners?
Lord Lemos (Lab)
Our position on this is that we will use prisoner transfer agreements where they exist and with those countries where we can make such agreements. However, as the noble and learned Lord knows, they are not an easy or quick route. Our commitment is therefore that we will deport foreign national offenders as soon as they have been sentenced. We introduced that in the Sentencing Act and we will commence it in the New Year. We are very serious about this. Of course we will work with our bilateral partners internationally, but it is our commitment that where foreigners commit offences, except for very serious offences, they will be deported.
Viscount Goschen (Con)
The Minister told my noble friend that his department had the data she requested but, unfortunately, it was not in a publishable form. Could he explain that further and perhaps go back to his department, ask it to put that data into publishable form and come back to the House with the numbers that my noble friend requested?
Lord Lemos (Lab)
I am happy to ask the Home Office again; it is not my department, but I speak for the Government. However, my view remains, in relation to putting out data that is misleading or unreliable—I am sorry, but hollow laughter does not help to get to the truth—this is a difficult enough debate in the public square without misleading information.
Lord Keen of Elie (Con)
My Lords, what consideration have His Majesty’s Government given to employing our Brexit freedoms to impose visa controls, sanctions and tariffs against third-party countries that will not accept back the foreign national criminals in our prisons?
Lord Lemos (Lab)
I have already said in response to the noble and learned Lord, Lord Garnier, that our policy is that we intend to deport people who are foreign national offenders. It is not a question of whether countries will accept them. Our intention is to deport them. I have already explained the difficulties with prisoner transfer agreements. By all means we can explore these other routes, but the policy will remain that, if foreign national offenders commit offences in this country then our intention is to deport them, except in the case of very serious offences.
Lord Forbes of Newcastle (Lab)
My Lords, does my noble friend agree that to deport foreign nationals before the end of their sentence served in this country without a cast-iron guarantee that they will serve out the remainder of their sentence in their country of destination would be a travesty of justice for their victims?
Lord Lemos (Lab)
With respect, no, I do not agree with that comment from my noble friend. Of course people who commit offences in this country should be punished, and that is our intention, but, as I have said, we intend to deport people. I do not regard that as a travesty of justice. Being deported from this country and not being allowed to return is a punishment in itself, and that is what we shall do.
Lord Harper (Con)
My Lords, if I may take the Minister back to the original Question and then the follow-up from my noble friend, no one is asking the Government to release inaccurate or misleading data. On the question, the Minister said the Home Office has the data but not in a form capable of being released. The Minister should make sure that it is capable of being released and that it is not misleading, and then make sure that that information is available to both Houses of Parliament and the public. I ask him again: will he go back to the department, make sure that that is done and come back to this House with a commitment and a timetable for producing that important information of enormous public interest?
Lord Lemos (Lab)
We will, of course, discuss with the Home Office and across government how we can make sure, in the interests of transparency and in the interest, if I may say so, of a well-informed public debate, that we get the information out there, but, as I have said, we are not going to put out information that is not in a reportable format. I will go back and ask again, but I doubt that the position is going to change. On the ECHR, I realise now that if you aspire to power in the Tory party then you have to advertise your commitment to getting rid of that convention. That is not this Government’s policy. We are committed to the ECHR.
Baroness Butler-Sloss (CB)
May I ask the Minister what will happen to prisoners who ought to be deported but it is not safe to send them back to their country of origin?
Lord Lemos (Lab)
It is precisely with that in mind that my right honourable friend the Home Secretary is clarifying this in the Immigration and Asylum Bill, so that we can put in place a public interest test to ensure that we can make the right arrangements for these deportations, including respect for their rights under the ECHR.
Lord Watts (Lab)
My Lords, can the Minister explain whether this system of storage of information is new, or whether it was in place for the 14 years that the Tories were in Government?
Lord Lemos (Lab)
It is fair to say that the previous Government did not release this data either.
Lord Bellingham (Con)
My Lords, the Minister has raised the ECHR on a number of occasions, and he himself pointed out some of the constraints that it imposes. He went on to say that it was this Government’s intention to push for reforms of the convention. Can the Minister elaborate on that, and does he really believe in his heart of hearts that our co-partners will allow these changes to take place?
Lord Lemos (Lab)
I am very happy to elaborate on that; I do believe it in my heart of hearts. I also believe in the political declaration from 46 member countries of the Council of Europe which recognised, in the political declaration from the Chiinău meeting—a good word, which I enjoy using from the Dispatch Box—that the ECHR must not unnecessarily constrain the ability of sovereign states to protect their borders or expel serious criminals, and that the threshold for Article 3 in relation to “inhuman or degrading treatment” must remain high and constant. This Government feel that they have done a lot to put that on the agenda of the Council of Europe, and we have received a lot of support for it. So, yes, I do feel optimistic about it.
Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5417785.