Topical Questions
Tuesday, 17 November 2026
Contributions
Stuart Andrew (Daventry) (Con)Conservative
T1. If she will make a statement on her departmental responsibilities.
The Minister for Climate Transition (Katie White)Labour
The climate crisis is a threat to our national security, our economic stability, and the safety of people in Britain and around the world. That is why this week the Secretary of State for Energy Security and Net Zero is leading negotiations in Turkey at COP31. That comes alongside the Prime Minister’s announcement of two major offshore wind projects, creating hundreds of jobs in the east of England, and securing our energy future. Britain has also agreed to increase electricity’s share of global energy consumption to 35% by 2035, accelerating the global shift to clean electricity and appointing a new special representative for climate security. Every step we take to tackle the climate crisis is a step towards greater energy independence, stronger national security, and hope for future generations.
Stuart AndrewConservative
In September I asked the Prime Minister to review the Government’s approach to solar development on agricultural land, particularly when my constituency has so many warehouses without a single solar panel on them, so that we safeguard both our food and our energy security. He said it was a “good suggestion” that he would take up, but just five weeks later the Government approved a major huge solar farm in my constituency on prime agricultural land. What discussions have taken place across Government since the Prime Minister gave me that commitment?
Katie WhiteLabour
In all our proposals solar will take up only 1% of our land. It is one of the cheapest forms of renewable energy—I know that Conservative Members like to use that adjective on a number of occasions. We are pursuing rooftop solar and land-based solar at the same time, and with our colleagues in the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, we are working across Government on the land-use framework to ensure that we prioritise areas of land.
Graeme Downie (Dunfermline and Dollar) (Lab)Labour
T2. Ofgem’s debt relief scheme could help clear energy crisis debts for up to 2.4 million households. Sadly, that scheme does not start until the spring, after this winter, by which time we will likely have seen a further increase in energy debt, and Ofgem has limited information about households in Scotland that are in energy debt. Will the Minister do everything that she can do to work with Ofgem and others to reduce energy debt, so that we can tackle that as quickly as possible and help people keep their bills under control?
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Energy Security and Net Zero (Ms Polly Billington)Labour
My hon. Friend will be aware of the new debt strategy, which was announced in the Budget, that will act as a circuit breaker. That strategy is expected to save a typical household almost £30 by 2030. At the moment, on average everyone is paying roughly £60 a year to service the debt in the energy system. That needs to be broken and that is what the energy circuit breaker will do.
Mr SpeakerSpeaker
I call the shadow Secretary of State.
Andrew Bowie (West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine) (Con)Conservative
What is more important to Ministers—the lives and livelihoods of thousands of oil and gas workers, or the views of 75 Labour Back Benchers?
The Minister for Energy (Michael Shanks)Labour
In the past two and a half years, we have been very clear that oil and gas will remain a hugely important part of our energy mix, and it is critical that we put in place a credible plan to support that workforce into the jobs of the future, while supporting oil and gas in the short term. The answer is to invest as heavily as we possibly can in renewables, carbon capture, hydrogen and other technologies in order to support them. That is what we have been doing—it is what pragmatism means—and why we made the decision on Jackdaw, as well as announcing record investment in renewables. We have to do both and I hope the hon. Gentleman will support that.
Andrew BowieConservative
Thanks to The Times today, we know that the Minister has signed off the Government’s impact assessment that showed £2.5 billion being lost to the British economy as a result of their ban on licences. We know that impact assessment showed that jobs are being lost because of their ban on licences. The Minister signed off a plan to ban licences knowing the pain and damage that would cause, but he had a chance to redeem himself by making a positive case for Rosebank and taking on the ignorance of a minority of Labour MPs, whose sole reason for coming into politics seems to be to make Britain poorer and weaker.
Michael ShanksLabour
The hon. Gentleman’s last comment demeans him and I will not respond to it. In the interest of everyone concerned, I will not risk the process that is under way with Rosebank from the Dispatch Box or anywhere else, and we will stand up our decision on that in due course. He is wrong to take one side of the impact assessment and, as his party is increasingly doing, completely ignore the other side, which is the significant cost—up to 3.3% of GDP by 2050—of the impact of climate change if we do not act now. It is important that we do both parts of this.
Andrew Lewin (Welwyn Hatfield) (Lab)Labour
T7. I congratulate the Government on the major announcement on offshore wind off the Norfolk coast, which has the potential to benefit 3 million households. Will the Minister update us on the accompanying work on the grid? How are we investing in it and ensuring grid connections can speed up, so that clean and green power can start flowing to households in the east of England and across the country as fast as possible?
Michael ShanksLabour
My hon. Friend is absolutely right that we are making a £12 billion investment in offshore wind, one of the biggest investments in clean energy in this country’s history, creating jobs across the east of England and the UK. He is right to say that we have to fix years of under-investment in the grid to remove barriers for network connections, so that the clean power can flow to homes and businesses and we can bring down bills as a result. We are reforming the connections queue, building the grid that is necessary for the future, and making up for decades of under-investment by the Conservatives.
Ayoub Khan (Birmingham Perry Barr) (Ind)Independent
T3. In my constituency, 86% of households are already experiencing fuel poverty, so it is no surprise that families, not just in my constituency but up and down the country, will be deciding between heating and eating. I welcome the Government’s initiatives, including the crisis and resilience support as well as £100 for certain households, but that will simply not be enough when energy bills rocket up by more than £500 later this year. Will the Minister meet me and leaders of Birmingham city council to see how we can assist local residents in Birmingham?
Ms BillingtonLabour
We are aware how appalling the situation is in relation to global energy prices, and that is one reason that we have created the household energy payment, taken the VAT off electricity, and put the crisis and resilience support aside, particularly for people who use heating oil. We also have the warm homes plan, on which the Minister for Energy worked very hard, to improve the quality of people’s homes, which will be vital in the hon. Gentleman’s constituency. I am happy to meet him. That stuff will happen through devolution, the warm homes plan and the warm homes agency, but to get where we need to be, profound retail-market reform will be required as well.
Pam Cox (Colchester) (Lab)Labour
T8. Like many others, I welcome the announcement of the Vanguard wind farm off the East Anglian coast, which will further boost the pivotal place that the east of England plays in our energy security. Can Ministers confirm the Government’s commitment to renewables, clean energy and fighting climate change?
Michael ShanksLabour
Yes, I absolutely can. I welcome my hon. Friend emphasising the historic investment in Vanguard East and West off the East Anglian coast, and we remain absolutely committed to the deployment of clean energy as the route to get us off fossil fuels and protect households. That is a hugely important example of what is now more than £110 billion of private investment flowing into the UK, with jobs and opportunities in every single part of this country to build the clean power system of the future, and we will continue to back it.
Alex Brewer (North East Hampshire) (LD)Liberal Democrat
T4. Following a summer of wildfires and many community screenings of the national emergency briefing across North East Hampshire, constituents have told me that they want faster action on climate change. What further steps is the Secretary of State taking to accelerate investment in renewable energy and ensure that local communities feel the benefit where it is built?
Katie WhiteLabour
I believe the hon. Lady was at the debate yesterday in Westminster Hall, which was absolutely packed. That is a testament to the campaigners, who have been working in constituencies up and down the country. It was great to be able to announce that we are meeting next week with the national emergency briefing to see what next steps we can take. Through our Energy Independence Bill, we are introducing community benefit—an ownership scheme that will be a great way for communities to see the direct, positive implications of the transition.
Josh Newbury (Cannock Chase) (Lab)Labour
Biomethane is great for farmers, households and businesses, but it is sometimes dismissed as a niche form of energy that has peaked. The National Energy System Operator has said that the sector could grow tenfold, and there is more than £1 billion-worth of pent-up investment in the Ofgem queue. Will the Minister look at getting the future biomethane framework out the door so that we can back this sector to reach its full potential?
Katie WhiteLabour
I am getting quite a reputation for my interest in biomethane; I had an excellent visit most recently to the Severn Trent Green Power facility in east Birmingham. My hon. Friend is right to highlight the contribution that biomethane can make in decarbonisation and energy security. The Government recognise the importance of providing greater certainty, and we will do that as soon as possible.
Mr Peter Bedford (Mid Leicestershire) (Con)Conservative
T5. Under the smart export guarantee, a supplier can pay a household just a penny for every unit of solar exported to the grid. Many of my constituents are doing their bit for energy resilience through home domestic solar. If the Government want more domestic solar, will the Minister look at a fairer pricing model for it?
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Energy Security and Net Zero (Martin McCluskey)Labour
I thank the hon. Member’s constituents who are interested in exporting to the grid. We are reviewing the smart energy guarantee, and we will come forward with proposals in due course.
Terry Jermy (South West Norfolk) (Lab)Labour
Many households in rural areas such as South West Norfolk are already paying a rural premium, with increased costs linked to rurality. Will the Minister commit to considering what more can be done to tackle the combined risk of poorly insulated homes, low wages and high running costs impacting on rural households?
Ms BillingtonLabour
As my hon. Friend knows, tackling affordability is the No. 1 priority of this Government. Fuel poverty affects 13.8% of rural households, compared with 9.4% of households overall. That is one reason we have made commitments through the household energy payment, the warm homes plan, abolishing gas standing charges and so on, as well as the £9,000 for the boiler upgrade scheme. We know that that is important, but we also know that local authorities have a responsibility to use the crisis and resilience fund properly. I am aware that the Reform council in Norfolk is not doing that, and we would like it to do so as fast as possible.
Rupert Lowe (Great Yarmouth) (Restore Britain)Restore Britain
T6. On 8 and 9 November, wind supplied just 2% of Britain’s electricity, with gas accounting for 63%. The grid operator warned publicly that spare capacity was thin. Ofgem says that without the Belgian interconnector deal, we could face a negative gas supply margin in very rare stress conditions; in a gas emergency, it assumes that three quarters of the shortfall is managed by switching off gas power stations, just when cold weather drives up electricity demand and puts the grid at risk. Has NESO costed the electricity consequences, up to and including—
Mr SpeakerSpeaker
Order. I call the Minister.
Michael ShanksLabour
I think I can probably guess the rest of that tirade. The hon. Gentleman is wrong on all counts. We rightly have as the highest priority of this Government our security of supply for both gas and electricity. We have published the winter outlooks, which show exactly how we will meet the supply requirements. We take this issue very seriously, and he is absolutely wrong to come to this place and scaremonger about something as important as that. We have resilient supplies in this country, and we are seeking to make them even more resilient through the exact investment that he opposes.
Gurinder Singh Josan (Smethwick) (Lab)Labour
Reindustrialising our communities is incredibly important to my constituency, which has a proud industrial heritage that continues today. What steps is the Minister taking to ensure that the green power revolution will bring new manufacturing investment, skilled jobs and apprenticeship opportunities to Smethwick?
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Energy Security and Net Zero (Blair McDougall)Labour
My hon. Friend is exactly right: the task for this Government in reindustrialising is to build on the deep heritage in communities such as his, and to bring it up to date through investment in clean power. To that end, there are now 1.1 million jobs in net zero, with more than £1 billion of gross value added, and there is now more than £110 billion of private investment, all of which is connected to jobs in constituencies such as his.
David Davis (Goole and Pocklington) (Con)Conservative
T9. Solar farm developers are currently trying to blanket my constituency with 10,800 acres of panels—an area the size of Oxford under black plastic. Because they are classed as nationally significant infrastructure projects, the plans bypass local democracy. The Minister has talked about this being 1% of the country, but that 1% is concentrated in small areas, so will he work with the Minister for Housing and Planning to urgently review the planning framework in order to ensure that the cumulative impact is taken into account before these projects are approved?
Michael ShanksLabour
Cumulative impact is already taken into account—it is a key part of the nationally significant infrastructure project programme process—and even in our most ambitious scenarios, if solar is deployed at the scale we hope it will be, it will take up to 0.6% of total agricultural land, so it is a small amount of land. I appreciate the right hon. Gentleman’s point about concentration, but that is exactly what the planning process is there to assess.
Kevin Bonavia (Stevenage) (Lab)Labour
There are over 4,000 businesses in my constituency of Stevenage and the villages, most of which are small and medium-sized enterprises. They are really feeling the pressure from the conflict and stand-off with Iran, so what can my hon. Friend do to help relieve some of that pressure?
Blair McDougallLabour
My hon. Friend is absolutely right. At the moment, for example, applications are open for the British industrial competitiveness scheme, which will particularly help smaller manufacturing businesses. As the Prime Minister has set out, we as a Government also need to move quickly on electrification, to help businesses such as those in my hon. Friend’s constituency cut their costs and become more efficient.
Helen Morgan (North Shropshire) (LD)Liberal Democrat
T10. National Grid is planning a huge substation in North Shropshire, and the process of community engagement has been really poor—I only found out by looking on NESO’s website, despite having explicitly and repeatedly asked it about scale, and the local community are largely in the dark about what is proposed. The Minister has already agreed to meet me to discuss the appropriateness of the site. Will he please expedite that meeting and add the community engagement process to the agenda?
Michael ShanksLabour
When I meet the hon. Lady, she will be in charge of the agenda, and I will be very happy to have that conversation. I expect everyone who is building infrastructure in the UK, including National Grid, to take community engagement seriously—it is a critical part of the planning process. The planning system only works if communities have a chance to voice their views, but I am not directly responsible for the siting of infrastructure. I am happy to pick that up with the hon. Lady during our meeting.
Becky Gittins (Clwyd East) (Lab)Labour
Yesterday, alongside many MPs from across the House, I took part in the Westminster Hall debate about the national emergency briefing, and I am very grateful to the Minister for her time. I recently held a summit in my constituency with local environmental groups, where we talked about how we can work together to spread information and build consensus on tackling the climate crisis. Can the Minister set out what the Government are doing to that end?
Katie WhiteLabour
I thank my hon. Friend for her question and for attending yesterday’s Westminster Hall debate—it was the busiest Westminster Hall debate I have ever seen, and the cross-party consensus on this issue was really inspiring. I pay tribute to the campaigners at the national emergency briefing for all they have done, and I look forward to meeting them next week and pursuing our youth climate and nature panel in the months ahead.
Dr Kieran Mullan (Bexhill and Battle) (Con)Conservative
The potential for deep geothermal projects to provide transition jobs for oil and gas workers in this country continues to be tragically under-utilised. Will the Minister meet me and the hon. Member for Bishop Auckland (Dr Rushworth), as co-chairs of the APPG on deep geothermal, to discuss how we can use a North sea wealth fund to fix that?
Katie WhiteLabour
I thank the hon. Member for his question and for his championing of that technology—it is really important that, in order to achieve net zero, we look at how we can accelerate the potential of all low-carbon technologies. I am pleased to see the innovation there has been in both heat and power applications. Geothermal technologies that generate electricity are eligible for contracts for difference, and I would be very happy to meet the hon. Member and my hon. Friend the Member for Bishop Auckland (Dr Rushworth) to discuss this further.
Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5439278.