Town and Country Planning (Fees for Applications, Deemed Applications, Requests and Site Visits) (England) (Amendment and Transitional Provision) Regulations 2026
Tuesday, 13 October 2026
Contributions
Considered in Grand Committee
Moved by
Lord Wilson of Sedgefield
That the Grand Committee do consider the Town and Country Planning (Fees for Applications, Deemed Applications, Requests and Site Visits) (England) (Amendment and Transitional Provision) Regulations 2026. Relevant document: 11th Report from the Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee
Lord in Waiting/Government Whip (Lord Wilson of Sedgefield) (Lab)
My Lords, these regulations were laid before the House on 16 June and, following minor corrections, re-laid on 1 September. If Parliament approves, the regulations will come into force on 8 December. I start by providing some context and background. A well-functioning planning system is essential to delivering the homes, infrastructure and economic growth that this country needs. Local planning authorities sit at the heart of that system. They make decisions on the development of our towns, cities and communities but, for many years, planning departments have been operating with insufficient resources. There remains a significant gap between the income generated through planning application fees and the cost of providing planning application services. That underfunding places pressure on local planning authorities’ ability to recruit and retain skilled staff, invest in modern systems and deliver timely decisions. These regulations address that challenge by providing local planning authorities with an immediate increase in fee income. Enabling authorities to recover a greater proportion of their costs will help strengthen capacity and capability across planning services, supporting more efficient and responsive decision-making for applicants and communities alike. These regulations also form part of a broader programme of planning reform. Through the Planning and Infrastructure Act 2025, Parliament provided powers that will enable local planning authorities, subject to appropriate safeguards, to set or vary planning fees locally. The Government intend to bring forward regulations to implement those powers later this year. These regulations provide an immediate boost in resourcing for local planning authorities and a robust national baseline from which future local fee-setting powers will operate. We consulted on increasing planning fees between March and June 2026. There was broad support across the sector for increasing fees, provided that the income is used to improve the quality, capacity and performance of planning services. Developer representatives, including the Home Builders Federation, have emphasised that underresourced planning departments are a significant barrier to housing delivery and have called for greater planning capacity and performance. The Government expect local planning authorities to reinvest this income in their planning and application services, helping to deliver those performance improvements and support a more effective planning system. I turn briefly to the details. The regulations make four principal changes. First, they establish a revised set of national fees, which we refer to as a national fees schedule, by increasing all existing fees payable to local planning authorities, by varying amounts, to achieve up to approximately 90% recovery of estimated costs. These increases are informed by evidence gathered through a benchmarking exercise undertaken by the Local Government Association’s planning advisory service. That work showed that every application category currently operates below cost recovery, with funding gaps ranging from around 18% to more than 60%. Increasing all fees up to approximately 90% of estimated costs will provide a meaningful and immediate boost for local planning authorities. We are not increasing fees to 100% of estimated costs, as this would risk over-recovery for some authorities. We also want to incentivise local planning authorities to make efficiency gains through process and service enhancements.
Secondly, the regulations simplify and modernise a number of fee categories, including by removing some existing baseline fees for larger developments. These changes are intended to make the fee regime clearer and easier to navigate.
Thirdly, the regulations introduce a standard fee of £310 for prior approval applications that currently attract no fee. Prior approval applications require local planning authorities to devote time and resources to their assessment and determination, and it is therefore appropriate that applicants make a contribution towards those costs. As part of that third change, the regulations also enable a fee to apply to prior approval applications relating to larger electricity substations. The statutory instrument introducing these changes was laid in Parliament on 30 September and comes into effect on 21 October.
Finally, the regulations correct an omission in the existing indexation provisions. This amendment ensures that mixed-use outline application fees are subject to annual inflationary increases in the same way as all other planning application fees.
In summary, these regulations are an important step towards a better-resourced and more effective planning system. They will provide local planning authorities with an immediate increase in funding, help strengthen planning capacity and capability, and establish the foundation for future local fee-setting powers. Together, these reforms will support faster, more reliable planning services that are better able to deliver the homes, infrastructure and economic growth that our country needs. I beg to move.
Lord Fuller (Con)
My Lords, I will be brief. This is just another step in the nationalisation of planning. We have seen it already and, in two weeks, the national scheme of delegation is going to take planning further away from the people it affects the most. Only last week, I was asked by a resident in my own ward—I am a councillor in South Norfolk—to look at a barn. The delegated scheme report said that it was inconsequential and that there would be no overshadowing because the building was only two storeys high and right next door, on the southern side, to an existing dwelling-house. The proprietor of that dwelling-house is horrified because the barn is 10 metres high—the size of a warehouse—completely overshadowing that person’s property. I do not want to get into the whys and wherefores and negotiate this particular complaint, but it demonstrates that taking power away from local councillors and putting excessive trust in the scheme of delegation makes planning worse. As I look through these draft regulations, I see increases in the charges of between 20% and 30%. That is quite a burden on top of the fees from the Building Safety Act and the community infrastructure levy, new charges from the mayoral community infrastructure levy and new taxes, from 1 January, on steel and cement, which will increase the cost of building for small builders. This is on top of the new fees announced for the EDPs under the Planning and Infrastructure Act for nutrient neutrality and biodiversity net gain. These regulations look at planning fees in isolation; they do not take into account the enormous cumulative increase in the burden faced by developers, whose costs have gone up by 40%, while real-terms house prices are down by 20% over 10 years. I do not think those applicants in a listed building or in a conservation area who are applying for a certificate of lawful use would mind, if there was not the other side. Although 90% cost recovery seems like a good thing, it ignores the increasing use of pre-application fees and pre-consultation advice, whereby applicants are encouraged to speak to planning officers on a chargeable basis beforehand. That was a good idea to begin with, but it has just become another profit centre, with generic advice given to applicants and no certainty—and certainly no reliability, to pick up the Minister’s point—in helping people to get it right first time. What we see here are, in themselves, relatively modest increases in planning fees, but they add to the total burden on development, imposing additional layers and more complexity, not less. It makes the Government’s task of building 1.5 million homes in this Parliament—a target they are missing already by a country mile—even harder. I would have had more sympathy if we could have said that we had greater certainty, or made the system easier to navigate. Let us see it in the context of the entire fee load—including building safety, CIL and those other points I have made—rather than having just this, which chips away once more at the commercial viability of building the homes our nation needs.
Baroness Pinnock (LD)
I do not want to go back into a debate on the Planning and Infrastructure Act. I remind the Committee that I am a councillor with an interest in planning. We Liberal Democrats do not take the view of the noble Lord, Lord Fuller, that regulation is to be swept away to make it less costly for housebuilders. I hope we have learned the lesson that, where regulations were swept away or ignored, it led to 72 people dying. We always ought to have that at the forefront of our mind.
Lord Fuller (Con)
I just clarify to the noble Baroness that I did not call for regulations to be swept away, but said that the costs of those regulations should be contained so that they did not become such a burden on schemes that nothing gets done. Collectively and cumulatively, we are not getting the homes built that the nation needs because of the policy inflation, cost inflation and regulatory burdens. The Home Builders Federation has said in the last week that additional regulatory costs of building a home have added £38,000 in the last six years; for flats, it is a further £22,000 over and above that. At some stage, we are going to have to call a stop to this inflation, or absolutely nothing will get built at all. That does not mean holding back on regulation, but constraining the cost.
Baroness Pinnock (LD)
Well, there we go.
Lord Fuller (Con)
They are the numbers.
Baroness Pinnock (LD)
On the one hand, the noble Lord, Lord Fuller, decries centralisation of planning, as I do, but wants to have regulations without them costing anything. That is the conundrum of those always saying to get rid of red tape; they never ever tell us which regulations they will sweep away and what will be the cost on people when they do. Let us go back to what this instrument is about: planning fees. That 90% cost recovery will provide an incentive to planning services to digitise and streamline their processes, what about those planning services where that has already taken place? They will find it really difficult to find that extra 10% saving, which is being proposed here. I would welcome the regulations enabling planning services to have more variation in planning fees within strict limits. The table provided is fine as it is but, when it gets to very large planning applications, it probably fails to reflect the cost of planning applications. A very large commercial development would be one example of that. That is one comment. The second is that where I agreed with the noble Lord, Lord Fuller, was on pre-application fees. As a local councillor, I attend pre-application discussions with developers, and it takes planning officers time to consider an outline case brought by a developer, and so a pre-application fee would be appropriate. Some consideration of that would be valuable, whether or not it was then deducted from a final fee. Having some sort of pre-app fee would be good. I agree with the prior approval fee, and I am glad that that has been introduced. I will make a final point about the centralisation of planning. The Government’s argument, which I partly understand, is about making it more consistent across the country. What I would welcome is for local authorities to be required to create and agree on a local plan and local plan policies, because that is where changes can be made, such as not having a 10-metre barn within a particular distance—that is where you could do it. It seems to me that the Government are missing a trick here by not making local plans a requirement of every local planning authority. Otherwise, give us 100%, not 90%.
Lord Jamieson (Con)
That sounds like an exam, my Lords. I thank the Minister for bringing forward these regulations for scrutiny and my noble friend Lord Fuller for his comments—as ever, he stole a little bit of my thunder. I agree, as ever, with the noble Baroness, Lady Pinnock, on some things and not on some others. This SI ultimately increases planning fees. I understand that the aim of the policy is to allow authorities to recover more money so they can provide a better planning service and deliver planning applications more swiftly. We welcome a simplification of the fee categories and the improvements to the planning system performance, but we have concerns about how those increased costs will impact developers, and therefore ultimately the cost of building a home and the price that someone will have to pay for a home—or, as my noble friend Lord Fuller suggested, the home not getting built. We believe that the cost of the planning system overall needs to come down. The Government seem to be going about this the wrong way. When a system becomes too cumbersome, too complex and too difficult, you do not charge higher fees—you fix the system. We need a system that is simpler, more consistent, more coherent, more proportionate and speedier. That would be better for all parties, for developers and for local home owners, who would know where they stood; we would not get such a complex system and it would be cheaper. It is not only the developers I have spoken to who would be in favour of a simpler, more consistent and more coherent system; several of the planning officers I speak to have complained that the increasing complexity of the system—the need for more reports and so forth—makes their job more of a processing agent rather than a planner, which is what they were trained to do and where they add most value. As my noble friend Lord Fuller raised, the Government continue to layer costs on building. The sums are not insignificant even for this: £144 million per year, according to the impact assessment. If you apply that just to the Government’s slim-chance target of 300,000 homes per year, that is about £500 a home. I know it does not apply just to that; I use it for purely illustrative purposes.
Is it surprising that Taylor Wimpey, a major housing developer, has said that it does not intend to build any more homes in London once its current projects are completed? Its chief executive has said:
“Baseline viability is, I think, fundamentally broken in London. The reward for undertaking what is a very high-risk form of development in London has just evaporated”.
The Government’s housing target requires 88,000 houses a year to be built in London, with a national target for 1.5 million homes over the course of this Parliament. Yet estimates indicate that the cost of building housing is highest in London. In many instances, if someone was to comply with all the regulations, it is simply not viable at the prices that people can afford to pay in London. Can the Minister explain what further policy changes the Government intend to make to improve the economic viability of those much-needed homes in London?
The noble Baroness, Lady Pinnock, raised the question, fairly, of the importance of regulation—we genuinely do need regulation to ensure safety following Grenfell. The problem is that we have too much regulation: it is too complex and too difficult. What we need is good regulation; that is what we need to address. We cannot keep piling regulations, levies and so forth on developments.
The noble Baroness raised a second good question: what regulation would you remove and change? Fortunately for her, I have an excellent book written by my friend in the other place, Kemi, that I am more than happy to share to explain what these things would be. I would not even mind if the noble Baroness plagiarised itt.
Baroness Pinnock (LD)
I am so lucky.
Lord Jamieson (Con)
Enough of the joviality. The key point that we are trying to say here is that this is indicative of the Government’s approach. Although we can have sympathy and we can understand in isolation, this is part of a package of continuing to seek higher costs, higher levies and more regulation, rather than addressing the underlying issue of a planning system that does not work. You should not have to hit a nail in with a bigger hammer; you should drill a hole through it—I am not sure that is the world’s greatest analogy, but hey. I would appreciate it if the Minister could explain what the Government are doing to reverse this approach. I look forward to hearing how they are going to improve regulations, lower costs and get Britain building again.
Lord Wilson of Sedgefield (Lab)
I thank noble Lords for their contributions. I will try to answer as many of the questions and the points that were raised that I can. In response to the noble Lord, Lord Fuller, although I cannot go into any discussion on the barn, we recognise that developers must meet a range of costs when bringing forward development and that viability remains an important consideration. I think we all accept that. However, planning application fees, even with these changes, are a very small proportion of overall development costs: less than 1%. That is what we are taking about: just 1%. The purpose of these regulations is to ensure that planning application services are properly resourced to process applications efficiently. A better-funded planning system can reduce delays, increase certainty and improve the overall development process—this is something that developers themselves are saying to the Government. It is absolutely right that the money raised should be ploughed back into the planning process to make it more efficient. The Government’s planning reforms share a common objective—creating a faster, more effective and more predictable planning system. Local fee-setting is designed to improve the resourcing of planning application services. Planning committee reforms are intended to improve the efficiency and consistency of decision-making. These reforms serve different purposes but are complementary; together, they will help to ensure that planning services are better resourced, more effective and better able to support housing infrastructure and economic growth and the additional burden on top of pre-application fees. Planning application fees fund the statutory planning application service and are set through legislation. Pre-application advice and planning performance agreements are different. They are discretionary services that applicants can choose whether to use. Many applicants find these services valuable because they can help to identify and resolve issues at an early stage, improve the quality of applications and support the effective handling of the complex development proposals. The noble Baroness, Lady Pinnock, and the noble Lord, Lord Jamieson, mentioned ring-fencing. The Government are clear that income from planning fees should be invested in planning application services. The Planning and Infrastructure Act 2025 introduces a statutory ring-fencing requirement to ensure that fee income is retained and applied to the delivery of the planning function once commenced. The ring-fencing measures will come into force through separate regulations at the same time as the local fee-setting measures. The ring-fencing duty will apply regardless of whether fees are being set nationally or locally. The noble Baroness, Lady Pinnock, mentioned pre-application fees, which I think I have mentioned there—but just to say that local planning authorities already have powers to charge for discretionary services such as planning performance agreements and pre-application advice. We are supporting reducing the cost of planning, and the whole process and digitisation is an example of that. We are clear that fees should rise where costs rise but should also fall as innovation and digital transformation return savings over time. As I have said, this is less than 1% of the total costs to the developer. I think we all agree with the developers that the money raised should go back into the planning process and should be ring-fenced to do that. Where costs can be reduced, we will do that through transformation using digital services. These regulations are a practical but important step towards a better funded and more effective planning system. They will provide planning authorities with the resources they need to strengthen capacity and capability, support more timely decision-making and help to deliver the homes, infrastructure and economic growth that this country needs—
Lord Jamieson (Con)
The Minister is keen to emphasise that it is just 1%. The key point that I and the noble Lord, Lord Fuller, were making is that it is a cumulative layering of a whole series of regulations, and levies in particular, that housebuilders are seeing—so it is not just the 1% but the multiple 1%, 2% and 3%, each of which in their own way can be looked at and thought probably to be appropriate. But cumulatively they are making housebuilding unviable in many parts of this country. That is why we are seeing firms such as Taylor Wimpey moving out of London, where the need for housing is among the highest. If we raise the cost of building a home to such an extent that it is higher than the market will bear, we will not get any houses built. As I said in the debate before recess—I think it was before recess—when several years ago the times were good and the developers’ margins were high, it may have been a different case. That is not the case today. If we want homes built, we must ensure that the cost of building them is below the price they will sell at.
Lord Wilson of Sedgefield (Lab)
The developers accept these increases, as long as they are ring-fenced. They are seeing that the lack of investment in planning departments is a significant barrier to housing delivery in the first place and they have called for greater planning capacity and performance, which is exactly what these fees will do. So it is good news, especially once it becomes more efficient and we can digitise services. If costs come down, the cost to the industry should come down as well. This is something that will help us to deliver houses in the future. It is not going to be a restriction; it is something that everybody wants to see. Together with our wider reforms on local fee-setting, they put planning services on a much more sustainable footing for the future. I commend this instrument to the Committee.
Motion agreed.
Committee adjourned at 5.56 pm.
← Previous
Hazards in Social Housing (Prescribed Requirements) (England) (Amendment) Regulations 2026
Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5415369.