Hansard·Lords Chamber·Vol. 861

Unilateral Nuclear Disarmament

Thursday, 19 November 2026

20 contributions8 members

Contributions

  1. Question

    View contribution permalink →

  2. Asked by

    View contribution permalink →

  3. Lord Soames of Fletching

    To ask His Majesty’s Government what assessment they have made of the impact unilateral nuclear disarmament would have on the ability of the United Kingdom to defend itself.

    View contribution permalink →

  4. The Minister of State, Ministry of Defence (Lord Coaker) (Lab)

    My Lords, I start by praising the service personnel and their families who sustain our deterrent. The Government assess that unilateral nuclear disarmament would remove the United Kingdom’s ultimate guarantee of security against the most extreme threats, weaken NATO’s overall deterrence posture and increase strategic risks to the UK and its allies. The only route to ridding the world of nuclear weapons is through gradual multilateral disarmament as the security situation allows. The UK will therefore maintain its independent nuclear deterrent for as long as the global security situation requires it.

    View contribution permalink →

  5. Lord Soames of Fletching (Con)

    My Lords, in this time of enormous uncertainty, and as of near danger as at any time in my life, is it not paramount that the British Government be seen to be unanimously committed to the maintenance of our independent nuclear deterrent? Given the recent seven-month deployment of HMS “Vengeance” and the fact that only three boats are currently available for service, will the Minister commit his department to accelerating the Dreadnought programme by bringing forward funding, thereby bolstering our nuclear deterrent and easing the already heavy burden on our gallant submariners and their families, for whom, incidentally, there is no praise high enough?

    View contribution permalink →

  6. Lord Coaker (Lab)

    Let me start where the noble Lord, with his excellent question, finished and again praise the service personnel who sustain our deterrent, but also their families and what they do. As I said to the noble Lord in my Answer to his Question, the Government, like previous Governments, have sustained the independent nuclear deterrent. It is a fundamental cornerstone of our security and, of course, we will do all we can to maintain it. The noble Lord will have seen that the Government are investing £64 billion between 2026-27 and 2029-30 to maintain that deterrent. That will be about the new Dreadnought programme, but it will also be doing what we can to ensure that the availability of our nuclear submarines is as good as it can be. The fundamental point is that we have been able to maintain that independent deterrent at sea, day in, day out, for decades, and we shall continue to do so.

    View contribution permalink →

  7. Lord Stirrup (CB)

    My Lords, for those who might doubt the effectiveness of the UK’s independent nuclear deterrent, do not Putin’s desperate attempts to have it excluded from the defence of, and therefore the deterrence of war in, Europe constitute the clearest possible signal of its utility?

    View contribution permalink →

  8. Lord Coaker (Lab)

    The noble and gallant Lord is absolutely right to point out the situation as Putin would see it, but let it resound from this Chamber that he will not succeed in that demand. The UK’s, and France’s, deterrent is committed to NATO, although the operational decision remains with the British Prime Minister. Putin and those who seek to do our country harm should know that we have a strategic, independent nuclear deterrent that this Government will maintain, and I am sure future Governments will do so as well.

    View contribution permalink →

  9. Lord Spellar (Lab)

    My Lords, we rightly give praise to those who keep our deterrent running around the clock, 365 days a year, but, frankly, they should not have to spend 217 days under the ocean maintaining it. The reason they have to is the disgraceful and disastrous decision of the coalition Government at the behest of the Liberal Democrats not to order the Dreadnought submarine programme. They ran down the ships and the workforce at Barrow, which is still having to be reconstituted. Can I have the assurance of the Minister that this Labour Government will never repeat that disgraceful mistake?

    View contribution permalink →

  10. Lord Coaker (Lab)

    My noble friend makes an excellent point. I give that assurance, because it is important. We are investing nearly £64 billion in the renewal and replacement of Dreadnought submarines. That is taking place over the next few years. We expect the Dreadnought class of submarines to be introduced into service through the 2030s. Certainly, this Labour Government, and I am sure most future Governments, will not play around with our nuclear deterrent. It is fundamental to the security of Europe and the world as a whole.

    View contribution permalink →

  11. Lord Wallace of Saltaire (LD)

    My Lords, I remind the House that in 2007 a Labour Defence Minister assured us that nuclear spending goes within the defence budget and not in a separate compartment—there is a historical myth on that. What impact has unilateral conventional disarmament had on Britain’s ability to defend itself over the last 10 years? General Barrons was quoted in August as saying that expenditure on nuclear capital investment is squeezing conventional capital spending out of the defence budget, leaving us with too few surface ships, not enough drones and the smallest Army we have had since the Napoleonic war. That is a problem. How are the Government going to tackle that?

    View contribution permalink →

  12. Lord Coaker (Lab)

    It is a fundamental mistake to put nuclear deterrence against conventional forces and pay for one with the other. The Government are paying for the renewal of our nuclear deterrent through the Dreadnought programme. We are also investing in conventional forces. That is important. The noble Lord also asked about unilateral disarmament. The Government’s pursuit of nuclear non-proliferation goes through the nuclear non-proliferation treaty. We were at that conference in New York a couple of months ago and we were very close, with many others, to having a statement which talked about how, notwithstanding the fact that we retain our right to have the deterrent, we do all that we can to reduce the threat from that.

    View contribution permalink →

  13. Lord Ahmad of Wimbledon (Con)

    My Lords, I welcome the statement from the Minister. I can assure him that on this side of the House we fully align with the commitment given by the Government in support of our independent nuclear deterrent. Does he agree that our diplomacy also gains strength from having an independent nuclear deterrent, whether it is our position on the UN Security Council or when our foes seek to cause us or our partners harm?

    View contribution permalink →

  14. Lord Coaker (Lab)

    The noble Lord is absolutely right. He will know from his experience as a Minister but also from the work that he continues to do in various capacities that having the nuclear deterrent is a significant point for this country. We are a P5 member of the Security Council. That counts enormously across the world. It brings responsibility with it. We have hard power and we will retain that, but alongside that we recognise the need to negotiate and discuss. Those who seek to do us harm should know that we have a nuclear deterrent and we keep it there in case of the ultimate threats we may face.

    View contribution permalink →

  15. Baroness Bennett of Manor Castle (GP)

    My Lords, we have heard “independent” repeated a remarkable number of times in seven and a half minutes. Given that the UK’s nuclear weapons system is dependent on the US, what assessment of risk have the Government made in the light of the fact that, as we are speaking now, President Trump is meeting with his self-described “friend”, President Putin?

    View contribution permalink →

  16. Lord Coaker (Lab)

    The Government would make a huge strategic error if they tried to push the United States away. It is important for us to understand that the United States, the UK and other allies standing together is of enormous importance to the security of our country and across the world. Of course it is an independent deterrent. The independence comes from the fact that it cannot be used without the express permission of the British Prime Minister.

    View contribution permalink →

  17. Lord Evans of Rainow (Con)

    My Lords, I pay tribute to my noble friend for asking this very good Question. It is good to see him in his place. On 24 June last year, the Government announced they would purchase 12 F35A aircraft for the NATO dual-capable aircraft nuclear mission, with the press release saying: “UK to purchase F-35As and join the NATO nuclear mission”. However, in July of this year, Air Vice-Marshal Jim Beck said that the F35As were not actually purchased to perform that role; rather, they were primarily for training purposes. Can the Minister clarify who is correct, the Government or the Royal Air Force?

    View contribution permalink →

  18. Lord Coaker (Lab)

    The Government have committed to the purchase of 12 F35As, which will come out of the overall F35 programme. We expect the first of those 12 to be delivered at the beginning of the 2030s. On F35 and dual-capability aircraft, as the F35A will be, this is a fundamental change in where we are. We have nothing between conventional forces and the strategic capability of Vanguard as it is now and Dreadnought as it will be. The noble Lord has made the point on a number of occasions. There used to be the theory of a ladder of escalation. At the moment, for the most serious threats, we go from conventional weapons to a strategic weapon. The F35A dual-capable aircraft that the noble Lord mentions gives us a tactical nuclear weapon capability. Why do we need that? It is because we are being threatened by others’ tactical nuclear weapons, and we will stand and say, “We need to develop that capability as well”, and we are.

    View contribution permalink →

Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5441467.