CONDUCT OF THE RT HONOURABLE MEMBER FOR EAST SURREY
Motion Text
That this House, now knowing the pivotal role of the Right honourable Member for East Surrey in offering the honourable Member for Winchester the 'guarantee' of no punishment if he agreed to stand down and the threat that, if he did not, he would be 'guaranteed' punishment, believes that this was a seriously unconstitutional act; notes that despite this, he felt able to tell the House (Official Report, 7 March 1990, column 897) that the House had increasingly, and in his judgement rightly, taken the view that the composition of the House was not a matter for the House itself, but for the electorate, and that 'A Member's election to, and continued membership of, this House is a matter between him and his constituents', and 'Finally I come to consider what is probably the most difficult question - that of penalty or reproach... Some honourable Members... will, I dare say, argue today - that talk of penalty is, in such circumstances, inappropriate. I do not share that view; nor do I believe that it accords with precedent'; is appalled that although the Right honourable Gentleman was aware that whips would be applied to the vote, he felt able to assure the House (Official Report, 7 March, column 966) that '... For my part, I stand by the terms of the motion, but I am content to leave the matter to the House'; and believes that in making these statements with his prior knowledge the Right honourable Gentleman, Lord President and a Queen's Counsel, intended to influence the House's judgement to vote unjustly against a Parliamentary colleague.