TRUSTPOLITICS

Public Authorities (Fraud, Error and Recovery) Bill Report Stage: New Clause 21

Tuesday, 29 April 2025

REJECTED
95
256
Aye: 95No: 257

Party Breakdown

Labour
0 Aye224 No
Conservative
88 Aye0 No
Labour (Co-op)
0 Aye26 No
Reform UK
4 Aye0 No
Green Party
0 Aye3 No
Your Party
0 Aye2 No
Independent
1 Aye1 No
Traditional Unionist Voice
1 Aye0 No
Ulster Unionist Party
1 Aye0 No

Aye (95)

Voted in favour

Alan Mak

Conservative
Havant

Alberto Costa

Conservative
South Leicestershire

Alex Burghart

Conservative
Brentwood and Ongar

Alicia Kearns

Conservative
Rutland and Stamford

Alison Griffiths

Conservative
Bognor Regis and Littlehampton

Andrew Bowie

Conservative
West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine

Aphra Brandreth

Conservative
Chester South and Eddisbury

Ben Obese-Jecty

Conservative
Huntingdon

Blake Stephenson

Conservative
Mid Bedfordshire

Bob Blackman

Conservative
Harrow East

Bradley Thomas

Conservative
Bromsgrove

Charlie Dewhirst

Conservative
Bridlington and The Wolds

Chris Philp

Conservative
Croydon South

Claire Coutinho

Conservative
East Surrey

Dame Caroline Dinenage

Conservative
Gosport

Dame Karen Bradley

Conservative
Staffordshire Moorlands

Damian Hinds

Conservative
East Hampshire

David Davis

Conservative
Goole and Pocklington

David Mundell

Conservative
Dumfriesshire, Clydesdale and Tweeddale

David Reed

Conservative
Exmouth and Exeter East

David Simmonds

Conservative
Ruislip, Northwood and Pinner

Dr Andrew Murrison

Conservative
South West Wiltshire

Dr Ben Spencer

Conservative
Runnymede and Weybridge

Dr Caroline Johnson

Conservative
Sleaford and North Hykeham

Dr Kieran Mullan

Conservative
Bexhill and Battle

Dr Luke Evans

Conservative
Hinckley and Bosworth

Dr Neil Hudson

Conservative
Epping Forest

Dr Neil Shastri-Hurst

Conservative
Solihull West and Shirley

Edward Argar

Conservative
Melton and Syston

Esther McVey

Conservative
Tatton

Gareth Bacon

Conservative
Orpington

Gareth Davies

Conservative
Grantham and Bourne

Graham Stuart

Conservative
Beverley and Holderness

Greg Smith

Conservative
Mid Buckinghamshire

Gregory Stafford

Conservative
Farnham and Bordon

Harriet Cross

Conservative
Gordon and Buchan

Helen Whately

Conservative
Faversham and Mid Kent

Jack Rankin

Conservative
Windsor

James Cartlidge

Conservative
South Suffolk

James Wild

Conservative
North West Norfolk

Joe Robertson

Conservative
Isle of Wight East

John Cooper

Conservative
Dumfries and Galloway

John Glen

Conservative
Salisbury

John Lamont

Conservative
Berwickshire, Roxburgh and Selkirk

Joy Morrissey

Conservative
Beaconsfield

Julia Lopez

Conservative
Hornchurch and Upminster

Katie Lam

Conservative
Weald of Kent

Kit Malthouse

Conservative
North West Hampshire

Laura Trott

Conservative
Sevenoaks

Lewis Cocking

Conservative
Broxbourne

Lincoln Jopp

Conservative
Spelthorne

Mark Garnier

Conservative
Wyre Forest

Martin Vickers

Conservative
Brigg and Immingham

Mike Wood

Conservative
Kingswinford and South Staffordshire

Mr Louie French

Conservative
Old Bexley and Sidcup

Mr Mark Francois

Conservative
Rayleigh and Wickford

Mr Peter Bedford

Conservative
Mid Leicestershire

Mr Richard Holden

Conservative
Basildon and Billericay

Neil O'Brien

Conservative
Harborough, Oadby and Wigston

Nick Timothy

Conservative
West Suffolk

Nigel Huddleston

Conservative
Droitwich and Evesham

Paul Holmes

Conservative
Hamble Valley

Peter Fortune

Conservative
Bromley and Biggin Hill

Rebecca Harris

Conservative
Castle Point

Rebecca Smith

Conservative
South West Devon

Richard Fuller

Conservative
North Bedfordshire

Robbie Moore

Conservative
Keighley and Ilkley

Saqib Bhatti

Conservative
Meriden and Solihull East

Sarah Bool

Conservative
South Northamptonshire

Shivani Raja

Conservative
Leicester East

Simon Hoare

Conservative
North Dorset

Sir Andrew Mitchell

Conservative
Sutton Coldfield

Sir Ashley Fox

Conservative
Bridgwater

Sir Bernard Jenkin

Conservative
Harwich and North Essex

Sir Gavin Williamson

Conservative
Stone, Great Wyrley and Penkridge

Sir Geoffrey Clifton-Brown

Conservative
North Cotswolds

Sir Geoffrey Cox

Conservative
Torridge and Tavistock

Sir James Cleverly

Conservative
Braintree

Sir John Hayes

Conservative
South Holland and The Deepings

Sir John Whittingdale

Conservative
Maldon

Sir Julian Lewis

Conservative
New Forest East

Sir Julian Smith

Conservative
Skipton and Ripon

Sir Oliver Dowden

Conservative
Hertsmere

Sir Roger Gale

Conservative
Herne Bay and Sandwich

Stuart Anderson

Conservative
South Shropshire

Tom Tugendhat

Conservative
Tonbridge

Victoria Atkins

Conservative
Louth and Horncastle

Wendy Morton

Conservative
Aldridge-Brownhills

James McMurdock

Independent
South Basildon and East Thurrock

Andrew Rosindell

Reform UK
Romford

Lee Anderson

Reform UK
Ashfield

Richard Tice

Reform UK
Boston and Skegness

Suella Braverman

Reform UK
Fareham and Waterlooville

Jim Allister

Traditional Unionist Voice
North Antrim

Robin Swann

Ulster Unionist Party
South Antrim

No (256)

Voted against

Carla Denyer

Green Party
Bristol Central

Dr Ellie Chowns

Green Party
North Herefordshire

Siân Berry

Green Party
Brighton Pavilion

Karl Turner

Independent
Kingston upon Hull East

Abtisam Mohamed

Labour
Sheffield Central

Adam Jogee

Labour
Newcastle-under-Lyme

Adam Thompson

Labour
Erewash

Afzal Khan

Labour
Manchester Rusholme

Alan Gemmell

Labour
Central Ayrshire

Alex Ballinger

Labour
Halesowen

Alex Davies-Jones

Labour
Pontypridd

Alex Mayer

Labour
Dunstable and Leighton Buzzard

Alison Hume

Labour
Scarborough and Whitby

Alison McGovern

Labour
Birkenhead

Amanda Hack

Labour
North West Leicestershire

Amanda Martin

Labour
Portsmouth North

Andrew Cooper

Labour
Mid Cheshire

Andrew Ranger

Labour
Wrexham

Andrew Western

Labour
Stretford and Urmston

Andy Slaughter

Labour
Hammersmith and Chiswick

Anna Dixon

Labour
Shipley

Anneliese Midgley

Labour
Knowsley

Apsana Begum

Labour
Poplar and Limehouse

Ashley Dalton

Labour
West Lancashire

Bambos Charalambous

Labour
Southgate and Wood Green

Barry Gardiner

Labour
Brent West

Bell Ribeiro-Addy

Labour
Clapham and Brixton Hill

Ben Goldsborough

Labour
South Norfolk

Bill Esterson

Labour
Sefton Central

Brian Leishman

Labour
Alloa and Grangemouth

Callum Anderson

Labour
Buckingham and Bletchley

Carolyn Harris

Labour
Neath and Swansea East

Cat Smith

Labour
Lancaster and Wyre

Catherine Atkinson

Labour
Derby North

Catherine McKinnell

Labour
Newcastle upon Tyne North

Charlotte Nichols

Labour
Warrington North

Chris Curtis

Labour
Milton Keynes North

Chris Elmore

Labour
Bridgend

Chris Hinchliff

Labour
North East Hertfordshire

Chris Kane

Labour
Stirling and Strathallan

Chris McDonald

Labour
Stockton North

Chris Murray

Labour
Edinburgh East and Musselburgh

Claire Hazelgrove

Labour
Filton and Bradley Stoke

Claire Hughes

Labour
Bangor Aberconwy

Clive Efford

Labour
Eltham and Chislehurst

Connor Naismith

Labour
Crewe and Nantwich

Dame Angela Eagle

Labour
Wallasey

Dame Chi Onwurah

Labour
Newcastle upon Tyne Central and West

Dame Diana Johnson

Labour
Kingston upon Hull North and Cottingham

Dame Nia Griffith

Labour
Llanelli

Dame Siobhain McDonagh

Labour
Mitcham and Morden

Damien Egan

Labour
Bristol North East

Dan Carden

Labour
Liverpool Walton

Dan Tomlinson

Labour
Chipping Barnet

Daniel Francis

Labour
Bexleyheath and Crayford

Daniel Zeichner

Labour
Cambridge

Danny Beales

Labour
Uxbridge and South Ruislip

Darren Paffey

Labour
Southampton Itchen

David Baines

Labour
St Helens North

David Burton-Sampson

Labour
Southend West and Leigh

David Pinto-Duschinsky

Labour
Hendon

David Smith

Labour
North Northumberland

Debbie Abrahams

Labour
Oldham East and Saddleworth

Deirdre Costigan

Labour
Ealing Southall

Derek Twigg

Labour
Widnes and Halewood

Douglas McAllister

Labour
West Dunbartonshire

Dr Allison Gardner

Labour
Stoke-on-Trent South

Dr Marie Tidball

Labour
Penistone and Stocksbridge

Dr Peter Prinsley

Labour
Bury St Edmunds and Stowmarket

Dr Scott Arthur

Labour
Edinburgh South West

Dr Zubir Ahmed

Labour
Glasgow South West

Emily Darlington

Labour
Milton Keynes Central

Emily Thornberry

Labour
Islington South and Finsbury

Emma Hardy

Labour
Kingston upon Hull West and Haltemprice

Euan Stainbank

Labour
Falkirk

Feryal Clark

Labour
Enfield North

Georgia Gould

Labour
Queen's Park and Maida Vale

Gill Furniss

Labour
Sheffield Brightside and Hillsborough

Gill German

Labour
Clwyd North

Gordon McKee

Labour
Glasgow South

Graeme Downie

Labour
Dunfermline and Dollar

Gregor Poynton

Labour
Livingston

Gurinder Singh Josan

Labour
Smethwick

Harpreet Uppal

Labour
Huddersfield

Helen Hayes

Labour
Dulwich and West Norwood

Henry Tufnell

Labour
Mid and South Pembrokeshire

Hilary Benn

Labour
Leeds South

Ian Byrne

Labour
Liverpool West Derby

Ian Lavery

Labour
Blyth and Ashington

Ian Murray

Labour
Edinburgh South

Irene Campbell

Labour
North Ayrshire and Arran

Jade Botterill

Labour
Ossett and Denby Dale

Jake Richards

Labour
Rother Valley

James Naish

Labour
Rushcliffe

Jas Athwal

Labour
Ilford South

Jeff Smith

Labour
Manchester Withington

Jenny Riddell-Carpenter

Labour
Suffolk Coastal

Jess Asato

Labour
Lowestoft

Jessica Morden

Labour
Newport East

Jessica Toale

Labour
Bournemouth West

Jim Dickson

Labour
Dartford

Jo Stevens

Labour
Cardiff East

Jo White

Labour
Bassetlaw

Joani Reid

Labour
East Kilbride and Strathaven

Joe Morris

Labour
Hexham

Joe Powell

Labour
Kensington and Bayswater

Johanna Baxter

Labour
Paisley and Renfrewshire South

John Grady

Labour
Glasgow East

John McDonnell

Labour
Hayes and Harlington

John Whitby

Labour
Derbyshire Dales

Jon Trickett

Labour
Normanton and Hemsworth

Josh Dean

Labour
Hertford and Stortford

Josh Fenton-Glynn

Labour
Calder Valley

Josh MacAlister

Labour
Whitehaven and Workington

Josh Newbury

Labour
Cannock Chase

Josh Simons

Labour
Makerfield

Julia Buckley

Labour
Shrewsbury

Justin Madders

Labour
Ellesmere Port and Bromborough

Kanishka Narayan

Labour
Vale of Glamorgan

Karin Smyth

Labour
Bristol South

Katie White

Labour
Leeds North West

Keir Mather

Labour
Selby

Kenneth Stevenson

Labour
Airdrie and Shotts

Kerry McCarthy

Labour
Bristol East

Kevin Bonavia

Labour
Stevenage

Kevin McKenna

Labour
Sittingbourne and Sheppey

Kim Leadbeater

Labour
Spen Valley

Kirith Entwistle

Labour
Bolton North East

Laura Kyrke-Smith

Labour
Aylesbury

Lauren Edwards

Labour
Rochester and Strood

Laurence Turner

Labour
Birmingham Northfield

Lee Pitcher

Labour
Doncaster East and the Isle of Axholme

Lewis Atkinson

Labour
Sunderland Central

Liam Byrne

Labour
Birmingham Hodge Hill and Solihull North

Liam Conlon

Labour
Beckenham and Penge

Lilian Greenwood

Labour
Nottingham South

Liz Kendall

Labour
Leicester West

Liz Twist

Labour
Blaydon and Consett

Lloyd Hatton

Labour
South Dorset

Lola McEvoy

Labour
Darlington

Louise Haigh

Labour
Sheffield Heeley

Louise Sandher-Jones

Labour
North East Derbyshire

Lucy Rigby

Labour
Northampton North

Luke Akehurst

Labour
North Durham

Luke Myer

Labour
Middlesbrough South and East Cleveland

Margaret Mullane

Labour
Dagenham and Rainham

Mark Ferguson

Labour
Gateshead Central and Whickham

Mark Sewards

Labour
Leeds South West and Morley

Markus Campbell-Savours

Labour
Penrith and Solway

Martin Rhodes

Labour
Glasgow North

Mary Creagh

Labour
Coventry East

Mary Kelly Foy

Labour
City of Durham

Matt Turmaine

Labour
Watford

Matt Western

Labour
Warwick and Leamington

Matthew Patrick

Labour
Wirral West

Matthew Pennycook

Labour
Greenwich and Woolwich

Maureen Burke

Labour
Glasgow North East

Melanie Onn

Labour
Great Grimsby and Cleethorpes

Michael Shanks

Labour
Rutherglen

Michael Wheeler

Labour
Worsley and Eccles

Michelle Scrogham

Labour
Barrow and Furness

Michelle Welsh

Labour
Sherwood Forest

Mike Tapp

Labour
Dover and Deal

Mr Calvin Bailey

Labour
Leyton and Wanstead

Mr Clive Betts

Labour
Sheffield South East

Mr Hamish Falconer

Labour
Lincoln

Mr James Frith

Labour
Bury North

Mr Luke Charters

Labour
York Outer

Mr Paul Foster

Labour
South Ribble

Mr Tanmanjeet Singh Dhesi

Labour
Slough

Mrs Elsie Blundell

Labour
Heywood and Middleton North

Mrs Sharon Hodgson

Labour
Washington and Gateshead South

Ms Diane Abbott

Labour
Hackney North and Stoke Newington

Ms Julie Minns

Labour
Carlisle

Ms Marie Rimmer

Labour
St Helens South and Whiston

Natasha Irons

Labour
Croydon East

Naushabah Khan

Labour
Gillingham and Rainham

Naz Shah

Labour
Bradford West

Neil Coyle

Labour
Bermondsey and Old Southwark

Neil Duncan-Jordan

Labour
Poole

Noah Law

Labour
St Austell and Newquay

Olivia Bailey

Labour
Reading West and Mid Berkshire

Pam Cox

Labour
Colchester

Pamela Nash

Labour
Motherwell, Wishaw and Carluke

Patricia Ferguson

Labour
Glasgow West

Patrick Hurley

Labour
Southport

Paul Davies

Labour
Colne Valley

Paula Barker

Labour
Liverpool Wavertree

Perran Moon

Labour
Camborne and Redruth

Peter Kyle

Labour
Hove and Portslade

Peter Lamb

Labour
Crawley

Peter Swallow

Labour
Bracknell

Phil Brickell

Labour
Bolton West

Rachel Hopkins

Labour
Luton South and South Bedfordshire

Richard Baker

Labour
Glenrothes and Mid Fife

Richard Burgon

Labour
Leeds East

Richard Quigley

Labour
Isle of Wight West

Rosie Wrighting

Labour
Kettering

Rushanara Ali

Labour
Bethnal Green and Stepney

Ruth Jones

Labour
Newport West and Islwyn

Sadik Al-Hassan

Labour
North Somerset

Sam Carling

Labour
North West Cambridgeshire

Samantha Niblett

Labour
South Derbyshire

Sarah Champion

Labour
Rotherham

Sarah Coombes

Labour
West Bromwich

Sarah Edwards

Labour
Tamworth

Sarah Jones

Labour
Croydon West

Sarah Owen

Labour
Luton North

Sarah Sackman

Labour
Finchley and Golders Green

Satvir Kaur

Labour
Southampton Test

Sean Woodcock

Labour
Banbury

Sir Alan Campbell

Labour
Tynemouth

Sir Nicholas Dakin

Labour
Scunthorpe

Sonia Kumar

Labour
Dudley

Stephanie Peacock

Labour
Barnsley South

Stephen Morgan

Labour
Portsmouth South

Sureena Brackenridge

Labour
Wolverhampton North East

Tahir Ali

Labour
Birmingham Hall Green and Moseley

Tom Collins

Labour
Worcester

Tom Hayes

Labour
Bournemouth East

Tonia Antoniazzi

Labour
Gower

Tulip Siddiq

Labour
Hampstead and Highgate

Uma Kumaran

Labour
Stratford and Bow

Valerie Vaz

Labour
Walsall and Bloxwich

Vicky Foxcroft

Labour
Lewisham North

Warinder Juss

Labour
Wolverhampton West

Will Stone

Labour
Swindon North

Yuan Yang

Labour
Earley and Woodley

Alice Macdonald

Labour (Co-op)
Norwich North

Anneliese Dodds

Labour (Co-op)
Oxford East

Baggy Shanker

Labour (Co-op)
Derby South

Chris Evans

Labour (Co-op)
Caerphilly

Chris Vince

Labour (Co-op)
Harlow

Dame Meg Hillier

Labour (Co-op)
Hackney South and Shoreditch

Florence Eshalomi

Labour (Co-op)
Vauxhall and Camberwell Green

Gareth Snell

Labour (Co-op)
Stoke-on-Trent Central

Gareth Thomas

Labour (Co-op)
Harrow West

Helena Dollimore

Labour (Co-op)
Hastings and Rye

Jack Abbott

Labour (Co-op)
Ipswich

James Murray

Labour (Co-op)
Ealing North

Jayne Kirkham

Labour (Co-op)
Truro and Falmouth

Jim McMahon

Labour (Co-op)
Oldham West, Chadderton and Royton

Jo Platt

Labour (Co-op)
Leigh and Atherton

Kate Dearden

Labour (Co-op)
Halifax

Kirsteen Sullivan

Labour (Co-op)
Bathgate and Linlithgow

Kirsty McNeill

Labour (Co-op)
Midlothian

Lucy Powell

Labour (Co-op)
Manchester Central

Miatta Fahnbulleh

Labour (Co-op)
Peckham

Ms Stella Creasy

Labour (Co-op)
Walthamstow

Oliver Ryan

Labour (Co-op)
Burnley

Paul Waugh

Labour (Co-op)
Rochdale

Preet Kaur Gill

Labour (Co-op)
Birmingham Edgbaston

Rachael Maskell

Labour (Co-op)
York Central

Sarah Hall

Labour (Co-op)
Warrington South

Jeremy Corbyn

Your Party
Islington North

Zarah Sultana

Your Party
Coventry South