Lord Fox (LD)

My Lords, I was surprised to hear the noble Lord, Lord Sikka, describe this SI as looking persuasive, as nothing he said prior to that indicated that that was how he felt. I will pick him up on one point on auditors, having been responsible for the content of dozens of annual reports at a corporate level: although the auditors may or may not have had a legal responsibility for directors’ reports and strategic reports, there is not a single directors’ report or strategic report for which I have been responsible where the auditors did not pick up and verify the points within. I am merely observing this; I do not think we need a debate on it because it is not relevant to the statutory instrument. It was just because the noble Lord brought it up. Late payment remains a significant issue for UK businesses, as the Minister said—particularly small businesses but other businesses too. Our calculations show that, in 2024, small businesses were owed an average of £21,400 in late payments. This clearly has a significant effect on cash flow and it creates a real challenge. Without cash flow, business viability is threatened and people are unable to invest in their businesses. Late payment undermines growth and drives some firms out of business. Some businesses use their suppliers’ balance sheets to fund their cash flow. We have seen notorious examples of this; for example, it seemed that Carillion’s entire business model was based on funding its activities through the cash flow of its supply chain. This sort of statutory instrument should be able to identify those operators effectively. This legislation goes some way to strengthening transparency around how large companies pay suppliers. Here, I agree with the noble Lord, Lord Sikka: it is not a universal panacea but a small step, and we should be careful not to invest too much in this step. Businesses have been expected to report on a number of issues, such as their environmental performance and the number of women in particular roles, for many years, yet change at the corporate level has been very slow despite the transparency that was earned through legislation. This SI should enable investors, auditors, shareholders and potential suppliers to get a better idea of what a company is about, as much thematically as definitively. If a company always files late numbers, that tells you something about how the business is managed; in some cases, one-off things may make that happen. As the Minister set out, though, there is more to be done. However, he did not mention the role of public procurement, which is vital to driving the right behaviours in business. I would like the Minister to talk about that and accept that the Government have a strong leadership role around public procurement and that there is still a lot of work to be done. That said, taking into account its limited objectives, we support this statutory instrument.