Lord Goddard of Stockport (LD)

The noble Lord, Lord Hunt, will say “Hear, hear” no more because we cannot support Amendment 149A, which is a new amendment that proposes removing Clause 72. I will tell the House why we cannot support it. On Monday I supported the noble Lords, Lord Hunt and Lord Sharpe, when we were very critical of the Government for tabling amendments on Report. People nodded wisely and said that it is not a good thing to do, yet this amendment was tabled today or yesterday. It has had no time for discussion or debate. It has had no time for people to understand its nuances. We know that it takes a big chunk out of the Government’s manifesto pledge Bill, and that does not seem fair to me. In our view, legislation should be done through constructive amendments. If you do that, you end up with a compromise, whether it is through ping-pong or by persuading the Minister to change their point of view. It is almost like taking the sledgehammer again, and that is not good politics. It is not good for the House, and it is not good for Members. Lots of Members come into these debates, not all the time, and try to get a flavour of what is going on. They might hear that Amendment 149A, which sounds fairly reasonable, has been put forward. It is not fairly reasonable; it takes an enormous chunk out of the Government’s Bill, and that cannot be right for democracy. I have criticised Ministers many times, but we should be mindful that it is in the manifesto and move legislation via amendments rather than trying to remove huge chunks of legislation. On that basis, we will not support Amendment 149A.