Contribution
My Lords, for clarification, as with the end-of-life Bill, I am speaking in a personal capacity. The Liberal Democrats have a free vote on this; clearly the Conservatives have a different view. That is for them to determine.
I have to say, listening to the arguments today for the Opposition, I am surprised that there is no one here from the Labour Party. The Labour Party has obviously learned from other occasions that it pays to keep their powder dry. At the end of the day, whatever the outcome of this, the usual channels will meet, it will come to the House and there will be a free vote in the House of Lords. That is where this will be determined eventually. It will not be determined by a Committee or who has made the best speech at any given time.
I come at this from a different angle. I am now the Chief Whip for the Liberal Democrats and have already, on a number of occasions, had to accompany elderly female Members from this House through Carriage Gates at past 2 am to put them in a taxi home. When we are in this House, we are protected. We have armed guards and doorkeepers, but at midnight, 1 am or 2 am you are on your own outside. As I am speaking personally, I am not going to reflect on the speakers. That would not be fair because they do not have the right to reply. One thing I would say is that when we sit late now, there are arrangements for the doorkeepers to take taxis home. Taxis do not take Members of the House home after late night sittings; we make our own way home. That may be something we should be looking at as well.
I sit down with proposed new Members and they ask: when do you sit and what do you do? When you tell them that we sit at 2.30 pm, 3 pm and 11 am, they ask why on earth we do that. That is tradition, history, the value of the House of Lords. That is our problem; we are living in the past. Modernisation is coming. The world is changing, and the membership of this house is changing radically. I know that from experience because the Liberal Democrats from, say, 2014-15 to 2020 plus had no new Peers as because of the number of our MPs we did not qualify, so I have an older group of Members proportionate to our numbers, and that brings its own challenges.
We are getting newer MPs through the allowances and other parties are getting the same. They look at this place and wonder what is going on. Yes, we have the expertise and knowledge—and yes, we sit—but we are not a dining club or a meeting place. The idea that you can change government policy over a bowl of soup is frankly for the birds. We are here to do business, to hold the Government to account and to make legislation better. I cannot understand how anybody could argue that that is best done past 10 pm, 11 pm or 12 am. This is my opinion.
I am saying that, by these modest changes, we can begin to bring things into line with the rest of the world, basically. I do not know of any companies that run the sort of hours that we do. People say, “What is the future of us? We are different. We are somehow superior”. We are not. We are not insular; we all come from somewhere. We all have families and speak to people. We read the newspapers. It is not as if we have to be available to meet somebody who comes in to tell us that something is going wrong in America or somewhere else. I know that information; I pick it up myself. If I do not have time to prepare for a speech in the morning, that is my fault for not getting up early enough. If I do not get into bed until 3 am, that makes it more difficult for me.
If we do nothing, somebody will do something to us eventually. It will be a Government of whatever persuasion, because at the moment legislation is coming thick and fast. It is difficult to do, but everyone in Committee or at Report stage does their best. Nobody is here to stop anything; we are here to hold the Government to account and they can speak for themselves.
I am here speaking as an independent Liberal Democrat Peer who comes from Stockport. I stay every week: I come down on Monday and go home Thursday or Friday. The hours really do not matter to me, but they do matter to other people. There are other people of a certain age. As time goes on in the evening, it becomes more difficult to concentrate and to participate meaningfully. The House should be able to allow everybody to participate meaningfully whenever they want and whenever they can. It must be better for the House if those hours are made more regular.
I will be voting for these changes. This is the beginning of modernisation. If the legislation for the age limit comes in at 80, everybody will know what that means for the House. That is the point I am trying to make today: change is coming. We should embrace it and should not resist it. We are not Luddites. We should be more modern and be thinking forward. We should be putting some of the ancient traditions to one side, because we are in the 21st century now, and we should act like that.