Contribution
My Lords, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Ponsonby, for giving us the opportunity to discuss and debate this. I am against the proposals to alter the sitting times of the House. Like everybody else—certainly a large number, anyway—I caution noble Lords that reform, particularly when void of evidence, does not always result in any improvement.
The House is, much to my regret, becoming increasingly overpopulated exclusively by professional, full-time politicians. We should be mindful of the fact that the strength of this House has always been vested in its ability to be a House of experience and expertise, made up of men and women who have led businesses, commanded our Armed Forces, conducted our foreign affairs, practised medicine and the law, served in local government and academia, and contributed eminently to civil society. We should therefore be encouraging these people of lived experience to participate fully, not making it harder, and I fear that any of the options that have been touted thus far will do just that.
As has already been said, the question before us should be not, “How can we make the House of Lords a more convenient place for us to work?”, but, “How can we ensure that it remains an effective place in which we are able to scrutinise and hold the Government of the day to account, on behalf of the British people?”. Earlier sitting times will exclude Peers who wish—or, in most professional cases, need—to continue to practise their profession. A lawyer who is required in court, a surgeon who operates in the mornings or a business leader running a company in the City should not be disadvantaged from participation in this place simply because they cannot conform to what is increasingly becoming a rigid parliamentary timetable.
The more we make the membership of this place a full-time parliamentary occupation, the greater the danger of creating a metro-focused political class that is entirely detached from the realities, communities and professions that we are constitutionally assembled to understand. I fear that the constant attempts to tinker with and modernise the Lords are turning us from a House of working experience into a home for experienced politicians looking for work. Your Lordships’ House is not a conventional workplace. It is certainly not the House of Commons and should never be seen as such, for our constitutional value in this House lies precisely in being different and adaptable.
It is absolutely inconsistent to appoint people to this place in recognition of their achievements beyond the Westminster machine, only then to reorganise ourselves in such a way that they are increasingly expected to abandon the activities from which they accumulate their knowledge and experience. The value in this House is not in how closely we can replicate the professional trappings of the Commons but in how effective we can be at being something, and offering something, different. Our operating hours reflect the responsibilities of your Lordships’ legislative and scrutiny functions as opposed to simply replicating, for nothing more than convenience, the working patterns and convenience of the wider Whitehall estate.
I further put it to your Lordships that there is a fundamental constitutional principle at stake here. The Government of the day should not be permitted to determine the intensity, convenience or effectiveness of the scrutiny to which they are subjected. It is not the responsibility of this House to organise itself around the convenience of Whitehall and Ministers. The Government have a constitutional responsibility to make themselves available to Parliament. There is a real danger of this House increasingly becoming an administrative department of the Executive and simply processing legislation. In changing our sitting times, there is an inherent risk that we are, through the back door, surrendering the institutional independence and practical work of this place.
Before bringing in any changes to the sitting hours of the House, noble Lords should carefully consider whether earlier starting times may directly disadvantage noble Lords travelling from outside London—this point has been made, but it is an extremely important one. The proposal to start our sittings earlier in the day risks establishing two classes of parliamentarian: those whose lives revolve around Westminster; and those whose lives continue to contribute to the country beyond it. We must be careful to avoid creating a situation by which London residency becomes the unofficial qualification for the effective membership of your Lordships’ House.
Further, the union of nations is constantly going through incredible strain, and we must therefore make sure that any changes to sitting times do not inadvertently make it impossible for Peers travelling from Scotland, Wales or Northern Ireland to participate properly. We have to strongly consider the union in everything we do.
Like other noble Lords, I have witnessed late-night sittings and how some of the most important scrutiny occurs when a debate is allowed to develop, Ministers are pushed and this House refuses to be hurried. Sadly, we are developing a culture here by which the tyranny of the parliamentary clock and the predicted finishing times are discouraging the level of scrutiny that your Lordships’ House was once admired for the world over.
The more we seek to make this House resemble the other place in its working practices and professional character, the harder it will be to argue and explain why a House elected by political patronage should be here. We should therefore preserve our distinctiveness as the layman legislators of expertise because it is that distinctiveness which helps justify our very existence.
I would go further and say that if we are going down this rather slippery slope, and this is not the only example of that, of diminishing the standing of this House in pursuit of, I am afraid I am going to call it political gimmickry, Whitehall conformity, perhaps it is only a matter of time before the Government will announce the establishment of the House of Lords North to complement the much-vaunted and costly No 10. North. Whatever our differences, I hope that the Committee can at least unite to discourage anyone from entertaining any such ambition, especially as it did not end well for the last person to move government to the north of England, Henry I: he died of dysentery as a result.