Sitting Times of the House
Thursday, 22 October 2026
Contributions
Motion to Take Note
Moved by
The Senior Deputy Speaker
That the Grand Committee takes note of the consultation relating to the sitting times of the House.
The Senior Deputy Speaker (Lord Ponsonby of Shulbrede)
My Lords, this Motion invites the Grand Committee to take note of the ongoing consultation on possible changes to the sitting times of the House. I am grateful to noble Lords for attending today’s debate and for their engagement with the consultation that we have already seen. Any decision to change the sitting times of the House is ultimately a matter for the House itself. Today’s debate therefore provides a further opportunity for noble Lords to express their views before the Procedure and Privileges Committee considers what, if any, recommendations it may make to the House. As noble Lords would expect, this is a neutral Motion. My role today is to assist the Grand Committee in its consideration of the matter rather than to advocate any particular outcome. Following the debate, I will seek to respond to the points raised where possible at this stage of the consultation process.
Noble Lords
We cannot hear. The microphone is not working.
The Senior Deputy Speaker (Lord Ponsonby of Shulbrede)
Can noble Lords hear me?
Noble Lords
Yes.
The Senior Deputy Speaker (Lord Ponsonby of Shulbrede)
The House last considered changes to sitting times in 2022, following concerns expressed by Members across the House that the House should sit earlier on Tuesdays and Wednesdays. The PPC conducted a consultation with Members and subsequently published a neutral report analysing the responses received. The report was debated by the House on 5 July 2022, when the House voted by 158 votes to 124 not to make changes to the sitting times. Earlier this year, the Government Chief Whip wrote to the PPC seeking its agreement to consult the House again on this question, noting renewed interest among Members in recognising the issue. The committee agreed and the current consultation seeks views on four options: sitting at 1 pm on Tuesdays, sitting at 1 pm on Wednesdays, sitting at 1 pm on both those days, or making no change. The consultation was launched on 2 September through a Members’ notice. Members may respond through either an online form or a paper form available from the Printed Paper Office. Since its launch I have met Back-Bench chairs and made myself available to speak at all-party groups. The Administration has also organised drop-in stands to raise awareness of the consultation and encourage participation. The consultation has been promoted through a range of channels, including ParliNet, PeerHub and digital screens across the Parliamentary Estate. As of yesterday, 21 October, 360 responses have been received. By comparison, in 2022, a total of 48 submissions was received. It is encouraging to see that substantially more Members have engaged with the current consultation. On this occasion, the committee has deliberately adopted a longer consultation period and sought to maximise awareness and engagement across the House. The response to date suggests that those efforts have enabled a greater number of Members to share their views on this important issue. The consultation will remain open until 5 pm on 13 November. The Administration is also examining the potential resource and cost implications for House services arising from various options under consideration. Further details of that work will be provided in due course and will form part of the information made available to the committee in reaching its conclusions. This will include advice on the impacts on tours and educational visits, Select Committees, catering, capital projects and staffing issues. As was the case during the consultation in 2022, this will ensure that the PPC has the best possible and most thorough analysis when formulating its recommendations to the House. Responses received through the consultation, together with feedback from party and group discussions and information from the Administration and bicameral services, will be considered by the PPC early in 2027. The committee’s report will include an analysis of consultation responses alongside information about operational and service impacts. The House will then have a further opportunity to debate the committee’s recommendations and to determine whether any changes should be made to sitting times. I look forward to hearing the views of noble Lords in today’s debate. I beg to move.
The Deputy Chairman of Committees (Lord Bates) (Con)
Before I put the Question, I have been advised by the clerk that there are issues to relating to the audio. We will therefore have to adjourn proceedings for a few minutes to investigate the issue.
A noble Lord
It is working well.
Lord Blencathra (Con)
Can we just speak louder?
Lord Stoneham of Droxford (LD)
Yes.
The Deputy Chairman of Committees (Lord Bates) (Con)
I think that there are matters of recording for Hansard as well. If we could just follow the instruction to adjourn for a few moments while the issue is investigated, I will then put the Question and we will continue.
Sitting suspended.
The Deputy Chairman of Committees (Lord Bates) (Con)
My Lords, the matter has been investigated, and I am afraid they cannot fix it. Therefore, we are going to have to take the unusual step of adjourning to another Committee Room. Committee Room 2A/3A has been prepared for us. We will therefore recommence at 12.40 pm, at which point I will put the Question.
Sitting suspended.
The Deputy Chairman of Committees (Lord Bates) (Con)
I thank Members for their patience in moving; I also thank the doorkeepers, staff and clerks for facilitating it. The result is that our deliberations can now be seen and heard by those who are external to the building. The Question is that this Motion be agreed to.
Lord Redwood (Con)
My Lords, I thank the Senior Deputy Speaker for his opening remarks, his clear and neutral presentation, and, above all, the enormous work that he has put into making this an extensive and fair consultation. We are all very grateful to him and his team for that work. As a relatively new Lord in your Lordships’ House, I approached the new job understanding that it would be very different from the spirit and the actions of the House of Commons and knowing that the task of your Lordships’ House is to tread very carefully so that we can be seen to be doing good work—making a difference, improving and amending—without in any way attempting to usurp the powers of the elected Government, understanding the power of the House of Commons. We generally get that right, I think. When I came here and saw the ancient traditions, as well as some of the more modern customs, they naturally seemed a little strange—as I think they do to many people outside the House—but I saw that many of them were well based in tried customs and practices that worked very well. Today, we are debating our hours of business; this relates to the large, diverse membership that your Lordships’ House enjoys. It is part of the decision that Parliament and the nation have made that there should be a second, unelected House with a wide range of skills, experience and talent to draw on, which leads to some of the customs and practices that are so clearly embedded and has led to past Sessions of your Lordships’ House deciding that the hours should be as they are today. We are invited to make a choice between four options. There is the “no change” option. Then, as we have heard, there are two mild options around changing one day a little and the slightly bolder option of changing two days a little. I approach this not as someone who believes that all customs and traditions have to be respected but as a conservative: there is usually a good reason for tradition and custom, and you do not want to destroy unnecessarily ones that are part of our culture and still work. For example, in the other place, during the past year of Lords reform, I was strongly in favour of retirement reform. I thought it essential that there was an opportunity for Lords to retire. There can be a system whereby, if any noble Lord’s judgment is a little wanting as to their aptitudes and capabilities, friendly Whips, friendly parties, family and others involved can help make sure that a sensible decision is made, but, again, this is relevant to our sitting hours. If we change our sitting hours too much, we will deter people from becoming Lords or from remaining Lords when they still have something to offer but need the adapted lifestyle that our rather strange hours produce. In past debates over hours in the House of Lords, the main case for shifting our hours forward to earlier in the day has been that people have family and caring responsibilities and that those responsibilities tend to be more concentrated in the evenings, when people wish to be with their families, so perhaps we should have family-friendly hours. I see nothing family-friendly in working to 8.30 pm. If we gave up at 8.30 pm rather than 10 pm, people would probably still not get home much before 9.30 pm in most cases, given the difficult transport position in London. Obviously, people who come from a long way away cannot get home anyway and have to stay overnight; for them, it is a nuisance that the House of Lords does not work on, because they would rather that the House worked on but over fewer days so that they could get back to their home for a longer weekend and come in on Monday rather later. So I do not see how the family-friendly bit works. What I do see is that noble Lords who have other serious jobs would find it more difficult if the hours were brought forward, whereas you can do a very serious job in the morning until lunchtime and then come in and make your contribution to the House of Lords in the afternoon. That seems a sensible approach. There is also the argument that if the hours were changed the working lunch on Tuesdays and/or Wednesdays would disappear because people would need to be in the Chamber at a much earlier hour. That would have an impact on the catering staff and facilities, and it would probably make it more difficult for those who are doing a full-time job in the House of Lords most days, who may wish to have working lunches with people. Regarding the dinner hour, it is likely that most people would go home and not stay to dinner, whereas quite a few people stay to dinner now. That can be an important collegiate opportunity. I like the feature in the Lords of the cross-party common table, because it gives us a chance to have informal cross-party conversations in a friendly way, which can often be helpful to both the Government and the Opposition in clarifying what we are doing. Again, there would be difficulty for the catering staff and facilities if far fewer covers were served at the dinner hour because we had finished early. There is also the question of a clash with committees if you drag the sitting hours too far forward into the morning or lunchtime. There is also the issue of educational visits, which would be impaired if the main Chamber started earlier, because people would obviously not have the same access to the building that they have at the moment, when the main facilities are not being used by your Lordships in the morning or at lunchtime. Putting all that together, I conclude, as someone who is not against good change, that I would keep the present hours as they are because people have arranged their lives around them accordingly. I favour that great diversity. One thing that works, which is difficult to explain to people outside, is that about the right number of Peers seem to turn up for most of the debates and committee scrutiny, and we do not have crowding on the red Benches. Looking at the total membership, you might think that that would be quite a problem. The House is self-regulating: there are enough Peers who want to do a serious job every day and there are enough other Peers with great talent, experience and skills who come in from time to time when those are relevant. That works well and provides a balance. Members of the public who are concerned about there being too many Peers need to remember that they are paid only if they turn up, which is an excellent part of the system. We get for nothing the experience on tap of all the Peers who do not participate very much, but we pay a day rate for those Peers who turn up regularly and do the real work in the Chamber of scrutinising the Government and opposing or defending their ideas. In conclusion, I very strongly recommend that we do not tamper with the hours and that we appreciate what we have and do a better job of selling it to the wider public, because I do not think they understand why the membership is so big. They do not understand that it provides extremely good value, given the remuneration system, and they do not understand how we can then harness the experience and talent in the way that we do.
Lord Stoneham of Droxford (LD)
My Lords, I thank the Senior Deputy Speaker for initiating this debate. I am a little disappointed that there are not more people from the Government Benches here. I am speaking in a personal capacity as a former group Chief Whip. Apart from the Government Chief Whip here today, I have probably spent more time in the House in the last nine years at late hours than anybody else in this Room. I have some experience that I should like to share as to why I support the proposed new sitting times for Tuesdays and Wednesdays as a long overdue reform of the House. The key question should be: will the revised hours improve the effectiveness and quality of our scrutiny work of the Government? In my view, of course it will because sitting late helps absolutely nobody. Few like it and most people vote with their feet anyway, and they are not here. That is the reality and 10 pm on a regular basis is too late, in my book. There is a slightly ridiculous system. Unless there is an agreement between the Whips, the Government have to keep 100 people here so that they are not ambushed and, if there is an agreement with the Opposition, 30 people here, to make sure that the House is not adjourned because it is not quorate. The reality is that on most evenings, particularly after dinner, the number in the Chamber is down to about 20 on average. That is my experience and the number gets even lower as the evening goes on. You can end up some evenings—I have been there—as one of two on our Benches, two on the Government Benches and two on the Conservative Benches. That is the reality. Votes are hopeless after dinner. The Opposition should know that. We can rarely win a vote after dinner because everybody disappears. What is the effect of that? Oppositions like to keep up the morale of their troops by wearing the Government down. I have done it. We feel good from wearing Ministers down by keeping them here late at night. But is this good for government? Is it good in practice? No, it is not. Does it improve government? No, it does not. One day, Oppositions will be in government and will realise that. Finishing at 8.30 pm will mean that more people will stay to see the day through. Votes will be more meaningful up to that time, whereas they are not after dinner on the current arrangements. We will not miss the scrutiny that we currently have after dinner. That is the reality. There is one major concern against the change. I am surprised that the noble Lord, Lord Redwood, did not mention this but I will address it because that is what people say to me. They say, “We will meet earlier and still sit late”. That is what worries people, regardless of the change. We will have longer hours. That will be the reality. That is what people say. But this underestimates the power of convention in this self-regulating House and, indeed, the responsiveness of the usual channels. The Companion says that it is a firm convention for the House to finish at about 10 pm on a Monday through to a Wednesday, and 7 pm on Thursdays. This convention will change on Tuesdays and Wednesdays to 8.30 pm. The reality of that is that the usual channels will then be under pressure to keep to that, except for exceptional circumstances. Those normally happen when you are trying to finish a Bill and it just makes for convenience and to meet deadlines before a Prorogation. That is the reality. Agreement is important in the usual channels, so people should understand. I know that the usual channels are often criticised and are a bit of a mystery. But one thing that is absolutely right in this House is that when relationships in the usual channels collapse, the House gets into a real mess. It is therefore important that in the usual channels—I was there and know what it is like—we always try to keep relationships together because it is a nightmare when those relationships break down. Eventually, it becomes so intolerable for people in the House that they call for the usual channels to meet and sort it out. When I was a Whip that is what we did. Relationships in the usual channels are important and if the convention is 8.30 pm for the finish, the Government Chief Whip will be under pressure from the Opposition Whips to keep to that unless there are special circumstances, as they do now for 10 pm. I do not buy this argument that if we agree to an 8.30 pm finish and an earlier starting time we will actually lengthen the hours of the House. It will be up to the House, as a self-regulating House, to make sure that that does not happen. But I think, with the relationships of the usual channels as they are, that that argument will not wash. That is the main argument I have heard against this change, but we have heard a few more from the noble Lord, Lord Redwood, so let me address some of them. We had them the last time we had this debate, and I remember debating with the now Lord Speaker, the noble Lord, Lord Forsyth, in quite difficult circumstances. Let us deal with each of the arguments put up by the noble Lord, Lord Redwood. We were told that school visits would reduce by 4,000 or 5,000 pupils a year. We have an education centre. We have to adapt if it works for the working of the House to meet earlier. I think that by meeting earlier we will give more of an opportunity for pupils to stay for 1 pm, to see the proceedings happening, before they have to go back to school, whereas now they do not wait until 2.30 pm. They have the trip round the Chamber, but they probably do not stay for the proceedings. I do not buy the argument that school visits will be inconvenienced. We have to change, and they can be accommodated. Catering budgets will suffer, we are told. We do not run the Lords to run a catering service. The needs of the House come first, I am afraid, and the catering service can adapt. In fact, if more people stay till 8.30 pm it will benefit, and more people may come in for lunch at a slightly earlier time. It will probably be easier to recruit staff. So I do not buy the catering argument. Then we are told that having a slightly earlier time will hit people working outside the House. Well, 1 pm is a marginal change. People here mix and match what they do; they are on Select Committees, they go to other meetings in the House, they do outside work, and they deal with legislation. We mix and match the whole time. I think it is perfectly compatible with people working outside the House to have a 1 pm start. Anyway, not everybody is here when the House starts at 2.30 pm. People mix and match. Then another argument we get is that camaraderie over the dining table is important. I thought the noble Baroness, Lady Morgan, was terrific in the debate we had back in 2022: “Camaraderie comes because we work together … it does not come because we dine together ”.—[ Official Report , 5/7/22; col. 977.] I agree with that. Last time, the vote was quite close. It was ruined—I remember it well—because a couple of years before we had a vote that included Mondays for an early start, with the consequence that all our friends from Scotland and from distant places voted against that change to having an early start on Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday. We are not considering it this time. When we had the second vote in 2022, it was still slightly confused by that original debate. Indeed, the number of people who voted last time was really poor: 284. I am delighted that we have a consultation of more than 350 so far. I am looking forward to seeing what the consultation results show. I suspect that there is growing support for improved hours in the House. Better hours will improve the working of the House and the effectiveness of scrutiny of the Government. That should be our major consideration. We should put more emphasis on improving scrutiny than simply wearing Governments or people down. If we have these earlier hours, we will stop the ridiculous situation where Peers are going home as public transport declines in the evening; indeed, some evenings, when we go very late, there is no public transport at all. We will make life better for people working in the House, and that will make it more attractive. We should make this change.
Lord Moylan (Con)
My Lords, I am speaking purely from personal experience. I thank the noble Lord, Lord Ponsonby, for initiating this debate, and I, like the noble Lord, Lord Stoneham, am disappointed at the relatively poor attendance. Although I am speaking early, like him, I discern that the majority of speakers are, in fact, going to be opposed to the change. I think it would have been better if there had been more advocates of the change to explain, with varying degrees of persuasion and persuasive force, why we should make this change. It is sad that they are not here. I do not have any outside appointments—no one wants me—but having been quite ill a few years ago, I still have an awful lot of hospital appointments to go to, and I am able to co-ordinate those largely so that they are in the morning. I just want it to be borne in mind that those people who have things to do in the morning are not all active in pursuit of filthy lucre. It is not all about Peers going off and earning money and having two jobs; we have other obligations as well, some of which we would like to escape. I do not want to go to hospital as frequently as I do. We have those obligations and need the time to attend to them. In my case, I treat this role in the House of Lords as a full-time activity at the moment. I do not, as I say, have outside appointments; I do have outside obligations. I am not persuaded by the argument from the noble Lord, Lord Stoneham, that we will have better scrutiny as a result of this. Changing things like this has serious consequences for Members, less so for me than others, and we need to bear that in mind. The first objection to this—and the noble Lord, Lord Stoneham, seeks to deal with it—is that nobody really believes it will work. We have a convention for finishing at 10 pm but, increasingly, I see Today’s List coming out saying not that the Chamber will rise at 10 pm or at about 10 pm, but that the Chamber will rise at the conclusion of Report stage or of some other piece of business. I see the Whips, grim-faced, staring at me. The Government Whips are an effective lot. They get their way and get the Government’s business through, and they do not hesitate to trample over convention or the convenience of noble Lords in their pursuit of that task. To that extent, we must congratulate them on their effectiveness. On Thursdays when we have only debates, of course the House will rise about 7 pm, but on Mondays to Wednesdays, when the Whips want to get business through, we will stay late, and this will create greater opportunities to do so. Staying beyond 10 pm is so egregious that it is a difficult thing to do, but 9 pm is just little bit longer than 8.30 pm. What is the difference in that? You are not going to get home for the repeats of “Vera”, which so many of us love, because they are on at 8 pm anyway, so stay until 9 pm. It is no difficulty. Settle down and have a bite to eat while you are doing it. You can hear all those arguments. It is cynical, but nobody actually believes that this is going to stick at 8.30 pm. A point I raised when we debated this in 2022—I think I am correct in saying the noble Lord, Lord Stoneham, said—is that nobody seems to have consulted the staff. I found this astonishing at the time.
Lord Stoneham of Droxford (LD)
That is not true.
Lord Moylan (Con)
For a proposition that was advocated for so much by the Labour Party, on that occasion there was consultation with management about whether the changes could be put into effect but no consultation with staff trade unions and staff associations about what the changes ought to be. Somebody—I am not sure who it was—shouted out just now from a sedentary position that there has been such consultation at the moment and trade unions and staff associations have been consulted. None of those responses have been vouchsafed to noble Lords. If that has taken place this time, as it should have done, perhaps we can see it. We should have seen it before we were invited to feed into the consultation. I am concerned about the change in the character of the House. There are those who wish to see membership of the House become a full-time, daytime job, like a nine-to-five job, in fact very much as the House of Commons has become. It is a perfectly respectable position to hold that view—if that is one’s view, that is absolutely fine—but the change in character of the House of Lords would be much more profound than the change that has occurred in the character of the House of Commons as a result of that. I am particularly concerned about the consequences for the age profile. We are an elderly House. I think it is to our discredit in the public mind that we are such an elderly House, because people look at us and think we are a bunch of old fogies. How do you persuade younger people to come into the House who might have careers—the people of experience and ability whom we wish to attract to this House—if doing so will preclude their external activities? Not everything everyone does is done to make a lot of money. Chairing a public body can be very time-consuming; two days a week is the normal sort of commitment made if someone is going to chair a major public body. We just had an appointment to the chairmanship of Great British Railways in the last few days—that is a two-day-a-week commitment. Sir John Kingman would not be able to accept an invitation to join this House if we became a full-time House, because he has to commit two days a week elsewhere to chairing Great British Railways. That is the sort of thing that becomes very difficult for people to do, especially if they are younger. It would mean great change and consequences for the age profile of the House, which worries me already. As I have said, any change such as this—which I oppose—is going to have little personal effect on me because of my own circumstances, so I think I can speak about it from a disinterested position. Other noble Lords have the opportunity to say for themselves through the consultation how it is going to affect them. What I took away from the speech of my noble friend Lord Redwood was that this change would not only affect other noble Lords. There are 10,000 people working on the Parliamentary Estate—of course, not all of them are at this end; the majority of them are working in relation to the other place. This change will affect a huge number of people who have happily tailored their lives to the existing working hours of your Lordships’ House. They will have their lives changed significantly, but we seem to be giving so little consideration to their interests, which seems to me a very great shame. Finally, I conclude with a question to the noble Lord, Lord Ponsonby, which he may want to pick up at the end, as to whether speeches made in the course of this debate are being fed formally into the consultation process. It would be a great pity if we all had this debate and gave our views, but then it was, so to speak, as nothing from the point of view of the consultation response.
Lord Blencathra (Con)
My Lords, I too congratulate the noble Lord, Lord Ponsonby of Shulbrede, on initiating this important debate. I exempt him from any criticism I may make of this consultation and the process. I have in my hand here the entirety of the consultation process for changing the sitting hours of the second Chamber of the Parliament of the United Kingdom: two sides of a bit of paper. Neville Chamberlain returned from Munich waving a bit of paper and saying, “Peace for our time”. I wave this flimsy document and say, “Chaos for our time”, because, on the basis of this document, that is what we might get. This is not a consultation in any meaningful sense of the word. It is, in essence, a multiple-choice tick-box questionnaire: “Do we want Tuesday? Do we want Wednesday? Do we want both? Just tick the box, my Lords”. There is no requirement to consider the effect on legislative scrutiny; no requirement to consider the effect on committees or on staff; no requirement to consider the effect on Members who live outside London and cannot get home at night; no requirement to consider the effect on the culture of the House. We are simply asked which option we would prefer. Even more remarkably, the accompanying papers tell us that much of the analysis on service implications is still being processed, so only after we have ignorantly ticked the box will the Procedure Committee then figure out what changes will be made to committee sitting hours. Only afterwards will the Services Committee decide on what dining services to withdraw, because they will no longer be viable for the fewer Peers attending after 8.30 pm. What other serious changes to our practical operating procedures will have to be made and have not been mentioned in this rather scrappy document? We are being asked for our conclusions before the evidence has been assembled. That is not evidence-based policy making; it is policy-making backwards. I oppose these proposals, as noble Lords may have gathered, but I also oppose the process by which they are being advanced. I have a particular advantage and perhaps a particular burden in this debate. I served in the House of Commons both before and after the introduction of the so-called family-friendly hours. There are only two other Peers participating in this debate who have that experience, my noble friends Lady Laing of Elderslie and Lord Redwood; the vast majority of noble Lords in the House do not have that experience, but the three of us do. We witnessed the consequences at first hand. Supporters of those changes promised a more modern Parliament. What they did not foresee was the effect on parliamentary culture. The greatest losses were not measured in hours; they were measured in relationships. Before those changes, Members from all parties met informally throughout the day. We talked over breakfast, lunch and coffee. We talked while waiting for committees. Political opponents knew each other. After the introduction of the new hours, much of that slowly disappeared. The Commons dining rooms have become largely deserted on Tuesday and Wednesday evenings. Members rush from home to go straight on to a committee, first thing in the morning, and then on to the Chamber or one commitment after another, with no thinking time and no chance to talk to colleagues informally, even those on their own side. Cross-party contact diminished. Politics became more tribal. I think we would all agree that the Commons has become a harsher place in the past 25 years. The lesson I learned from that is simple: changing the clock changes the culture. Those advocating this proposal speak as though they are moving a hand on a watch. In reality, they are changing the character of an institution. Every Member of the House is equal, and every Member’s opinion deserves respect in this consultation. However, not every Member of the House of Lords possesses the same depth of experience of parliamentary procedure. For decisions of this magnitude, institutional memory matters. Those who served in Parliament before and after the Commons reforms possess direct evidence about what happens in practice. We witnessed the consequences. Likewise, Members who have spent many years in this House serving on committees, scrutinising legislation and participating in House business necessarily possess a deeper understanding of how procedural changes affect parliamentary effectiveness. There is one Member in this Committee who has 36 years’ experience of serving in the House of Lords. It is fortunate that that is the noble Lord, Lord Ponsonby of Shulbrede, the Senior Deputy Speaker—and, of course, the Government Chief Whip has 25 years’ experience.
Captain of the Honourable Corps of Gentlemen-at-Arms and Chief Whip (Lord Kennedy of Southwark) (Lab Co-op)
It is 16 years.
Lord Blencathra (Con)
I thought it was 25 years. Of course, they are absolutely neutral in this debate, but I suspect that they agree with what I am saying, although they cannot acknowledge that. Since July 2024, 122 new peerages have been created. Almost 80 of those Members are relatively new to parliamentary life and have inevitably had less opportunity to experience the detailed workings of Lords committees, legislative scrutiny and parliamentary procedure. I make no criticism of those colleagues. However, when evaluating changes of long-term constitutional significance, greater weight should naturally be attached to those with extensive operational experience, rather than new Peers who were just sworn in the last few months and have never served on any committees. I turn to the family-friendly argument. I have heard that phrase repeated over the years, but family-friendly for whom? Even in the Commons, a 7 pm finish never meant that Members automatically got home in time to read the kiddies their bedtime stories. Many were still travelling across London or much further afield. The children were often asleep before they arrived home. Whatever force that argument once had in the Commons, it has little relevance here. The average age of the House is around 71. We are primarily not a House of parents rushing home to supervise homework. There is, however, one respectable argument. An earlier finish might permit Peers and their spouses or partners to participate more fully in civic, charitable, social or cultural life. That argument has some merit, but it is not what is being proposed. If we were talking about finishing at 6.30 pm or 7 pm, one could understand it—one could do those things—but 8.30 pm is neither fish nor fowl. It is too late for most evening engagements and too early to justify sacrificing the advantages of the current arrangements. What exactly can most people do at 8.30 pm that they cannot do at 10 pm? The answer is, “Very little”, and who would benefit from an earlier finish? This consultation is London-centric. Only London-based Members or those within the M25 would get home at night. All of us other, provincial Peers will have to retreat to our luxurious London hotels, costing £125 per night. That is not acceptable. One of the greatest strengths of the House of Lords is that it is not a full-time legislature. Indeed, our value lies precisely in the fact that many Members do not spend all day inside Westminster. The Chamber is an extraordinary national asset. Within it sit former Cabinet Ministers, ambassadors, judges, surgeons, scientists, engineers, military commanders, intelligence chiefs, academics, vice-chancellors, entrepreneurs, business leaders, charity founders and leaders of faith communities. We do not possess all this expertise despite our outside experience; we possess it because of our outside experience. As my noble friend Lord Moylan pointed out, many Members continue to serve on public bodies; they chair inquiries, lead charities, practise professions, advise industries and remain connected to the real world beyond Westminster. That connection enriches every debate we have. It brings reality into legislation. It brings experience into scrutiny and expertise into public policy. The present sitting pattern accommodates that contribution. An earlier start inevitably places pressure on it. Supporters describe this as a modest procedural change. I suggest that it is far more significant than that. It nudges the House towards becoming a more conventional full-time legislature. I fear for the Cross-Benchers in particular. I disagree with how they vote most of the time but, nevertheless, they are a unique feature of this House. Their authority rests upon not party organisation but professional achievement and specialised knowledge. If parliamentary business increasingly crowds out the external activities from which that expertise derives, we risk weakening one of the most valuable components of this Chamber. Experience is evidence and the House must give it proper weight. I turn now to a crucial point: our role in scrutiny. The House of Lords performs an increasingly important revising role. Successive Governments have relied on this House to identify defects, improve drafting and correct omissions that escape adequate scrutiny elsewhere. The constitutional value of the House of Lords lies primarily in the quality of our scrutiny. Any reform, therefore, should be judged by one simple test: will it improve scrutiny? Twiddling with the start and finishing times by 90 minutes a day will do nothing for improving the scrutiny and quality of primary legislation or statutory instruments; that can be done only with major procedural changes to deal with the way that we handle primary and secondary legislation. The changes that would really improve scrutiny include: giving many more draft Bills pre-legislative scrutiny; the Government tabling more draft affirmative SIs; the power for the Lords to amend SIs; greatly reduced numbers of Henry VIII clauses and Bills; no more skeleton legislation where Bills have little substance but many regulation-making powers; and then hidden regulation via guidance that has to be obeyed but does not go through Parliament. These are some of the changes which would really improve parliamentary scrutiny but, of course, they are not on offer just now—and never will be, because no Government will ever give us those powers. I say this to the noble Lord, Lord Stoneham: the only thing that would improve parliamentary scrutiny is those changes, not an extra 90 minutes in the day or an early start. Some say that an earlier start and finish might persuade more Peers to turn up and vote if the votes are not too late in the evening but, in response to the noble Lord, Lord Stoneham, 20 more Peers voting is not increased scrutiny. It may mean 20 more speeches in Parliament, of course, but no persuasive evidence that finishing at 8.30 pm instead of 10 pm will improve scrutiny is being produced. Indeed, there are strong grounds for believing that the proposed changes may create new pressures without delivering any corresponding benefits. I move on to our overnight allowance. We rightly get our travel refunded, an untaxed daily allowance and, now, an untaxed overnight stay allowance—which is pitifully inadequate, in my opinion, but that is another matter. However, I sometimes hear Peers at the Lord Speaker’s forum calling for an increase in some allowances. The Lord Speaker and others point out that these things must be agreed with the Inland Revenue, which rigorously polices the justification for any non-taxed allowance. What might the Inland Revenue say when we tell it that we still want the overnight stay allowance agreed for when we finish at 10 pm, but that now we may finish at 8.30 pm? We might be on dangerous ground with our overnight allowance, and it could affect scores of Peers who may then be considered capable of getting home to places well outside the M25. We cannot make this change without consulting and having firm evidence about what the Inland Revenue might say or do. I turn to the point about dining together, another issue which troubles me greatly. Many people—including, I think, the noble Lord, Lord Stoneham—regard dining together as irrelevant; they regard it as a social activity. I regard it as a constitutional asset of this House. This House works because Members encounter one another outside formal proceedings. We argue in the Chamber and we continue discussion over lunch, tea or dinner. Political opponents sit together; Cross-Benchers sit with party politicians. Relationships develop, misunderstandings are resolved and consensus becomes possible. That is partly why our Select Committee reports are often unanimous, and it is why debate here remains remarkably civil compared with so many other legislatures. The Long Table tradition is not a curiosity; it is a mechanism through which Parliament functions better. Some other countries understand this. I have researched it and found that other parliamentary systems have recognised the same principle. Examples include Iceland’s Althing, Sweden’s Riksdag and the Federal Palace in Bern, Switzerland. Although none of these exactly replicates the Long Table tradition, they have introduced a system whereby their members can sit together to eat, drink and speak informally. At a time when democracies across Europe are becoming increasingly polarised, why should we deliberately weaken one of the institutions that helps preserve civility and mutual respect? I will not say much on the staff consultation because my noble friend Lord Moylan has already done so, but the staff have not been properly consulted on this. If they have been, we should see what they have said before we come to tick the boxes on this rather shoddy form. This debate is not really about whether we start at 1 pm or 2.30 pm. It is about what sort of institution we want this House to be. Do we want a House characterised by expertise, experience, scrutiny, independence and collegiality, or do we want to gradually become another version of the House of Commons? I know which House I was proud to join in 2011, and which House I wish to preserve. For that reason, I oppose these proposals.
Baroness Laing of Elderslie (Con)
My Lords, what a pleasure it is to follow the excellent speech of my noble friend Lord Blencathra, who has just about said it all. I will make three short points but, before doing so, I thank the Senior Deputy Speaker for bringing forward this debate and giving your Lordships the opportunity to participate in this consultation. My first point is about the consultation. I was very disappointed, when filling it in, to note that we are not asked to identify where we live and go home to when this House rises in the evening. There is a huge difference between someone who lives within walking distance, someone who lives an hour away on public transport and someone who lives in Scotland, Devon, Wales or Yorkshire. The difference is enormous, and this consultation would have been a lot more meaningful—I hope the Senior Deputy Speaker does not mind my making this point directly to him—if it were divided into responses from people who live in different places. I therefore challenge whether the results of this consultation are valid at all, given that that distinction has not been made. Secondly, I turn to the question of the nature of this House. Being a Member of the House of Lords is not a job; it is public service. I am sure that all noble Lords present in this room are proud to say that they carry out a public service. We must not pretend that we are doing a normal nine-to-five job because that is not what it is about. As my noble friend Lord Blencathra so eloquently said, we need people in this House who bring expertise and experience from every walk of life, not just those who have retired from their main career, but those who are still working in their main career. That is what gives this place its exceptional and unusual value. Therefore, we have to sit at times which accommodate other professions, jobs or other requirements in people’s lives, and that includes being family friendly. There are not many Members of your Lordships’ House who as a parliamentarian have given birth to a child and brought up that child, hopefully safely, to adulthood while being a full-time parliamentarian, but I have, and I can tell noble Lords that it is the flexibility of our hours that matters. It is not when we begin and when we end; it is the flexibility so that you can carry out your family duties as well as your parliamentary duties. The idea that stopping at 8.30 pm would in fact be more family friendly is, I am afraid, nonsense. My noble friend Lord Blencathra has made all the points about the importance of the way in which we interact with one another. This is not a normal place of work. This is a Parli-a-ment. It is a place where people come to talk to one another, to interact with one another. The fact that we sit outside normal working hours is a vital part of that. Thirdly, I turn to the idea that 8.30 pm could be a normal rising time because that is what this consultation proposes. The fact is that 8.30 pm is neither one thing nor another. It is not early enough to carry out our family obligations or social obligations or even to go to the theatre or anything else that one might want to do of an evening. It is too late for that, but it is not early enough to take up the whole evening. If you have come all the way from Devon or Scotland and you want to spend your three full working days in this place, you are going to waste an awful lot of time after 8.30 pm because then nothing can really be usefully done. I also say to your Lordships that the idea of normally rising at 8.30 pm is a fiction. I ask your Lordships: what actually is the problem that this consultation and proposal is trying to solve? What is the question that needs to be answered? I suggest that the problem that appears to have arisen is that new Members have come to Parliament unaware of how Parliament actually works. They have been horrified to discover that they are expected to be here to defend the Government’s majority until late at night, and therefore they have complained. I suggest that, if we were to put these proposals into action, they would not solve that problem. Normally rising at 8.30 pm would not mean that we would rise at 8.30 pm. I put it to your Lordships that that is not the problem; the problem is that too many people speak for too long and too often. I dare to suggest to your Lordships, within earshot of the Government Chief Whip, that what we really need in order to have a more efficient and effective House, is time limits on speeches and a formal end to proceedings at 10 pm, a rule that we stop at 10 pm unless, in exceptional circumstances, the House votes not to do so and to go past 10 pm. I know that your Lordships will say to me, “Don’t you understand that this is a self-regulating House and therefore time limits on speeches could not possibly be imposed and could not possibly work?” Well, I think that is also a fiction. I am relatively new to this House, and I have been astounded at the patience that your Lordships show in their self-regulation for those who speak for much longer than is necessary. We do not need to change the sitting hours; we need to be more self-aware, we need to be more disciplined, and we need to be more considerate of others. I dare your Lordships to give consideration to the possibility of a formal stop at 10 pm and real time limits to speeches that must be observed. I promised myself that with a 15-minute limit, I would speak for less than 10, so I had better stop at 8 minutes and 42 seconds. Some 30 years of participation in parliamentary debates has taught me that that which can be said in 20 minutes can usually be said far more effectively in 10, and I have spoken for 8 minutes and 56 seconds.
Baroness Lawlor (Con)
My Lords, it is a pleasure to follow my noble friend Lady Laing of Elderslie. I thank the Senior Deputy Speaker for bringing this debate and for all the thought and neutrality he has bought today and previously. The sitting hours of this House are a compromise which fit no individual’s way of life perfectly. Rather, in order to contribute to its work, we all have to adjust our lives to them, often making complicated arrangements which, over time, have come to work smoothly. This is one important reason why we should be circumspect about making changes. Any change will come with a considerable cost to everyone and in upset to the established patterns of the lives that they have framed to meet the many different commitments they may have in addition to the work of this House. Any such change would need to bring a great deal of extra good before it outweighed the harm. In fact, the change now proposed—starting and finishing earlier on two days—will be damaging in itself, undoing our finely balanced compromise. On the first level, that compromise is between the need to have enough sitting hours for, on the one hand, the Government’s business and the House’s business and, on the other, the demands of noble Lords’ lives. On the second level, the compromise is between the different sorts of demands. There are three main types. First, many Members are engaged in professions or work apart from their functions here. As has been said today, and as we all recognise, this is one of the central features of this House, which gathers mainly not professional politicians—although we do benefit from them—but all kinds of people, including experts of different kinds from different walks of life. Many are engaged with their specialist area of expertise, be it the law, business, medicine, the media, universities, the sciences or humanities, local government or the voluntary and charitable sector. Secondly, there are demands that relate more directly to the business of the House: careful preparation for Bills; committee meetings; contributions; and, for some, ministerial duties. Thirdly, there are the demands of family and social life, which also came up in the previous consultation and which might include parenting, grandparenting and other caring duties. The new proposals ostensibly concern a compromise between the different sorts of demand. Given the number of sitting hours needed, the first of these demands—to balance the work that we do for this House and the work that we do outside, perhaps, or our preparations for this House—can be met by the present sitting hours. It leaves a good part of the working day on Mondays, Tuesdays and Wednesdays to do that work, prepare and so on. It also leaves time for all the other demands because, on Thursdays, Fridays, Saturdays and Sundays, we have time for them. It is a compromise, but it allows for the different sorts of activity, specialism and preparation. Those proposing change may not agree. Some may think that the compromise should be weighted more towards family and social life than it is at present. I disagree with that. Most people bearing equivalent responsibilities outside, in other jobs, have to accommodate family and caring commitments. They have to accommodate them with their professional work and obligations. Even if noble Lords are no longer working outside our House, they will have had to do so during their working life. In any case, as noble Lords have already said, the proposed change to 8.30 pm on Tuesdays and Wednesdays will not achieve the objective sought. If the House rises at 8.30 pm, noble Lords might, if they are lucky, be home at 9.15 pm or 9.30 pm at the earliest, if they live nearby. However, for many of us, as has been mentioned—I am an example of it—if your commute is at least two hours, and sometimes longer when the trains do not work, an 8.30 pm finish will allow no one a social or family life. For many of us, an 8.30 pm finish will still mean that we will be lucky to be home by 11 pm if the trains run. I say to the noble Lord that it is not only the last trains that tend to be cancelled; some days, all trains are cancelled after, say, 6 pm because of a problem on the line or something else. The noble Lord mentioned that it would be easier to travel by train if we left earlier, because we would be more certain of getting home, but, with the way transport is, I do not think that we would. Anyway, I do not believe that an 8.30 pm change will make any great difference to the demands that we have. There is also reason to fear that the new proposals will adjust things just for the first level of compromise by increasing our total number of sitting hours, leaving us with less time for anything else—work or social—since the Tuesday and Wednesday sessions proposed, if we take both days, are being made three and a half hours earlier in all, while only three hours is planned to be trimmed at the end. More seriously, it is hard to believe that an 8.30 pm finishing time will in fact mean an 8.30 pm finish. I enjoy the repartee—and feel that it was probably true—where the Whips get together and agree that it is how to keep their Members there for the important votes. It will not necessarily make government business any easier to get through. I do not agree that it would be less likely to stop a drift from 8.30 onwards to finishing a little later. I say in response to the noble Lord, Lord Stoneham, that I see what he is getting at when he says that there will be dwindling numbers and that he does not like to see them. An 8.30 pm finish will make no difference to that. People are here late at night, in Committee on a Bill or in a Second Reading debate, because they have expertise, interest and specialism and are involved. They will be there for the 8.30 pm sitting as much as they are there now. It will not make a difference. It reflects their specialism, experience and involvement in different subjects where they want to help with the scrutiny, particularly because they can contribute. I still see them there last thing at night; in fact, there is quite a camaraderie when the last groups of amendments are called. People stay to contribute if they are interested and knowledgeable about the subject. In my view, the proposed changes will do harm and not produce the desired results. Most importantly, the work of this House will suffer if sitting times prevent Members preparing properly and exclude them from professional activities that allow this Chamber to scrutinise, do the work it does and fulfil its important role in a bicameral system. I therefore oppose any change.
Lord Jamieson (Con)
My Lords, I echo many of the comments that other noble Lords have made. I, too, thank the Senior Deputy Speaker for this debate and the way in which he introduced it. The key question for me is: what is the problem we are trying to solve, and do the benefits outweigh the disadvantages? A number of noble Lords have spoken about why they believe that there are significantly more disadvantages than advantages. I thank the noble Lord, Lord Stoneham, because it is good to have an advocate to explain why he believes that there are positives to this proposal. He introduced the issue of scrutiny; I would like to come back to that later because it is an important point, although I disagree with him on it. In the consultation, at least, the key point is that this is about enabling noble Lords to return home at a reasonable hour and participate in family life. I echo the opinion of many other noble Lords that, quite frankly, the difference between 8.30 pm and 10 pm to family life, such as putting your children to bed and so on, is pretty small and would not have a dramatic impact; it is similar if you wanted to go out of an evening. So I am not sure that that is really the case—albeit there may be one or two people who live around the corner who would see a significant benefit. The alternative question is on attendance and the quality of debate when we go long into the night. In my two and a half years here, I do not have the experience of many other noble Lords, but I have experienced finishing at one o’clock or two o’clock at night. I have to say, it was not particularly enjoyable. The noble Lord, Lord Stoneham, was right to say that there were only one or two people from each Bench there, but sitting late at night is not an issue of when we start the day; it is about the fact that we have too much poor-quality legislation. I am talking about not the principle of legislation but poor drafting and lots of late amendments coming in. In fact, we are about to debate the Representation of the People Bill. I am told that we are going to get more than 100 government amendments half way through Committee. That is not the right way to do proper scrutiny. If we could fix that, I am sure that we would have much better scrutiny and that it would have a much impact than starting an hour earlier. However, I see a lot of downsides in these proposals. A number of noble Lords have raised the fact that we are a very diverse House; we have a lot of expertise on very different issues. In fact, one of the most interesting debates I heard was on broccoli and Brussels sprouts. That sounds a very esoteric topic, but it was a brilliant debate, going through the whole farming gamut from fertilisers to planting, logistics change and whatever. The reason it was such a good debate is that we had a vast range of people with different niche expertise, and so you realised just what it takes to get a Brussels sprout on your Christmas dinner table and all the things that have to work. I am not so sure that we would have had that interesting debate in the other place. It is just an example of what we can do as scrutiny. I say, as a new Peer, that that is what I have seen because we do not have people with full-time parliamentary careers. They have careers outside this place and bring that knowledge to it. I worry that, if we move towards a full-time professional House, we will completely change the character of the House. That is the thing that most worries me about this. It is a move towards excluding other people who bring so much expertise to the House. My own experience from my only other role in life at the moment, as a councillor, is that one of the benefits of having Monday and Tuesday mornings is that I can stay in my patch, meet residents and attend meetings. If I have to be here an hour and a half earlier all of a sudden, that will be gone. The hour and a half extra I would get in the evening is not meaningful. An hour and a half on a morning is a full morning. When you are halfway through the night, an hour and a half is not a full evening. It will also impact those who commute. I live 90 minutes or so away from here, when the trains are running properly, which means that most days I can commute and go back. When I know I am going to be late, until 10 pm or whatever, I book a hotel. I am sure there are many like me; there are others who, because they live in Scotland or wherever, will stay here all week. What are they supposed to do with that extra hour in the evening? That full morning is much more useful. People have mentioned the collegiate issue of dinner. In every organisation where I have worked, the best work, where you solve the problems and discuss in depth, is done outside the formal meetings—in the Chamber or whatever. It is over dinner or the water- cooler moments. Those are really important. I have had so many incredibly helpful conversations with world-renowned experts down in the canteen, on the Long Table or in the coffee room. The loss of those would be huge because that is brought to the Chamber. In fact, in many instances a problem is solved and is not even brought to the Chamber, so I really care about that for the operation of the House. Oher noble Lords have raised the issue of how committees will work, so I will not go on to it or talk about other meetings, such as the group meetings. When we want to meet with outside parties, meeting in and around lunchtime works incredibly well. I am not so confident of having so many takers to meet in and around 8 pm or 9 pm. Again, that is a loss of the opportunity to engage with outside parties. As others have said, I fear that 8.30 pm will not be seen as a hard stop; it will be a soft stop. It is a lot easier to just nibble away at, whereas at 10 pm, as others have said, people start voting with their feet. Others have raised the issue of staff and facilities and so on, so I will not do so, but I want to get on to the point of scrutiny. Yes, the number of people in the Chamber is an important factor in scrutiny. But even more important is the quality of debate, the diversity of opinions that are there and the expertise of the people involved. If you start excluding people who are not willing to be here because they have other careers or are involved in other organisations, we will weaken our debates. I have been here at 10 pm or even 11 pm with significant numbers of people because it was an important debate and they had real value to add. Yes, I have also been here when there have been only a few people here because, frankly, we were going through the motions—the debate had already happened on the key issues. That diversity of opinion and expertise is absolutely critical, and we cannot lose that from this House. It is something we add in the parliamentary process that does not happen in the other place. I am puzzled. I can see many downsides to this proposal, but little upside. We should not seek change for change’s sake. If the concern is really that we have too many Sittings very late at night, would it not be better to examine why this is the case, rather than facilitating the problem by, in effect, extending the hours of this House?
Baroness Meyer (Con)
My Lords, I, too, thank the Senior Deputy Speaker for scheduling this debate and introducing it so well. It is my honour to follow so many noble Lords’ excellent speeches; I am going to repeat some of them, I am afraid, because so many good points were made. I, too, see no compelling reasons to change our sitting hours. Our long-established arrangements serve this House well. What problem are we trying to solve? Would these changes create more difficulties than they resolve? I recognise that our present hours do not suit everybody, but any change must bring clear benefits to the House as a whole. These proposed changes would force Members to choose between attending committee meetings and taking part in Chamber business, making it much harder to fulfil both parliamentary responsibilities. These changes would also leave us less time in the morning to prepare; I really need those hours in the morning. Preparing Questions, speeches and amendments requires research, thought and consultation. Otherwise, we cannot prepare ourselves properly. Squeezing it into a shorter morning will not improve our scrutiny. Colleagues travelling from outside London would be particularly disadvantaged, as many speakers before me have noted. They already face long journeys, and the uncertainty of delayed or cancelled trains affects them. Earlier sittings would mean leaving home even earlier or travelling the night before, increasing accommodation costs for the taxpayer. And what would we gain? As many noble Lords have mentioned, an earlier start does not guarantee an earlier finish. The noble Lord, Lord Stoneham, mentioned 8.30 pm instead of 10 pm being meaningful but, as many noble Lords have mentioned, unless it is 6 pm instead of 10 pm, it is not very meaningful—an hour and a half at that time of the evening, when we cannot do anything else, is not meaningful. Many colleagues could still be unable to get home in the evening. Unless we also control the volume of business, we risk lengthening the parliamentary day, with greater demands on Members and staff alike. The Prime Minister has promised “the biggest rebalancing of power our country has ever seen”, yet these proposed changes risk pulling this House in precisely the opposite direction by making more London-centric. Personally, I do not have a dog in this fight, because I live three stops away from Parliament, but we need colleagues who live and work across the country. We need the knowledge and practical experience of Peers from the worlds of business, medicine, law, education and science. We will lose those things. Earlier sittings would make those professional commitments harder to maintain, and we would be poorer for losing that experience, as many noble Lords before me have mentioned. Working lunches and early-evening engagements matter, too. They give us the opportunity to hear directly from experts, charities and the people who are affected by our decisions. These meetings help us do our work properly. Nor do I see how earlier hours would help families. Colleagues with young children would have to leave home earlier and would still arrive back after bedtime. Where is the benefit for them? We also need to consider our doorkeepers. Many of them commute into London, and their concerns deserve our attention. We depend on them every day; their working lives matter, too. As we have said before, we have not heard their position on the changing of times. I care about the character of this House. We should not become a House of full-time professional politicians. Our strength lies in the knowledge we bring from various professions, communities and wider life experience. Our arrangements enable Members to continue their professional work while contributing to the work of this House. The role of this House is to scrutinise legislation, draw on the widest possible experience and enable colleagues from across the country to participate. I see no convincing case that changing our sitting hours to those proposed would help us achieve any of those aims. I therefore support our present arrangements.
Lord Moynihan of Chelsea (Con)
My Lords, I am a new boy, so I feel myself under the lash of my noble friend Lord Blencathra in speaking to this debate. But, having spent less than three years here so far—and probably having not many more than that to go if the age restrictions come into operation—I do not have any big fish to fry. So I can be somewhat objective in looking at this and just use my experience from elsewhere to see whether it is a good idea. All the same, I am hesitant to speak on this, especially as so many noble Lords have said so many good things about it. I hope I can add one or two small points. I had difficulty figuring out the system of the Lords. It is complicated. The Lords do a huge amount of different things and you have to work hard to understand the system and try to make yourself effective in it. But having figured it out, I have now adapted my lifestyle to the way in which the House works, and I find myself perhaps slightly more effective than I was when I first arrived. Some relatively small changes are now being offered to us, so we have to consider them; that is our situation. The complication is that we debated them already, in 2022. We seem to be adopting the Irish approach to referenda: if you do not vote the right way the first time, we will get you to vote again until you do. These are not huge changes. Are they important enough to oppose? I have thought about that quite hard, and I think that, yes, they should be, because they worsen things rather than better them, and they constitute a direction of travel that should be stopped right now, just as it was in 2022. Why do I say that? Well, in former times—perhaps I am one of the few here today to have been there to remember it, given my ancient position—age and outside experience were highly valued attributes in both Houses of this Parliament. It is probably artificial nostalgia to look back to those times and lament their greatness compared with now, but there were certainly some great politicians in those times, most of whom had age and widespread experience from outside these Houses. We have now taken a step to professionalise the other House. There is much lamenting, which I do not have to rehearse too lengthily, over what that greatly eloquent person, Dominic Cummings, called “PPE bluffers” coming straight out of university, going into some kind of spad work, eventually getting a seat at a fairly early age and staying as professional politicians all of their life. I am sorry if I am boring noble Lords on the other side. That professionalisation has not been for the good. I should not criticise the other House, so can say only what others have criticised its Members for: they are criticised for having very little non-political experience, for doing very little scrutiny and for seeing themselves as professional politicians who believe that for every problem there ought to be a law—“By the way, we know best”—so that laws proliferate and the country is regulated more and more. They are criticised for having form and not substance, and for doing slipshod work. That has been the outcome, according to these critics, of the professionalisation of the other House. Now we have a repeated attempt to do the same for the House of Lords and to move in that direction. The House of Lords is a part-time House for a reason, and its effectiveness as a revising Chamber is, I argue, unequalled around the world. As we have heard, people complain that there are about 800 Peers, but the vast number of them come in only when their experience is called upon—as other noble Lords have said—and they are an expense to the House of Lords only when they come in. Of those 800 part-time Peers, many have a hinterland, which means that we can call on a plethora of knowledge from them, and that makes us effective as a revising Chamber. It means knowledge of what really works in the real world, not of what works in theory in law. Anything that makes it more difficult to operate that general hinterland held by those Peers is bad for the effectiveness of this House. A hinterland needs access to the outside world to keep going. That access has to take place between 9 am and 5 pm, because that is when the rest of the world operates, so any hour that we take away from noble Peers’ access to the outside world between 9 am to 5 pm cuts off their access to reality. Every generation wants change. By no means should every change be resisted, but this change should be. Change for change’s sake is no benefit. As my noble friend Lord Moylan pointed out, we have not really heard any strong arguments on the benefits. As my noble friend Lord Redwood and other noble Lords have pointed out, there are multiple disbenefits. The change to the other House made it worse. Why should we want to have similar changes here, however small? Like any successful long-standing institution, the House of Lords has developed its way of working over many years—in fact, in our case, over many centuries. It has many odd and unique features, each of which has a reason, including the ones we are debating here today. That is why each is jealously guarded. Together, they make up an institution that is now, with the decline in scrutiny in the other House, more important than ever. We should stay as we are.
Lord Polak (Con)
My Lords, I too thank the noble Lord, Lord Ponsonby, for opening the debate with such patience, a quality he will clearly need because every noble Lord, I suspect, has an opinion—most of us have several—on this issue. It was a bit upsetting for me that we moved rooms, because I had planned to say—I will still say it—that it is appropriate to have this debate in the Moses Room. Moses knew a great deal about long sittings, for 40 years in the wilderness, and not once did anyone propose finishing at 8.30 pm. When he came down the mountain with the Ten Commandments—I have checked them very carefully—not one said, “Thou shalt sit at one o’clock on a Wednesday”. If it was good enough for Moses, it is certainly good enough for me. Of course, as has been said, we have been here before. In 2022, the committee consulted on this question. Here we are, just four years later, being asked again. I admire the persistence: it reminds me of my grandchildren asking whether they can stay up late. The answer does not change, but the arguments get more creative. Let me declare an interest, which opposes something that the noble Lord, Lord Stoneham, said, and is in support of my noble friend Lord Jamieson. My interest is that I like lunch. A 1 pm start is not a modest procedural tweak, it is an actual assault on one of the House’s oldest and most effective conventions. I shall explain. Much cross-party agreement has been reached over a bowl of soup in the building, many an amendment has been quietly withdrawn over the main course, and more than one Bill has been rescued by the pudding. Move the start to 1 pm and we lose not just a meal but possibly the most productive committee in the House. We are told that the reward is going to be finishing at 8.30 pm. I have nothing against going home early, especially when Liverpool are playing at 8 pm, but I have sat in this House long enough—11 years this week—to know that “normally around 8.30 pm” may be very optimistic indeed. A Bill does not get any shorter because we start and finish earlier. I do take seriously, of course, the case made about the staff of the House who look after us so well, and their well-being must be part of this decision, and I take seriously the argument that late nights are not family friendly, although I gently observe that for a good number of noble Lords, getting home in time for bedtime is less about the children’s bedtime than about our own. I turn to the consultation itself. It offers four options. Three of them change or literally tinker, and one of them does not. As a conservative, I found that the choice makes itself. The present arrangements are not perfect—nothing in this place or any place is perfect—but they work. They let Members bring the outside world into the Chamber in the afternoon, having been out in it in the morning. If it is not broken, do not fix it. If it is a little bit broken, please do not fix it either at 1 pm or at 8.30 pm. I finish by following the words of my noble friend Lady Laing. Who is demanding these changes? If you join a gym, a choir or a golf club, you know that there are certain rules. Much as many people at a golf club might want to start on the fifth tee or wear collarless T-shirts, you have joined the club, you know the rules. When new Members come here to our House, they know the rules and the regulations, and they know what they are signing up to. I am all for change and modernisation where that is appropriate, but I fail to understand, as other noble Lords have said, how some of these changes being discussed will help our deliberations and our effectiveness. Where in fact are those people wanting changes? The noble Lord, Lord Ponsonby, has given us an opportunity to discuss. It is a bit like the assisted dying Bill and those debates we had every Friday. There was a vow of silence from those who supported the Bill, who then accused those with opposing views of wasting time by advancing arguments and putting forward amendments. I ask: where are those people today who are proposing these changes?
Lord Udny-Lister (Con)
My Lords, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Ponsonby, for giving us the opportunity to discuss and debate this. I am against the proposals to alter the sitting times of the House. Like everybody else—certainly a large number, anyway—I caution noble Lords that reform, particularly when void of evidence, does not always result in any improvement. The House is, much to my regret, becoming increasingly overpopulated exclusively by professional, full-time politicians. We should be mindful of the fact that the strength of this House has always been vested in its ability to be a House of experience and expertise, made up of men and women who have led businesses, commanded our Armed Forces, conducted our foreign affairs, practised medicine and the law, served in local government and academia, and contributed eminently to civil society. We should therefore be encouraging these people of lived experience to participate fully, not making it harder, and I fear that any of the options that have been touted thus far will do just that. As has already been said, the question before us should be not, “How can we make the House of Lords a more convenient place for us to work?”, but, “How can we ensure that it remains an effective place in which we are able to scrutinise and hold the Government of the day to account, on behalf of the British people?”. Earlier sitting times will exclude Peers who wish—or, in most professional cases, need—to continue to practise their profession. A lawyer who is required in court, a surgeon who operates in the mornings or a business leader running a company in the City should not be disadvantaged from participation in this place simply because they cannot conform to what is increasingly becoming a rigid parliamentary timetable. The more we make the membership of this place a full-time parliamentary occupation, the greater the danger of creating a metro-focused political class that is entirely detached from the realities, communities and professions that we are constitutionally assembled to understand. I fear that the constant attempts to tinker with and modernise the Lords are turning us from a House of working experience into a home for experienced politicians looking for work. Your Lordships’ House is not a conventional workplace. It is certainly not the House of Commons and should never be seen as such, for our constitutional value in this House lies precisely in being different and adaptable. It is absolutely inconsistent to appoint people to this place in recognition of their achievements beyond the Westminster machine, only then to reorganise ourselves in such a way that they are increasingly expected to abandon the activities from which they accumulate their knowledge and experience. The value in this House is not in how closely we can replicate the professional trappings of the Commons but in how effective we can be at being something, and offering something, different. Our operating hours reflect the responsibilities of your Lordships’ legislative and scrutiny functions as opposed to simply replicating, for nothing more than convenience, the working patterns and convenience of the wider Whitehall estate. I further put it to your Lordships that there is a fundamental constitutional principle at stake here. The Government of the day should not be permitted to determine the intensity, convenience or effectiveness of the scrutiny to which they are subjected. It is not the responsibility of this House to organise itself around the convenience of Whitehall and Ministers. The Government have a constitutional responsibility to make themselves available to Parliament. There is a real danger of this House increasingly becoming an administrative department of the Executive and simply processing legislation. In changing our sitting times, there is an inherent risk that we are, through the back door, surrendering the institutional independence and practical work of this place. Before bringing in any changes to the sitting hours of the House, noble Lords should carefully consider whether earlier starting times may directly disadvantage noble Lords travelling from outside London—this point has been made, but it is an extremely important one. The proposal to start our sittings earlier in the day risks establishing two classes of parliamentarian: those whose lives revolve around Westminster; and those whose lives continue to contribute to the country beyond it. We must be careful to avoid creating a situation by which London residency becomes the unofficial qualification for the effective membership of your Lordships’ House. Further, the union of nations is constantly going through incredible strain, and we must therefore make sure that any changes to sitting times do not inadvertently make it impossible for Peers travelling from Scotland, Wales or Northern Ireland to participate properly. We have to strongly consider the union in everything we do. Like other noble Lords, I have witnessed late-night sittings and how some of the most important scrutiny occurs when a debate is allowed to develop, Ministers are pushed and this House refuses to be hurried. Sadly, we are developing a culture here by which the tyranny of the parliamentary clock and the predicted finishing times are discouraging the level of scrutiny that your Lordships’ House was once admired for the world over. The more we seek to make this House resemble the other place in its working practices and professional character, the harder it will be to argue and explain why a House elected by political patronage should be here. We should therefore preserve our distinctiveness as the layman legislators of expertise because it is that distinctiveness which helps justify our very existence. I would go further and say that if we are going down this rather slippery slope, and this is not the only example of that, of diminishing the standing of this House in pursuit of, I am afraid I am going to call it political gimmickry, Whitehall conformity, perhaps it is only a matter of time before the Government will announce the establishment of the House of Lords North to complement the much-vaunted and costly No 10. North. Whatever our differences, I hope that the Committee can at least unite to discourage anyone from entertaining any such ambition, especially as it did not end well for the last person to move government to the north of England, Henry I: he died of dysentery as a result.
Lord Goddard of Stockport (LD)
My Lords, for clarification, as with the end-of-life Bill, I am speaking in a personal capacity. The Liberal Democrats have a free vote on this; clearly the Conservatives have a different view. That is for them to determine. I have to say, listening to the arguments today for the Opposition, I am surprised that there is no one here from the Labour Party. The Labour Party has obviously learned from other occasions that it pays to keep their powder dry. At the end of the day, whatever the outcome of this, the usual channels will meet, it will come to the House and there will be a free vote in the House of Lords. That is where this will be determined eventually. It will not be determined by a Committee or who has made the best speech at any given time. I come at this from a different angle. I am now the Chief Whip for the Liberal Democrats and have already, on a number of occasions, had to accompany elderly female Members from this House through Carriage Gates at past 2 am to put them in a taxi home. When we are in this House, we are protected. We have armed guards and doorkeepers, but at midnight, 1 am or 2 am you are on your own outside. As I am speaking personally, I am not going to reflect on the speakers. That would not be fair because they do not have the right to reply. One thing I would say is that when we sit late now, there are arrangements for the doorkeepers to take taxis home. Taxis do not take Members of the House home after late night sittings; we make our own way home. That may be something we should be looking at as well. I sit down with proposed new Members and they ask: when do you sit and what do you do? When you tell them that we sit at 2.30 pm, 3 pm and 11 am, they ask why on earth we do that. That is tradition, history, the value of the House of Lords. That is our problem; we are living in the past. Modernisation is coming. The world is changing, and the membership of this house is changing radically. I know that from experience because the Liberal Democrats from, say, 2014-15 to 2020 plus had no new Peers as because of the number of our MPs we did not qualify, so I have an older group of Members proportionate to our numbers, and that brings its own challenges. We are getting newer MPs through the allowances and other parties are getting the same. They look at this place and wonder what is going on. Yes, we have the expertise and knowledge—and yes, we sit—but we are not a dining club or a meeting place. The idea that you can change government policy over a bowl of soup is frankly for the birds. We are here to do business, to hold the Government to account and to make legislation better. I cannot understand how anybody could argue that that is best done past 10 pm, 11 pm or 12 am. This is my opinion. I am saying that, by these modest changes, we can begin to bring things into line with the rest of the world, basically. I do not know of any companies that run the sort of hours that we do. People say, “What is the future of us? We are different. We are somehow superior”. We are not. We are not insular; we all come from somewhere. We all have families and speak to people. We read the newspapers. It is not as if we have to be available to meet somebody who comes in to tell us that something is going wrong in America or somewhere else. I know that information; I pick it up myself. If I do not have time to prepare for a speech in the morning, that is my fault for not getting up early enough. If I do not get into bed until 3 am, that makes it more difficult for me. If we do nothing, somebody will do something to us eventually. It will be a Government of whatever persuasion, because at the moment legislation is coming thick and fast. It is difficult to do, but everyone in Committee or at Report stage does their best. Nobody is here to stop anything; we are here to hold the Government to account and they can speak for themselves. I am here speaking as an independent Liberal Democrat Peer who comes from Stockport. I stay every week: I come down on Monday and go home Thursday or Friday. The hours really do not matter to me, but they do matter to other people. There are other people of a certain age. As time goes on in the evening, it becomes more difficult to concentrate and to participate meaningfully. The House should be able to allow everybody to participate meaningfully whenever they want and whenever they can. It must be better for the House if those hours are made more regular. I will be voting for these changes. This is the beginning of modernisation. If the legislation for the age limit comes in at 80, everybody will know what that means for the House. That is the point I am trying to make today: change is coming. We should embrace it and should not resist it. We are not Luddites. We should be more modern and be thinking forward. We should be putting some of the ancient traditions to one side, because we are in the 21st century now, and we should act like that.
Lord Jamieson (Con)
I just want to make a point of clarification because both noble Lords opposite have referred to a free vote or whatever. Let us be clear that Conservatives, as in all constitutional matters, have a free vote and we have all spoken of our own position.
Lord Goddard of Stockport (LD)
I see that not one of you in the Conservative Party has a different view.
The Senior Deputy Speaker (Lord Ponsonby of Shulbrede)
My Lords, this has been, regretfully, a fairly unbalanced debate. We had two speeches in favour of the proposals, and everyone else has spoken against it. As noble Lords know, I have been to the Association of Conservative Peers and to the Liberal Democrats, and I will be going to the Crossbench Peers next week. I can say that there is a diversity of views within each group. My understanding of the position is that none of the political parties is putting forward a collective view, and it will be for individuals to vote as they wish. I want to make a couple of opening comments. As was noted by the noble Lord, Lord Blencathra, I have been around this House for a long time. However, I have had a whole career outside this House. My whole working life was in a completely different world, the oil and gas world, where I worked as an engineer. But I came in here fairly frequently to participate as and when I could. I have also been a magistrate for 22 years and I have spoken about that in the House many times. I will be sitting as a magistrate tomorrow, for example. One point that no noble Lord has made, which I was reminded of by the speech of the noble Lord, Lord Udny-Lister, is that councillors sit in the evening when they are considering local government matters. I was a councillor when the noble Lord was the leader of Wandsworth Council. So it is not exceptional; it is the way in which councils work up and down the country. Having made those comments, I am of course neutral on this issue and will do my best to address some of the points made by noble Lords, starting with the noble Lord, Lord Redwood. All the points he made will be considered by the PPC. I take his point about the importance of championing the work skills of Members of this House; it is very important. The House of Lords has one role in life: to be different from the House of Commons. It justifies its existence by its expertise and the quality of the work that it produces. I agree with the points the noble Lord made. The noble Lord, Lord Stoneham, made the fundamental point that the 8.30 pm stop is ultimately a question of the usual channels and self-regulation. The Chief Whip was here and heard those noble Lords who have had direct experience of working in the usual channels. It is right to say that there will be an expectation of a stop unless there are particular circumstances; we will see. It will be for the PPC to set up a review period if it wishes to see whether any new regulations that are brought in are operating as expected. The noble Lord, Lord Moylan, made a fair point about his medical appointments. That is not a point you often hear in these debates, but it is very fair. The trade unions have been informed. They are certainly aware of this, and the speeches from today’s debate will be formally fed into the process. I acknowledge the points made by the noble Lord, Lord Blencathra, who expressed his views fully, as he usually does. It will be for the PPC to look at this. The additional information about the consultations and the effect on working practices will be available to the PPC when it makes its final recommendation. That information will also be available to the House when it considers whatever recommendation may come out of the PPC.
Lord Blencathra (Con)
It is reassuring that the PPC will have that information but, in the meantime, 800 Peers have been asked to make a decision, to tick a box for Tuesdays, Wednesdays or both, without knowing that information in advance. The consultation may result in an overwhelming majority wanting a change, but then the PPC will get the information about what the changes might be, leaving Peers in the dark as to the consequences as we make our decision now, if that makes sense.
The Senior Deputy Speaker (Lord Ponsonby of Shulbrede)
With the greatest respect for the noble Lord, noble Lords are not making a decision now. They have responded to a consultation, and it was not just a tick box; they were able to write more than that. Nevertheless, I take the point the noble Lord makes. It is certainly my earnest hope that the PPC and subsequently the House will be as well informed as possible when they look at the issues. It is encouraging that we have had 360 responses as of yesterday. That is a huge improvement on the last time this matter was considered. The noble Baroness, Lady Laing, made a couple of particularly pertinent points. There will be a breakdown of responses regarding claimed expenses and overnight expenses; it will not be specifically on the address, but it will be on those two factors. That will be part of the analysis as presented to the PPC. There will also be an analysis of how often the respondent actually sits in the House; that will be part of the analysis as well. It will not identify individuals but, for example, if a Member sits on 10 days in a Session, that will be identified in the data presented to the PPC. I hope that that addresses the points she made. The noble Baroness, Lady Lawlor, spoke about compromises and trade-offs for sitting patterns. Well, here we are, having a consultation on exactly that. I do not know whether she was sitting in on Oral Questions earlier today, but a noble Lord behind me was saying that these changes are far too modest. Nevertheless, that is what is on the table right now, and that is the basis on which we are having this consultation. The noble Lord, Lord Jamieson, said that it is a modest change, but he questioned whether it would affect the quality of legislation. Again, if appropriate, the PPC would have a trial period for six months, a year or something like that to see whether any changes should be kept. The noble Baroness, Lady Meyer, asked, “What problem are we trying to solve?” The answer to that is that we all want to do a good job. I see my primary role as making the House of Lords do the best job it possibly can. I have been defending the House of Lords for many years, and I defend it not on the grounds of who we are but on the grounds of what we do. We need to maintain the quality of what we do, both in the scrutiny of public law but also in all the Select Committees. That is the essential reason for the existence of this Chamber; maintaining that quality must be uppermost in anyone’s considerations. Have I missed anybody out? I am not sure. Nevertheless, this has been an interesting debate. As I said, it will be taken account of by the PPC.
Motion agreed.
Committee adjourned at 2.32 pm.
Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5423197.