T

The Senior Deputy Speaker (Lord Ponsonby of Shulbrede)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 22 October 2026

Debate

Sitting Times of the House

Contribution

With the greatest respect for the noble Lord, noble Lords are not making a decision now. They have responded to a consultation, and it was not just a tick box; they were able to write more than that. Nevertheless, I take the point the noble Lord makes. It is certainly my earnest hope that the PPC and subsequently the House will be as well informed as possible when they look at the issues. It is encouraging that we have had 360 responses as of yesterday. That is a huge improvement on the last time this matter was considered. The noble Baroness, Lady Laing, made a couple of particularly pertinent points. There will be a breakdown of responses regarding claimed expenses and overnight expenses; it will not be specifically on the address, but it will be on those two factors. That will be part of the analysis as presented to the PPC. There will also be an analysis of how often the respondent actually sits in the House; that will be part of the analysis as well. It will not identify individuals but, for example, if a Member sits on 10 days in a Session, that will be identified in the data presented to the PPC. I hope that that addresses the points she made. The noble Baroness, Lady Lawlor, spoke about compromises and trade-offs for sitting patterns. Well, here we are, having a consultation on exactly that. I do not know whether she was sitting in on Oral Questions earlier today, but a noble Lord behind me was saying that these changes are far too modest. Nevertheless, that is what is on the table right now, and that is the basis on which we are having this consultation. The noble Lord, Lord Jamieson, said that it is a modest change, but he questioned whether it would affect the quality of legislation. Again, if appropriate, the PPC would have a trial period for six months, a year or something like that to see whether any changes should be kept. The noble Baroness, Lady Meyer, asked, “What problem are we trying to solve?” The answer to that is that we all want to do a good job. I see my primary role as making the House of Lords do the best job it possibly can. I have been defending the House of Lords for many years, and I defend it not on the grounds of who we are but on the grounds of what we do. We need to maintain the quality of what we do, both in the scrutiny of public law but also in all the Select Committees. That is the essential reason for the existence of this Chamber; maintaining that quality must be uppermost in anyone’s considerations. Have I missed anybody out? I am not sure. Nevertheless, this has been an interesting debate. As I said, it will be taken account of by the PPC.

More from The Senior Deputy Speaker (Lord Ponsonby of Shulbrede)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.