Contribution
I thought it was 25 years. Of course, they are absolutely neutral in this debate, but I suspect that they agree with what I am saying, although they cannot acknowledge that.
Since July 2024, 122 new peerages have been created. Almost 80 of those Members are relatively new to parliamentary life and have inevitably had less opportunity to experience the detailed workings of Lords committees, legislative scrutiny and parliamentary procedure. I make no criticism of those colleagues. However, when evaluating changes of long-term constitutional significance, greater weight should naturally be attached to those with extensive operational experience, rather than new Peers who were just sworn in the last few months and have never served on any committees.
I turn to the family-friendly argument. I have heard that phrase repeated over the years, but family-friendly for whom? Even in the Commons, a 7 pm finish never meant that Members automatically got home in time to read the kiddies their bedtime stories. Many were still travelling across London or much further afield. The children were often asleep before they arrived home.
Whatever force that argument once had in the Commons, it has little relevance here. The average age of the House is around 71. We are primarily not a House of parents rushing home to supervise homework. There is, however, one respectable argument. An earlier finish might permit Peers and their spouses or partners to participate more fully in civic, charitable, social or cultural life. That argument has some merit, but it is not what is being proposed. If we were talking about finishing at 6.30 pm or 7 pm, one could understand it—one could do those things—but 8.30 pm is neither fish nor fowl. It is too late for most evening engagements and too early to justify sacrificing the advantages of the current arrangements. What exactly can most people do at 8.30 pm that they cannot do at 10 pm? The answer is, “Very little”, and who would benefit from an earlier finish? This consultation is London-centric. Only London-based Members or those within the M25 would get home at night. All of us other, provincial Peers will have to retreat to our luxurious London hotels, costing £125 per night. That is not acceptable.
One of the greatest strengths of the House of Lords is that it is not a full-time legislature. Indeed, our value lies precisely in the fact that many Members do not spend all day inside Westminster. The Chamber is an extraordinary national asset. Within it sit former Cabinet Ministers, ambassadors, judges, surgeons, scientists, engineers, military commanders, intelligence chiefs, academics, vice-chancellors, entrepreneurs, business leaders, charity founders and leaders of faith communities. We do not possess all this expertise despite our outside experience; we possess it because of our outside experience.
As my noble friend Lord Moylan pointed out, many Members continue to serve on public bodies; they chair inquiries, lead charities, practise professions, advise industries and remain connected to the real world beyond Westminster. That connection enriches every debate we have. It brings reality into legislation. It brings experience into scrutiny and expertise into public policy. The present sitting pattern accommodates that contribution. An earlier start inevitably places pressure on it.
Supporters describe this as a modest procedural change. I suggest that it is far more significant than that. It nudges the House towards becoming a more conventional full-time legislature. I fear for the Cross-Benchers in particular. I disagree with how they vote most of the time but, nevertheless, they are a unique feature of this House. Their authority rests upon not party organisation but professional achievement and specialised knowledge. If parliamentary business increasingly crowds out the external activities from which that expertise derives, we risk weakening one of the most valuable components of this Chamber. Experience is evidence and the House must give it proper weight.
I turn now to a crucial point: our role in scrutiny. The House of Lords performs an increasingly important revising role. Successive Governments have relied on this House to identify defects, improve drafting and correct omissions that escape adequate scrutiny elsewhere. The constitutional value of the House of Lords lies primarily in the quality of our scrutiny. Any reform, therefore, should be judged by one simple test: will it improve scrutiny? Twiddling with the start and finishing times by 90 minutes a day will do nothing for improving the scrutiny and quality of primary legislation or statutory instruments; that can be done only with major procedural changes to deal with the way that we handle primary and secondary legislation.
The changes that would really improve scrutiny include: giving many more draft Bills pre-legislative scrutiny; the Government tabling more draft affirmative SIs; the power for the Lords to amend SIs; greatly reduced numbers of Henry VIII clauses and Bills; no more skeleton legislation where Bills have little substance but many regulation-making powers; and then hidden regulation via guidance that has to be obeyed but does not go through Parliament. These are some of the changes which would really improve parliamentary scrutiny but, of course, they are not on offer just now—and never will be, because no Government will ever give us those powers. I say this to the noble Lord, Lord Stoneham: the only thing that would improve parliamentary scrutiny is those changes, not an extra 90 minutes in the day or an early start.
Some say that an earlier start and finish might persuade more Peers to turn up and vote if the votes are not too late in the evening but, in response to the noble Lord, Lord Stoneham, 20 more Peers voting is not increased scrutiny. It may mean 20 more speeches in Parliament, of course, but no persuasive evidence that finishing at 8.30 pm instead of 10 pm will improve scrutiny is being produced. Indeed, there are strong grounds for believing that the proposed changes may create new pressures without delivering any corresponding benefits.
I move on to our overnight allowance. We rightly get our travel refunded, an untaxed daily allowance and, now, an untaxed overnight stay allowance—which is pitifully inadequate, in my opinion, but that is another matter. However, I sometimes hear Peers at the Lord Speaker’s forum calling for an increase in some allowances. The Lord Speaker and others point out that these things must be agreed with the Inland Revenue, which rigorously polices the justification for any non-taxed allowance. What might the Inland Revenue say when we tell it that we still want the overnight stay allowance agreed for when we finish at 10 pm, but that now we may finish at 8.30 pm? We might be on dangerous ground with our overnight allowance, and it could affect scores of Peers who may then be considered capable of getting home to places well outside the M25. We cannot make this change without consulting and having firm evidence about what the Inland Revenue might say or do.
I turn to the point about dining together, another issue which troubles me greatly. Many people—including, I think, the noble Lord, Lord Stoneham—regard dining together as irrelevant; they regard it as a social activity. I regard it as a constitutional asset of this House. This House works because Members encounter one another outside formal proceedings. We argue in the Chamber and we continue discussion over lunch, tea or dinner. Political opponents sit together; Cross-Benchers sit with party politicians. Relationships develop, misunderstandings are resolved and consensus becomes possible. That is partly why our Select Committee reports are often unanimous, and it is why debate here remains remarkably civil compared with so many other legislatures. The Long Table tradition is not a curiosity; it is a mechanism through which Parliament functions better.
Some other countries understand this. I have researched it and found that other parliamentary systems have recognised the same principle. Examples include Iceland’s Althing, Sweden’s Riksdag and the Federal Palace in Bern, Switzerland. Although none of these exactly replicates the Long Table tradition, they have introduced a system whereby their members can sit together to eat, drink and speak informally. At a time when democracies across Europe are becoming increasingly polarised, why should we deliberately weaken one of the institutions that helps preserve civility and mutual respect?
I will not say much on the staff consultation because my noble friend Lord Moylan has already done so, but the staff have not been properly consulted on this. If they have been, we should see what they have said before we come to tick the boxes on this rather shoddy form.
This debate is not really about whether we start at 1 pm or 2.30 pm. It is about what sort of institution we want this House to be. Do we want a House characterised by expertise, experience, scrutiny, independence and collegiality, or do we want to gradually become another version of the House of Commons? I know which House I was proud to join in 2011, and which House I wish to preserve. For that reason, I oppose these proposals.