B

Baroness Laing of Elderslie (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 22 October 2026

Debate

Sitting Times of the House

Contribution

My Lords, what a pleasure it is to follow the excellent speech of my noble friend Lord Blencathra, who has just about said it all. I will make three short points but, before doing so, I thank the Senior Deputy Speaker for bringing forward this debate and giving your Lordships the opportunity to participate in this consultation. My first point is about the consultation. I was very disappointed, when filling it in, to note that we are not asked to identify where we live and go home to when this House rises in the evening. There is a huge difference between someone who lives within walking distance, someone who lives an hour away on public transport and someone who lives in Scotland, Devon, Wales or Yorkshire. The difference is enormous, and this consultation would have been a lot more meaningful—I hope the Senior Deputy Speaker does not mind my making this point directly to him—if it were divided into responses from people who live in different places. I therefore challenge whether the results of this consultation are valid at all, given that that distinction has not been made. Secondly, I turn to the question of the nature of this House. Being a Member of the House of Lords is not a job; it is public service. I am sure that all noble Lords present in this room are proud to say that they carry out a public service. We must not pretend that we are doing a normal nine-to-five job because that is not what it is about. As my noble friend Lord Blencathra so eloquently said, we need people in this House who bring expertise and experience from every walk of life, not just those who have retired from their main career, but those who are still working in their main career. That is what gives this place its exceptional and unusual value. Therefore, we have to sit at times which accommodate other professions, jobs or other requirements in people’s lives, and that includes being family friendly. There are not many Members of your Lordships’ House who as a parliamentarian have given birth to a child and brought up that child, hopefully safely, to adulthood while being a full-time parliamentarian, but I have, and I can tell noble Lords that it is the flexibility of our hours that matters. It is not when we begin and when we end; it is the flexibility so that you can carry out your family duties as well as your parliamentary duties. The idea that stopping at 8.30 pm would in fact be more family friendly is, I am afraid, nonsense. My noble friend Lord Blencathra has made all the points about the importance of the way in which we interact with one another. This is not a normal place of work. This is a Parli-a-ment. It is a place where people come to talk to one another, to interact with one another. The fact that we sit outside normal working hours is a vital part of that. Thirdly, I turn to the idea that 8.30 pm could be a normal rising time because that is what this consultation proposes. The fact is that 8.30 pm is neither one thing nor another. It is not early enough to carry out our family obligations or social obligations or even to go to the theatre or anything else that one might want to do of an evening. It is too late for that, but it is not early enough to take up the whole evening. If you have come all the way from Devon or Scotland and you want to spend your three full working days in this place, you are going to waste an awful lot of time after 8.30 pm because then nothing can really be usefully done. I also say to your Lordships that the idea of normally rising at 8.30 pm is a fiction. I ask your Lordships: what actually is the problem that this consultation and proposal is trying to solve? What is the question that needs to be answered? I suggest that the problem that appears to have arisen is that new Members have come to Parliament unaware of how Parliament actually works. They have been horrified to discover that they are expected to be here to defend the Government’s majority until late at night, and therefore they have complained. I suggest that, if we were to put these proposals into action, they would not solve that problem. Normally rising at 8.30 pm would not mean that we would rise at 8.30 pm. I put it to your Lordships that that is not the problem; the problem is that too many people speak for too long and too often. I dare to suggest to your Lordships, within earshot of the Government Chief Whip, that what we really need in order to have a more efficient and effective House, is time limits on speeches and a formal end to proceedings at 10 pm, a rule that we stop at 10 pm unless, in exceptional circumstances, the House votes not to do so and to go past 10 pm. I know that your Lordships will say to me, “Don’t you understand that this is a self-regulating House and therefore time limits on speeches could not possibly be imposed and could not possibly work?” Well, I think that is also a fiction. I am relatively new to this House, and I have been astounded at the patience that your Lordships show in their self-regulation for those who speak for much longer than is necessary. We do not need to change the sitting hours; we need to be more self-aware, we need to be more disciplined, and we need to be more considerate of others. I dare your Lordships to give consideration to the possibility of a formal stop at 10 pm and real time limits to speeches that must be observed. I promised myself that with a 15-minute limit, I would speak for less than 10, so I had better stop at 8 minutes and 42 seconds. Some 30 years of participation in parliamentary debates has taught me that that which can be said in 20 minutes can usually be said far more effectively in 10, and I have spoken for 8 minutes and 56 seconds.

More from Baroness Laing of Elderslie (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.