Contribution
My Lords, it is a pleasure to follow my noble friend Lady Laing of Elderslie. I thank the Senior Deputy Speaker for bringing this debate and for all the thought and neutrality he has bought today and previously.
The sitting hours of this House are a compromise which fit no individual’s way of life perfectly. Rather, in order to contribute to its work, we all have to adjust our lives to them, often making complicated arrangements which, over time, have come to work smoothly. This is one important reason why we should be circumspect about making changes. Any change will come with a considerable cost to everyone and in upset to the established patterns of the lives that they have framed to meet the many different commitments they may have in addition to the work of this House. Any such change would need to bring a great deal of extra good before it outweighed the harm.
In fact, the change now proposed—starting and finishing earlier on two days—will be damaging in itself, undoing our finely balanced compromise. On the first level, that compromise is between the need to have enough sitting hours for, on the one hand, the Government’s business and the House’s business and, on the other, the demands of noble Lords’ lives. On the second level, the compromise is between the different sorts of demands. There are three main types. First, many Members are engaged in professions or work apart from their functions here. As has been said today, and as we all recognise, this is one of the central features of this House, which gathers mainly not professional politicians—although we do benefit from them—but all kinds of people, including experts of different kinds from different walks of life. Many are engaged with their specialist area of expertise, be it the law, business, medicine, the media, universities, the sciences or humanities, local government or the voluntary and charitable sector.
Secondly, there are demands that relate more directly to the business of the House: careful preparation for Bills; committee meetings; contributions; and, for some, ministerial duties. Thirdly, there are the demands of family and social life, which also came up in the previous consultation and which might include parenting, grandparenting and other caring duties.
The new proposals ostensibly concern a compromise between the different sorts of demand. Given the number of sitting hours needed, the first of these demands—to balance the work that we do for this House and the work that we do outside, perhaps, or our preparations for this House—can be met by the present sitting hours. It leaves a good part of the working day on Mondays, Tuesdays and Wednesdays to do that work, prepare and so on. It also leaves time for all the other demands because, on Thursdays, Fridays, Saturdays and Sundays, we have time for them. It is a compromise, but it allows for the different sorts of activity, specialism and preparation.
Those proposing change may not agree. Some may think that the compromise should be weighted more towards family and social life than it is at present. I disagree with that. Most people bearing equivalent responsibilities outside, in other jobs, have to accommodate family and caring commitments. They have to accommodate them with their professional work and obligations. Even if noble Lords are no longer working outside our House, they will have had to do so during their working life.
In any case, as noble Lords have already said, the proposed change to 8.30 pm on Tuesdays and Wednesdays will not achieve the objective sought. If the House rises at 8.30 pm, noble Lords might, if they are lucky, be home at 9.15 pm or 9.30 pm at the earliest, if they live nearby. However, for many of us, as has been mentioned—I am an example of it—if your commute is at least two hours, and sometimes longer when the trains do not work, an 8.30 pm finish will allow no one a social or family life. For many of us, an 8.30 pm finish will still mean that we will be lucky to be home by 11 pm if the trains run.
I say to the noble Lord that it is not only the last trains that tend to be cancelled; some days, all trains are cancelled after, say, 6 pm because of a problem on the line or something else. The noble Lord mentioned that it would be easier to travel by train if we left earlier, because we would be more certain of getting home, but, with the way transport is, I do not think that we would. Anyway, I do not believe that an 8.30 pm change will make any great difference to the demands that we have.
There is also reason to fear that the new proposals will adjust things just for the first level of compromise by increasing our total number of sitting hours, leaving us with less time for anything else—work or social—since the Tuesday and Wednesday sessions proposed, if we take both days, are being made three and a half hours earlier in all, while only three hours is planned to be trimmed at the end. More seriously, it is hard to believe that an 8.30 pm finishing time will in fact mean an 8.30 pm finish. I enjoy the repartee—and feel that it was probably true—where the Whips get together and agree that it is how to keep their Members there for the important votes. It will not necessarily make government business any easier to get through. I do not agree that it would be less likely to stop a drift from 8.30 onwards to finishing a little later.
I say in response to the noble Lord, Lord Stoneham, that I see what he is getting at when he says that there will be dwindling numbers and that he does not like to see them. An 8.30 pm finish will make no difference to that. People are here late at night, in Committee on a Bill or in a Second Reading debate, because they have expertise, interest and specialism and are involved. They will be there for the 8.30 pm sitting as much as they are there now. It will not make a difference. It reflects their specialism, experience and involvement in different subjects where they want to help with the scrutiny, particularly because they can contribute. I still see them there last thing at night; in fact, there is quite a camaraderie when the last groups of amendments are called. People stay to contribute if they are interested and knowledgeable about the subject.
In my view, the proposed changes will do harm and not produce the desired results. Most importantly, the work of this House will suffer if sitting times prevent Members preparing properly and exclude them from professional activities that allow this Chamber to scrutinise, do the work it does and fulfil its important role in a bicameral system. I therefore oppose any change.