B

Baroness Lawlor (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 14 October 2026

Debate

UK and Poland: Security and Defence Partnership

Contribution

It is a pleasure to follow the noble Baroness, Lady Anelay. I too add my thanks to those of others to our excellent staff, committee officials and the chairman, who led our deliberations on this and other matters with intelligence, impartiality and a great deal of humour. This helped to bring very serious matters to a very amicable conclusion. As noble Lords have heard, this treaty prompted a number of questions during our deliberations. As the Minister knows by now, some are as yet unresolved. I refer to two in particular; they have been mentioned but I hope to bring something else to them. First, the treaty seeks to do too much. It commits not merely to security and defence but to other, arguably more distant, aims. Some of them, such as economic resilience, are uncontentious; the noble Lord, Lord Johnson, referred to the potential collaboration on weapons systems, and we hope also for collaborations on platforms, which can only be a good thing. Others are a little more contentious, such as energy and climate security. Indeed, the treaty was described during our sessions as something of a Christmas tree—one on which the Government have agreed to hang a number of attractive decorations—and this phrase recurred a few times. We may wonder whether, in thus signalling their flagship priorities, the Government have the means, ability, will and resources to fund and provide them? In seeking to do so much—perhaps too much—the treaty may end up doing too little. Without adequate funding, a treaty such as this could seem like a hollow gesture. What cannot be ignored—this has been mentioned by other noble Lords not only here but in the Chamber—is the fact that, so often, the UK’s security is in a perilous position, with its Army and naval resources being so depleted. As the noble Lord, Lord Dannatt, warned only last year in respect of the UK potentially leading a peacekeeping mission in Ukraine, the UK’s resources are “so run down” that it could not lead any future peacekeeping mission in Ukraine as 40,000 UK troops would be needed for such a mission. He said: “We just haven’t got that number available”. I put it to the Minister that he could perhaps seek reassurance from his colleagues in defence. The second problematic aspect of the treaty is even more fundamental, to my mind. As has been mentioned: is it necessary? The noble Lord, Lord Johnson, referred to two agreements that have already been signed with Poland in the past decade; this one adds a third. The Government have made a political choice to have a new treaty, rather than beefing up an older one—perhaps the 2023 declaration—and enhancing its status. A choice has also been made to expand the scope to economic resilience, energy and climate security. Indeed, since 2024, the Government have reached a number of bilateral security agreements, understandings and partnerships. In doing so, have they debased the currency by pursuing their explicit policy aim of strengthening their links with European allies? My concerns are these. The Explanatory Memorandum says: “The Government is entering into this Treaty to strengthen the UK’s partnership with Poland … at a time of sustained geopolitical challenge”. As we have heard, both parties are members of NATO and bound by Article 5, which says that, in the event of “an armed attack against one or more of them”, the parties are obliged to assist each other, whether they are attacked individually or collectively, “in concert with the other Parties”. I simply repeat: does Article 2(5) of this treaty add anything of significance to that? There is something of “me too” about that article; I would like to be assured that that is not the case. That leads me to think that either this treaty accomplishes nothing here or our expectations may be raised by a bilateral commitment over and above the existing obligations to Poland as a NATO member under the 1949 North Atlantic Treaty. If it is the latter, is there a danger of spreading UK general good will so widely that its resources are not devoted to the safety of ourselves, our islands and the people of this country? No single area of government policy is more important than UK defence and security, and that of its people. Since the 2024 elections, we have seen a number of other Europe-focused bilateral security treaties, one with France and one with Germany, and an announcement of a UK security and defence partnership with the EU last year. Whether the UK-Poland one will amount to anything other than what was described in our sessions as high-level discussions without adequate focused funding remains to be seen. Of course, the UK is not alone in pursuing such bilateral agreements but, on defence, I have two points to make. This seems to put the emphasis on the Europeanisation of defence, despite the reality that the UK is a trading nation and head of the Commonwealth, with global interests, global responsibilities and alliances and global reach. It also complicates arrangements for defence, bringing potential complications and consequences. Professor Mark Webber of the University of Birmingham, who is also senior non-resident fellow of the NATO Defence College in Rome points out: “Bilateralism of this sort adds to the complexity of Europe’s defence provision. Three tiers are now evident—the multilateral (involving NATO and increasingly the EU), the regional (with initiatives such as the British-led Joint Expeditionary Force), and the bilateral. These trends add up to a Europeanisation of defence—even within NATO, where the United States is stepping back”. My conclusion is that this treaty may suffer, and indeed does suffer, from a danger of overreach—of trying to achieve too many disparate aims, some unconnected with security. It is also superfluous in part, coinciding with existing NATO commitments. Is it pointing to the Europeanisation of defence, and is that in the best interests of the UK and its global reach?

More from Baroness Lawlor (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.