Contribution
My Lords, the noble Lord, Lord Hannay, ended by correctly explaining that, although some reports of Select Committees can be very long and important, the shorter ones can also be essential. The way he described our relationship with Poland, and the history behind it, makes it very clear indeed why we felt so strongly about the importance of being able to carry this treaty forward. My noble friend Lord Johnson of Lainston, the chair, can take complex issues and make them seem simple but important, and I am grateful to him for his speech today. I also thank the clerk of our Select Committee—he may be sitting here in the Grand Committee, but we are allowed to say whether he is—and his team for the extremely good work they do for us and for their enduring patience with us.
Our report makes it clear that we welcome the treaty as a recognition of Poland’s crucial role in the Euro-Atlantic security architecture, against a background of increasing security threats and in the light of a return of warfare to the European continent and of Russian aggression. I am of a generation that grew up thinking that could never happen again, but it has. As my noble friend Lord Johnson pointed out, our report concludes that the treaty is, however, basically high level and general in nature on a range of issues. The treaty lacks substance and detail to support its provisions.
I shall focus on two aspects of the treaty: hybrid threats and the importance of NATO. A significant part of the treaty relates to joint efforts to counter hybrid threats. Poland has faced repeated challenges caused by such attacks. Just last month, Poland’s Deputy Prime Minister, Krzysztof Gawkowski, was quoted by the BBC as saying that the fire at a Starlink station in the Masovian Voivodeship, which, of course, includes Warsaw, was
“deliberately designed to disable the station … disrupting internet access for various institutions, including the Ukrainian army”.
He added that “many indications suggest” the attack fits into a
“new Russian doctrine of attack”.
Last year, I went to Warsaw to represent the European Affairs Committee at the EU’s inter-parliamentary conference on the common foreign and security policy and the common security and defence policy. Our debate today gives me the opportunity to put on record, for the first time, my thanks to both Anna Clunes, who was then our excellent ambassador to Poland, and our military attaché for their private briefings about security threats and our co-operation with our Polish allies. I found their detailed briefing on hybrid attacks particularly illuminating, as it appears to forecast the future.
It is welcome that, accompanying the treaty, there is a list of 14 landmark projects to be delivered by the UK and Poland. They include plans to create a co-operation agreement to counter hybrid threats, which should support the efforts of the UK and Poland to disrupt malign actors, plus a new UK-Poland counter-hybrid working group to co-ordinate our joint working—that is essential. They also include commitments to work with our military and civilian arms to respond to cyber threats, of which we have seen several across Europe recently.
Such information sharing and joint responses could of course further strengthen the UK’s ability to detect cyber threats, hostile interference and attacks on critical infrastructure. However, the landmark projects are non-binding on the UK and Poland. They also lack specific timelines for delivery, as our chair said. Our committee was simply told by Minister Doughty, in a letter to us on 21 July this year, that
“the Landmark Projects are intended to turn that ambition into tangible activity and outcomes in the near term”.
Today, I invite the Minister, the noble Lord, Lord Wood —who is responding to this debate—to give assurances that “near term” means putting the projects into effect as soon as the ratification procedures are completed. We should be ready, willing and able to do so.
I turn to references to NATO in the UK-Poland treaty. Article 2(4) provides that
“the Parties reaffirm their commitment to NATO as the foundation of their collective defence, and to their obligations … in the North Atlantic Treaty … in particular Article 5”,
to which the noble Lord, Lord Hannay, referred. However, when Minister Doughty gave evidence to our committee on 30 June, I found his presentation both somewhat confused and confusing. The noble Lord, Lord Hannay, asked him the very important question as to whether the Minister did
“not feel any concern that by saying it complements and strengthens Article 5 of NATO, it casts some doubt on the validity of Article 5”.
Minister Doughty’s answer to the noble Lord seemed to confirm—I emphasise “seemed”—that the Government were indeed adding commitments to the UK-Poland treaty that would go beyond Article 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty. He was not clear in his evidence that any use of military force in response to an armed attack would take place within the NATO framework. Our report therefore asks the Government, as a matter of urgency, to clarify whether Article 2(5) of the UK-Poland treaty creates any commitment in addition to those under Article 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty. I would be grateful if the Minister could clarify this important matter today.
Ultimately, the long-term success of the treaty depends on turning the framework into substantive action. That will depend on adequate funding, strong departmental co-operation, practical implementation and accountability. I look forward to hearing the Minister’s response.