L

Lord Hannay of Chiswick (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 14 October 2026

Debate

UK and Poland: Security and Defence Partnership

Contribution

My Lords, the security agreement between the UK and Poland, which we are debating and which has been so ably introduced by our chair, the noble Lord, Lord Johnson, has been firmly supported by your Lordships’ International Agreements Committee, of which I have the honour to be a member. I hope that this support will receive backing in this debate, enabling the agreement to go forward for early ratification. The agreement is an ancillary one, in the sense that both parties to it are firm members of the Atlantic alliance and committed by Article 5 of the NATO treaty to come to the collective defence of its members if one or several of them are attacked. From all the evidence we took on this agreement, there was no suggestion that the Article 5 commitment is undermined or contradicted, or that there risks being confusion of responsibility as a result of it. What is lacking in the agreement, however, is any real degree of specificity—the chair of our committee made that point several times during his speech. There was no specificity about how the parties to it will put flesh on the bones of their broad commitments. That remains to be defined and to be effected. That it should be so in a meaningful and operationally convincing way is essential if the agreement is not to remain just words on paper. I would be grateful if the Minister, in replying to this debate, could give an assurance that this follow-up is already in hand and under way. Yesterday, the Warsaw Security Forum met. The Foreign Secretary was present at it and presumably had a good deal to say on matters that were relevant to this agreement—as others there would have, such as the Norwegian Foreign Minister, the German Foreign Minister and, of course, the Polish Foreign Minister. I would be grateful if the Minister could give us some sense of how that meeting went and where it took matters to. Another essential feature is that an agreement such as this has to enjoy wholehearted cross-party support. Without that, its implementation will always be at risk. Judging from this debate, that cross-party support would seem to be assured in this country. We were told in our sessions with witnesses that that would seem to be the case in Poland too. Does that correspond to the Government’s information? Perhaps the Minister could give us a word or two on that. It is sometimes said that those who ignore or overlook history are fated to repeat it. Well, Anglo-Polish security co-operation is not an empty book. In 1939, this country gave Poland a firm guarantee of support in the event of an attack. We were then unable to validate that following the Molotov-Ribbentrop pact and the aggression against Poland and the Baltic states committed by Hitler’s Germany and Stalin’s Soviet Union. The main price was paid by Poland and the millions of Poles who lost their lives. We have a tendency to forget that dismal failure on our part, overlaid as it is by the memories of ending the war that ensued on the winning side and without being occupied. The Poles were neither. That memory should underlie the lively debate we are having here on our fulfilment of our commitments to NATO targets for defence spending. I do not intend to make a party-political point, because the sole purpose of agreements such as this is to deter effectively any potential enemy; it is not to wage a war but to deter anyone from having a war. We will not succeed in doing that if we obviously fall short of the targets that have been set by NATO and our own Government for defence spending. The 1939 story is as much about failed deterrence as it is about the failure of mutual support when aggression was committed. Does that story hold any parallels now? Not exact ones, but Russia’s aggression against Ukraine and its subsequent cyber and covert attacks must be a real concern to us all, and particularly to Poland, which is so much closer to the front line than us. I argue that there is much more to this debate than the words on paper in the report and the agreement before us today. I hope the Minister will address some of that when he replies.

More from Lord Hannay of Chiswick (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.