L

Lord Hannay of Chiswick (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 20 October 2026

Debate

EU, Euratom and UK Agreement on Gibraltar

Contribution

My Lords, this is the first occasion on which I have had the honour to follow the noble Lord, Lord Redwood, in the speakers’ list, and I can assure him that his contribution today will go straight into the fiction part of my library. I congratulate the noble Lord, Lord Barrow, on standing in at rather short notice for the Chair of his committee and on introducing this report so comprehensively and ably. I need to begin my contribution with a declaration, not of interest, as I have none, but of involvement. In 1982, when I was Assistant Under-Secretary of State at the FCO with responsibility for relations with the European Communities, I was tasked by Lord Hurd of Westwell, then Minister of State, with trying to bring about the opening of the border between Spain and Gibraltar, closed many years earlier by General Franco as part of his campaign to subvert our sovereignty over Gibraltar. I was asked to do this before any Spanish treaty of accession then being negotiated was brought before the House of Commons for ratification. After a number of detailed discussions with the then Chief Minister of Gibraltar, Sir Joshua Hassan, whose successor but several I welcome to our audience—I wish the previous speaker had shown a little greater respect for the views of Gibraltarians—and after many meetings with my opposite numbers in Madrid in charge of Spain’s accession negotiations, a basis for lifting the Spanish border closure was established ahead of the ratification of its accession agreement. The result was a resumption of large daily border crossings by Spanish workers with jobs in Gibraltar and, eventually, the arrangements for Gibraltar airport to give access to both Spain and Gibraltar. These arrangements have operated ever since, to the mutual benefit of the UK, Gibraltar, the EU and Spain, although on only an increasingly shaky legal basis since the UK left the EU in 2019. It is their replacement by a properly constituted and negotiated agreement between the EU and the UK that we are debating today, and I hope that we will it give broad support. Since the 1980s, much water has flowed under many bridges, but the essentials have not changed. Most importantly, the Brexit vote in 2016 created an anomalous and aberrant outcome. The UK as a whole voted to leave the EU by a small margin, and the Gibraltarians voted by 99% to remain in the EU. In effect, that UK vote removed Gibraltar from the EU, since its inclusion was derived only from being a European territory which was part of a member state. If ever there was a case for separate and special treatment, this is surely it. Otherwise, what weight are we giving to our quite rightly reiterated view that Gibraltarians should have a real say over their own destiny? Since Brexit, the Governments of the UK and the EU, with Spain having a key voice, have been negotiating a viable solution. The present Chief Minister of Gibraltar, Mr Fabian Picardo, who is among us today, and successive —quite a few—British Governments and Spanish ones have negotiated with great perseverance and determination. As a member of the All-Party Parliamentary Group on Gibraltar, I can bear testimony to that, since the Government of Gibraltar have been meticulous at keeping us informed. The agreement before us today is the outcome of those negotiations. Has anything had to be conceded over sovereignty or other matters of crucial importance to reach the complex arrangements for handling Schengen and customs union issues? I do not believe so, nor do Gibraltar’s Government and its assembly, which have endorsed what has been negotiated. I hope we can lend our support to them through this debate and through the Government’s subsequent ratification. What could be the consequence of the UK not ratifying and rejecting the agreement reached, which, of course, this Committee does not have the right to recommend anyway? We have some idea of that because of our experience during General Franco’s closure of the border. It would be very costly. It was some hundreds of millions of pounds in the 1970s and no doubt a great deal more now. There would also be difficulties for our defence arrangements in Gibraltar, which are fully safeguarded by the present agreement—both points raised by the noble Lord, Lord Redwood. I would argue that considerations of principle and of practice point us towards supporting the agreement wholeheartedly, as I do.

More from Lord Hannay of Chiswick (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.